Menu
25/05/2012
Murder Prisoner "Wrongly Convicted", Appeal Court Hears
A man who is in jail for the killing of two soldiers was wrongly convicted of murder, the Court of Appeal has heard.
Lawyers acting on behalf of terminally ill Brian Shivers, 46, are trying to overturn his conviction.
Shivers was told he would serve at least 25 years in prison for his part in the murders of Sappers Mark Quinsey (23) and Patrick Azimkar (21), both shot dead by the Real IRA in March 2009.
But Shivers's lawyer claimed that it was legally impossible for him to have been found guilty as the ruling was based on his conduct after the attack and could not prove actus reus – a criminal act.
Shivers was found guilty on the strength of DNA evidence linking him to a partially burnt-out getaway car used in the attack at Massereene Barracks.
Patrick O'Connor QC argued: "These were appalling offences which caused immense loss and suffering to the victims and families. Nothing we say can, nor is intended to, detract from that. The actus reus must be an act of aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring. The prosecution never suggested a single act which could amount to aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring."
Terence Mooney QC, prosecuting, responded: "Having said 'Yes, I will be there', that is an act as much as any other in the sequence that allowed the gunmen to escape."
Lord Chief Justice Sir Declan Morgan, sitting with Lord Justices Higgins and Girvan, reserved judgment.
Sir Morgan said: "There are some delicate matters here that we want to look at very carefully."
(NE)
Lawyers acting on behalf of terminally ill Brian Shivers, 46, are trying to overturn his conviction.
Shivers was told he would serve at least 25 years in prison for his part in the murders of Sappers Mark Quinsey (23) and Patrick Azimkar (21), both shot dead by the Real IRA in March 2009.
But Shivers's lawyer claimed that it was legally impossible for him to have been found guilty as the ruling was based on his conduct after the attack and could not prove actus reus – a criminal act.
Shivers was found guilty on the strength of DNA evidence linking him to a partially burnt-out getaway car used in the attack at Massereene Barracks.
Patrick O'Connor QC argued: "These were appalling offences which caused immense loss and suffering to the victims and families. Nothing we say can, nor is intended to, detract from that. The actus reus must be an act of aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring. The prosecution never suggested a single act which could amount to aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring."
Terence Mooney QC, prosecuting, responded: "Having said 'Yes, I will be there', that is an act as much as any other in the sequence that allowed the gunmen to escape."
Lord Chief Justice Sir Declan Morgan, sitting with Lord Justices Higgins and Girvan, reserved judgment.
Sir Morgan said: "There are some delicate matters here that we want to look at very carefully."
(NE)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
19 November 2024
Justice Minister Announces Additional Funding For Department
Justice Minister Naomi Long has welcomed the allocation of an additional £39.3 million to the Department of Justice following the October Monitoring Round. This funding will be used to address various pressures within the justice system, including those arising from the civil disorder during the summer.
Justice Minister Announces Additional Funding For Department
Justice Minister Naomi Long has welcomed the allocation of an additional £39.3 million to the Department of Justice following the October Monitoring Round. This funding will be used to address various pressures within the justice system, including those arising from the civil disorder during the summer.
16 January 2013
Massereene Murders: Retrial Confirmed
Brian Shivers is to face a retrial, following the overturning of his convictions for murdering two British soldiers at Massereene barracks in 2009. Northern Ireland's Court of Appeal has ordered the convictions against Shivers, 47, were unsafe.
Massereene Murders: Retrial Confirmed
Brian Shivers is to face a retrial, following the overturning of his convictions for murdering two British soldiers at Massereene barracks in 2009. Northern Ireland's Court of Appeal has ordered the convictions against Shivers, 47, were unsafe.
15 January 2013
Massereene Conviction Quashed
A man who was jailed for his part in the murder of two soldiers at Massereene Army base in Antrim has had his convictions overturned. 47-year-old Brian Shivers, from Magherafelt, has successfully challenged his convictions for the murders of Sappers Mark Quinsey, 23, and 21-year-old Patrick Azimkar in March 2009.
Massereene Conviction Quashed
A man who was jailed for his part in the murder of two soldiers at Massereene Army base in Antrim has had his convictions overturned. 47-year-old Brian Shivers, from Magherafelt, has successfully challenged his convictions for the murders of Sappers Mark Quinsey, 23, and 21-year-old Patrick Azimkar in March 2009.
13 April 2010
New Era Of NI Policing Begins
As the NI Policing Board welcomed devolution of the last powers to Stormont yesterday, the newly installed NI Justice Minister David Ford has said that his appointment heralds a new era.
New Era Of NI Policing Begins
As the NI Policing Board welcomed devolution of the last powers to Stormont yesterday, the newly installed NI Justice Minister David Ford has said that his appointment heralds a new era.
24 June 2024
Attempted Murder Investigation Launches In Ballygowan
An attempted murder investigation has been launched after shotgun pellets were fired into a house in Ballygowan on Saturday evening, 22 June. Police received a report that at around 11pm, a number of shotgun pellets were fired through the window of a house in the Brae Grove area, striking a woman in the head and her back.
Attempted Murder Investigation Launches In Ballygowan
An attempted murder investigation has been launched after shotgun pellets were fired into a house in Ballygowan on Saturday evening, 22 June. Police received a report that at around 11pm, a number of shotgun pellets were fired through the window of a house in the Brae Grove area, striking a woman in the head and her back.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
