Menu
11/05/2011
Supreme Court Favours Jail Compensation
A Sinn Fein MLA and a Co Londonderry journalist have won the right to claim compensation for the time they spent in prison in the 1970s, wrongfully charged with murder.
The landmark ruling by the UK Supreme Court said the test for payments to those wrongfully convicted should be redefined.
Raymond McCartney and former Derry Journal reporter Eamonn MacDermott had two previous bids for compensation refused.
They took their case to the highest court in the United Kingdom and five of the nine judges on the panel found in the men's favour to claim compensation.
President of the Supreme Court, Lord Phillips, said the new test should ensure innocent defendants are not precluded from obtaining compensation because they cannot "prove their innocence beyond reasonable doubt".
The Supreme Court ruling could have implications for dozens of former prisoners in England, Wales and Northern Ireland and the Ministry of Justice said it welcomed the Supreme Court decision.
Raymond McCartney and Eamonn MacDermott were convicted of murdering RUC officer Patrick McNulty in Derry in 1977.
Mr McCartney was also found guilty of murdering DuPont Managing Director, Jeffrey Agate in the city a week later and spent 17 years in prison.
While in prison he became a 'commanding officer' for the IRA in the Maze and spent 53 days on hunger strike.
Eamonn MacDermott spent 15 years in prison, later working for the Derry Journal.
Speaking to the Journal after the judgement was handed down, Mr MacDermott said compensation couldn't give him back the years he lost in prison, but added that he felt "vindicated".
Mr MacDermott commented: "I think a lot of people find it very hard to believe that you could spend years in prison and not be entitled to some sort of compensation.
"I think this is the first time the Supreme Court has actually dealt with the question of what constitutes a miscarriage of justice, so it will be interesting to see what way they phrase it and what way they deal with it.
"How narrow or how broad the definition is remains to be seen."
Sinn Féin MLA Raymond McCartney also commented on the ruling and said that it was a "total vindication" of his and Mr McDermott's contention of innocence all along.
Mr McCartney commented: "It is also a heavy indictment of what passed for a policing and justice system in the North of Ireland throughout the conflict.
"After many years of campaigning and successfully challenging the judgement of the Northern Courts we were finally vindicated and the original findings were quashed.
"But even though the Courts here found in our favour, the vindictiveness of the British Establishment towards Irish Republicans could not handle the fact that its courts in effect found it guilty of a miscarriage of justice and the British Secretary of State refused an application for compensation.
"Now the highest Court in the British Judicial System has over ruled the political decision of the British SOS and totally vindicated our position," he said.
The Supreme Court ruling means people will receive statutory compensation under section 133 of the Criminal Justice Act 1988 if the Justice Secretary accepts that a new fact has so undermined the evidence against them "that no conviction could possibly be based upon the evidence in their cases".
Another man involved in the Supreme Court case on Tuesday, Andrew Adams, from Newcastle-upon-Tyne, who spent 14 years in jail after being wrongly convicted of murder, lost his appeal. The court found Mr Adams did not fall within this new definition.
(JG/BMcC)
The landmark ruling by the UK Supreme Court said the test for payments to those wrongfully convicted should be redefined.
Raymond McCartney and former Derry Journal reporter Eamonn MacDermott had two previous bids for compensation refused.
They took their case to the highest court in the United Kingdom and five of the nine judges on the panel found in the men's favour to claim compensation.
President of the Supreme Court, Lord Phillips, said the new test should ensure innocent defendants are not precluded from obtaining compensation because they cannot "prove their innocence beyond reasonable doubt".
The Supreme Court ruling could have implications for dozens of former prisoners in England, Wales and Northern Ireland and the Ministry of Justice said it welcomed the Supreme Court decision.
Raymond McCartney and Eamonn MacDermott were convicted of murdering RUC officer Patrick McNulty in Derry in 1977.
Mr McCartney was also found guilty of murdering DuPont Managing Director, Jeffrey Agate in the city a week later and spent 17 years in prison.
While in prison he became a 'commanding officer' for the IRA in the Maze and spent 53 days on hunger strike.
Eamonn MacDermott spent 15 years in prison, later working for the Derry Journal.
Speaking to the Journal after the judgement was handed down, Mr MacDermott said compensation couldn't give him back the years he lost in prison, but added that he felt "vindicated".
Mr MacDermott commented: "I think a lot of people find it very hard to believe that you could spend years in prison and not be entitled to some sort of compensation.
"I think this is the first time the Supreme Court has actually dealt with the question of what constitutes a miscarriage of justice, so it will be interesting to see what way they phrase it and what way they deal with it.
"How narrow or how broad the definition is remains to be seen."
Sinn Féin MLA Raymond McCartney also commented on the ruling and said that it was a "total vindication" of his and Mr McDermott's contention of innocence all along.
Mr McCartney commented: "It is also a heavy indictment of what passed for a policing and justice system in the North of Ireland throughout the conflict.
"After many years of campaigning and successfully challenging the judgement of the Northern Courts we were finally vindicated and the original findings were quashed.
"But even though the Courts here found in our favour, the vindictiveness of the British Establishment towards Irish Republicans could not handle the fact that its courts in effect found it guilty of a miscarriage of justice and the British Secretary of State refused an application for compensation.
"Now the highest Court in the British Judicial System has over ruled the political decision of the British SOS and totally vindicated our position," he said.
The Supreme Court ruling means people will receive statutory compensation under section 133 of the Criminal Justice Act 1988 if the Justice Secretary accepts that a new fact has so undermined the evidence against them "that no conviction could possibly be based upon the evidence in their cases".
Another man involved in the Supreme Court case on Tuesday, Andrew Adams, from Newcastle-upon-Tyne, who spent 14 years in jail after being wrongly convicted of murder, lost his appeal. The court found Mr Adams did not fall within this new definition.
(JG/BMcC)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
20 November 2024
Hydebank Wood Prison Praised For 'Model Of Excellence'
Justice Minister Naomi Long has hailed Hydebank Wood Secure College and Women's Prison as a "model of excellence and good practice" following the publication of two positive inspection reports.
Hydebank Wood Prison Praised For 'Model Of Excellence'
Justice Minister Naomi Long has hailed Hydebank Wood Secure College and Women's Prison as a "model of excellence and good practice" following the publication of two positive inspection reports.
06 December 2011
Wilson 'Overturns' Lords Asbestos Ruling
A crippling illness that has hit many people who were working in the construction industry is being tackled with new legislation on compensation. People suffering from the asbestos-related lung condition pleural plaques - usually contracted in the building sector - will be able to seek compensation from next week due to new legislation.
Wilson 'Overturns' Lords Asbestos Ruling
A crippling illness that has hit many people who were working in the construction industry is being tackled with new legislation on compensation. People suffering from the asbestos-related lung condition pleural plaques - usually contracted in the building sector - will be able to seek compensation from next week due to new legislation.
27 April 2011
Freed Rape Suspect Sought Over Kilkeel Killing
A foreign national who embarrassed officials when he was freed by mistake from a high security jail in Co Antrim last autumn is being sought over a shock Co Down murder.
Freed Rape Suspect Sought Over Kilkeel Killing
A foreign national who embarrassed officials when he was freed by mistake from a high security jail in Co Antrim last autumn is being sought over a shock Co Down murder.
24 November 2022
PM Urged To Set Out Criteria For Unity Referendum
Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has been urged to set out the criteria for a referendum on Irish unity in the interests of 'democratic transparency'.
PM Urged To Set Out Criteria For Unity Referendum
Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has been urged to set out the criteria for a referendum on Irish unity in the interests of 'democratic transparency'.
10 October 2018
Ashers Bakery Wins Supreme Court Appeal
The Christian owners of a Northern Ireland bakery have won their Supreme Court appeal in the so-called 'gay cake' discrimination case, a decision that has divided politicians. The UK's highest court ruled today that Asher's bakery was not discriminating against a customer when it refused to make a cake with the slogan "Support Gay Marriage" on it.
Ashers Bakery Wins Supreme Court Appeal
The Christian owners of a Northern Ireland bakery have won their Supreme Court appeal in the so-called 'gay cake' discrimination case, a decision that has divided politicians. The UK's highest court ruled today that Asher's bakery was not discriminating against a customer when it refused to make a cake with the slogan "Support Gay Marriage" on it.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
