Menu
05/10/2001
Appeal Court rules Sinn Féin meeting ban illegal
A bid by Ulster Unionist leader David Trimble to overturn a High Court ruling that he acted illegally in banning Sinn Féin ministers from attending North South Ministerial meetings has failed.
In an Appeal Court ruling in Belfast on Friday October 5, Lord Chief Justice Carswell upheld a judgment made earlier this year that the Ulster Unionist party leader had acted unlawfully in preventing Sinn Féin ministers from attending North South Ministerial Council meetings.
Mr Trimble had imposed the ban on Minister for Education Mr Martin McGuinness and Minister for Health Ms Bairbre de Brún in an effort to pressurise the IRA into disarming.
The judge maintained Mr Trimble's reason for imposing the ban - that it was a bid to put pressure on the IRA to begin decommissioning - could not be accepted. Lord Chief Justice Carswell insisted on Friday that fostering north-south links was a crucial strand of the agreement.
"It must follow that as a matter of law it cannot be sustained as a valid exercise of that discretionary power," he said.
Sinn Féin Education Minister Martin McGuinness said: “This judgement should be the spur for the UUP to come back into the political process. They should end the politics of threat, walkout and ultimatum and work with the rest of us to make this process succeed.”
After the ruling Mr Trimble indicated that he was planning to appeal the judgment in the House of Lords.
In a one-line statement issued after the Court of Appeal's ruling, the Ulster Unionists confirmed that former First Minister had instructed his lawyers to advise on bringing a petition before the House of Lords' Appeal Committee. (AMcE)
In an Appeal Court ruling in Belfast on Friday October 5, Lord Chief Justice Carswell upheld a judgment made earlier this year that the Ulster Unionist party leader had acted unlawfully in preventing Sinn Féin ministers from attending North South Ministerial Council meetings.
Mr Trimble had imposed the ban on Minister for Education Mr Martin McGuinness and Minister for Health Ms Bairbre de Brún in an effort to pressurise the IRA into disarming.
The judge maintained Mr Trimble's reason for imposing the ban - that it was a bid to put pressure on the IRA to begin decommissioning - could not be accepted. Lord Chief Justice Carswell insisted on Friday that fostering north-south links was a crucial strand of the agreement.
"It must follow that as a matter of law it cannot be sustained as a valid exercise of that discretionary power," he said.
Sinn Féin Education Minister Martin McGuinness said: “This judgement should be the spur for the UUP to come back into the political process. They should end the politics of threat, walkout and ultimatum and work with the rest of us to make this process succeed.”
After the ruling Mr Trimble indicated that he was planning to appeal the judgment in the House of Lords.
In a one-line statement issued after the Court of Appeal's ruling, the Ulster Unionists confirmed that former First Minister had instructed his lawyers to advise on bringing a petition before the House of Lords' Appeal Committee. (AMcE)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
15 October 2021
Poots Fails To Attend NSC Meeting On The Environment
A North-South Ministerial Council meeting on the environment has been unable to proceed after the DUP Environment Minister Edwin Poots failed to show up.
Poots Fails To Attend NSC Meeting On The Environment
A North-South Ministerial Council meeting on the environment has been unable to proceed after the DUP Environment Minister Edwin Poots failed to show up.
06 July 2010
Queen's Visit Raised At Farmleigh
The Stormont Minister Peter Robinson has said he hopes people would show the same respect to the British Queen during any visit to the Republic as he did to Irish President Mary McAleese yesterday.
Queen's Visit Raised At Farmleigh
The Stormont Minister Peter Robinson has said he hopes people would show the same respect to the British Queen during any visit to the Republic as he did to Irish President Mary McAleese yesterday.
06 July 2010
Face-Off On Health Cuts Battle
The Stormont Health Minister has been forced into a U-turn on taking part in an Executive 'away day'.
Face-Off On Health Cuts Battle
The Stormont Health Minister has been forced into a U-turn on taking part in an Executive 'away day'.
27 March 2024
SDLP Calls For Urgent Restoration Of North South Ministerial Council
The SDLP has called for the urgent restoration of the North South Ministerial Council (NSMC), which it said is needed to advance all-island cooperation following the restoration of the Stormont government earlier this year.
SDLP Calls For Urgent Restoration Of North South Ministerial Council
The SDLP has called for the urgent restoration of the North South Ministerial Council (NSMC), which it said is needed to advance all-island cooperation following the restoration of the Stormont government earlier this year.
27 October 2022
NI Health Service To Face 'Extremely Difficult Winter'
Northern Ireland's health and social care system is facing another extremely difficult winter, Health Minister Robin Swann has warned. The Minister made the warning as he updated MLAs on the winter resilience planning being undertaken across the system.
NI Health Service To Face 'Extremely Difficult Winter'
Northern Ireland's health and social care system is facing another extremely difficult winter, Health Minister Robin Swann has warned. The Minister made the warning as he updated MLAs on the winter resilience planning being undertaken across the system.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
