Menu
12/11/2015
No Evidence Found Police Were Involved In Sectarian Attack
No evidence has been found to support concerns that police did not intervene to stop a sectarian attack in Coleraine in which one man died and a number of people were injured, the Police Ombudsman has concluded.
Kevin McDaid died after he was beaten in an attack in the Heights housing estate in Coleraine on 24 May 2009, the day of a Glasgow Rangers v Glasgow Celtic football match.
A number of other people suffered serious injuries in the incident.
Nine men received prison sentences for offences relating to Mr McDaid's death and the attack on others.
However, concerns were voiced that policing that day had not been robust, that some police officers had texted Loyalists earlier in an attempt to goad them into violence, and that officers did not intervene when these men launched an attack.
No evidence was found that police officers had texted a number of Loyalists.
Dr Maguire described the referral made to his Office about events that day as among the most serious which can be made. He said his team undertook a thorough, detailed and independent investigation of what happened.
Police Ombudsman staff conducted house-to-house inquiries to identify people who saw what happened. They recorded 120 witnesses' statements, from members of the public, from both sides of the community and from police. They examined all available CCTV coverage of the area and listened to all local police radio transmissions made from 12am until 12pm that day. They recovered and examined a number of mobile phones. All relevant police documentation, including the notebooks of police officers involved in the operation, were also examined.
Dr Maguire said: "All this material when taken together has allowed us to compile a detailed and independent picture of what happened.
"My investigation has found no evidence to suggest that police planning and actions that day were driven by anything other than a desire to prevent injury or damage to Coleraine and its citizens.
"Police did all that could be reasonably asked of them. The sole responsibility for what happened lies with those who attacked Mr McDaid and others in such a vicious way."
Dr Maguire said his investigators examined the mobile phones of the police officers who were dealing with events that day: "A forensic examination of these phones uncovered no evidence of any calls or text messages as alleged to those who were in a bar where Rangers supporters had been prior to the attack or to those who were subsequently arrested for it.
"There is clear evidence that police had made plans which were regularly reviewed. Each time there was a report of increased tension, police responded to it.
"From early afternoon police were talking to both sides and for several hours this seemed to be help contain things. They had neighbourhood police officers 'on the ground', police vehicles were patrolling the area and officers were watching the Bar on CCTV cameras. Police had planned for the possibility of trouble, particularly when the bars closed, with more officers to be put in place.
"Had they taken a more visible approach and put officers in riot gear onto the streets, police judged that this might have provoked the sort of trouble they were trying to avoid.
"The most direct route between where these men had been prior to the attack and the Heights estate was to use the main bridge across the River Bann.
"We have looked at the CCTV footage covering the period in question and can confirm that no large groups of people can be seen using the bridge prior to the attack.
"It was later established that those involved had not travelled in one group to the area and had taken different routes," said the Police Ombudsman.
(CD/JP)
Kevin McDaid died after he was beaten in an attack in the Heights housing estate in Coleraine on 24 May 2009, the day of a Glasgow Rangers v Glasgow Celtic football match.
A number of other people suffered serious injuries in the incident.
Nine men received prison sentences for offences relating to Mr McDaid's death and the attack on others.
However, concerns were voiced that policing that day had not been robust, that some police officers had texted Loyalists earlier in an attempt to goad them into violence, and that officers did not intervene when these men launched an attack.
No evidence was found that police officers had texted a number of Loyalists.
Dr Maguire described the referral made to his Office about events that day as among the most serious which can be made. He said his team undertook a thorough, detailed and independent investigation of what happened.
Police Ombudsman staff conducted house-to-house inquiries to identify people who saw what happened. They recorded 120 witnesses' statements, from members of the public, from both sides of the community and from police. They examined all available CCTV coverage of the area and listened to all local police radio transmissions made from 12am until 12pm that day. They recovered and examined a number of mobile phones. All relevant police documentation, including the notebooks of police officers involved in the operation, were also examined.
Dr Maguire said: "All this material when taken together has allowed us to compile a detailed and independent picture of what happened.
"My investigation has found no evidence to suggest that police planning and actions that day were driven by anything other than a desire to prevent injury or damage to Coleraine and its citizens.
"Police did all that could be reasonably asked of them. The sole responsibility for what happened lies with those who attacked Mr McDaid and others in such a vicious way."
Dr Maguire said his investigators examined the mobile phones of the police officers who were dealing with events that day: "A forensic examination of these phones uncovered no evidence of any calls or text messages as alleged to those who were in a bar where Rangers supporters had been prior to the attack or to those who were subsequently arrested for it.
"There is clear evidence that police had made plans which were regularly reviewed. Each time there was a report of increased tension, police responded to it.
"From early afternoon police were talking to both sides and for several hours this seemed to be help contain things. They had neighbourhood police officers 'on the ground', police vehicles were patrolling the area and officers were watching the Bar on CCTV cameras. Police had planned for the possibility of trouble, particularly when the bars closed, with more officers to be put in place.
"Had they taken a more visible approach and put officers in riot gear onto the streets, police judged that this might have provoked the sort of trouble they were trying to avoid.
"The most direct route between where these men had been prior to the attack and the Heights estate was to use the main bridge across the River Bann.
"We have looked at the CCTV footage covering the period in question and can confirm that no large groups of people can be seen using the bridge prior to the attack.
"It was later established that those involved had not travelled in one group to the area and had taken different routes," said the Police Ombudsman.
(CD/JP)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
23 June 2016
Police Officers Disciplined For Failing To Tell Doctor About Woman's Head Injuries
Two police officers have been disciplined after they failed to let their colleagues and a police doctor know that a woman had sustained a head injury, a Police Ombudsman investigation has concluded. The woman died from bleeding to the brain on 24 February 2014, the day after she suffered the injury.
Police Officers Disciplined For Failing To Tell Doctor About Woman's Head Injuries
Two police officers have been disciplined after they failed to let their colleagues and a police doctor know that a woman had sustained a head injury, a Police Ombudsman investigation has concluded. The woman died from bleeding to the brain on 24 February 2014, the day after she suffered the injury.
10 July 2013
Ardoyne Bomb Attack Targets Police
A bomb attack in north Belfast on Tuesday evening has been described as "a blatant attempt to kill or seriously injure police officers". Chief Inspector Andrew Freeburn said those who planted the bomb "showed callous disregard for the safety of the local community and police officers serving this community.
Ardoyne Bomb Attack Targets Police
A bomb attack in north Belfast on Tuesday evening has been described as "a blatant attempt to kill or seriously injure police officers". Chief Inspector Andrew Freeburn said those who planted the bomb "showed callous disregard for the safety of the local community and police officers serving this community.
14 December 2018
Police Disciplined Over Coleraine Pub Fight
PSNI failings compromised an investigation into off-duty police officers involved in a fight with members of the public, the Police Ombudsman has found.
Police Disciplined Over Coleraine Pub Fight
PSNI failings compromised an investigation into off-duty police officers involved in a fight with members of the public, the Police Ombudsman has found.
31 August 2012
Four Men Arrested For Dissident Activity
Four men have been arrested in Newtownabbey on suspicion of dissident republican activity. PSNI officers detained the men on Thursday evening aged 30,35 and 46. They are being questioned in Antrim police station.
Four Men Arrested For Dissident Activity
Four men have been arrested in Newtownabbey on suspicion of dissident republican activity. PSNI officers detained the men on Thursday evening aged 30,35 and 46. They are being questioned in Antrim police station.
29 April 2009
Hamill Inquiry Witnesses To Be Screened
The Robert Hamill Inquiry has ruled that witnesses who are serving or retired police officers may give their evidence from behind a screen. However, they will not be granted full anonymity. This ruling has been made in response to applications for such screening on behalf of a number of former or still serving police officers due to give evidence.
Hamill Inquiry Witnesses To Be Screened
The Robert Hamill Inquiry has ruled that witnesses who are serving or retired police officers may give their evidence from behind a screen. However, they will not be granted full anonymity. This ruling has been made in response to applications for such screening on behalf of a number of former or still serving police officers due to give evidence.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
