Menu
03/12/2003
Good Friday Agreement 'rethink' needed says analyst
With no early prospect of a return to power-sharing devolution expected in the wake of the Northern Ireland Assembly election, a timely paper by a Belfast policy analyst has called for a "rethink" in the context of the forthcoming review of the Good Friday Agreement.
The paper, `Northern Ireland: What’s Going Wrong?’, argues that, paradoxically, the 1998 agreement may have entrenched the divisions which are at the basis of the region’s conflict, thereby discouraging genuine reconciliation.
Published by the Institute of Governance, Public Policy and Social Research – an interdisciplinary centre of Queen’s University Belfast which brings together practitioners and researchers – the paper says that, while Northern Ireland has enjoyed a degree of peace since the paramilitary ceasefires of 1994, it is still a far from normal society.
The “parity of esteem” for nationalism and unionism which is central to the agreement has in effect conferred recognition and respectability upon sectarian political ideologies, the author, Robin Wilson, argued. In so doing, it may have inadvertently perpetuated mistrust and social tensions, and discouraged an atmosphere of compromise and political risk-taking.
Mr Wilson continued: "Whatever other advantages devolution brought to Northern Ireland under the terms of the Belfast Agreement of 1998, assuaging intercommunal tensions was not one of them. Indeed the continued sectarian polarisation of recent years has further corroded intercommunal trust, leading to repeated suspension of the institutions established in the wake of the Agreement.
“The paper argues that, far from offering a model to other ethnically divided societies as to how they might solve their problems, the Belfast Agreement looks backwards rather than forwards. An alternative, integrationist, approach is identified, based on a more contemporary understanding of identity as multiple, plastic and relational.”
Robin Wilson is a member of the board of the Institute of Governance and director of the think-tank Democratic Dialogue. Along with Professor Rick Wilford of the School of Politics and International Studies at Queen’s, he leads a team of researchers who have been monitoring the implementation of devolution in the region since 1999.
The agreement is due to be reviewed later this month, four years after coming into effect, and the paper outlines four modernising reforms which could be enacted to engender a more conciliatory atmosphere, to place power-sharing devolution on a stable footing, and to hold out the prospect of a normal society.
(MB)
The paper, `Northern Ireland: What’s Going Wrong?’, argues that, paradoxically, the 1998 agreement may have entrenched the divisions which are at the basis of the region’s conflict, thereby discouraging genuine reconciliation.
Published by the Institute of Governance, Public Policy and Social Research – an interdisciplinary centre of Queen’s University Belfast which brings together practitioners and researchers – the paper says that, while Northern Ireland has enjoyed a degree of peace since the paramilitary ceasefires of 1994, it is still a far from normal society.
The “parity of esteem” for nationalism and unionism which is central to the agreement has in effect conferred recognition and respectability upon sectarian political ideologies, the author, Robin Wilson, argued. In so doing, it may have inadvertently perpetuated mistrust and social tensions, and discouraged an atmosphere of compromise and political risk-taking.
Mr Wilson continued: "Whatever other advantages devolution brought to Northern Ireland under the terms of the Belfast Agreement of 1998, assuaging intercommunal tensions was not one of them. Indeed the continued sectarian polarisation of recent years has further corroded intercommunal trust, leading to repeated suspension of the institutions established in the wake of the Agreement.
“The paper argues that, far from offering a model to other ethnically divided societies as to how they might solve their problems, the Belfast Agreement looks backwards rather than forwards. An alternative, integrationist, approach is identified, based on a more contemporary understanding of identity as multiple, plastic and relational.”
Robin Wilson is a member of the board of the Institute of Governance and director of the think-tank Democratic Dialogue. Along with Professor Rick Wilford of the School of Politics and International Studies at Queen’s, he leads a team of researchers who have been monitoring the implementation of devolution in the region since 1999.
The agreement is due to be reviewed later this month, four years after coming into effect, and the paper outlines four modernising reforms which could be enacted to engender a more conciliatory atmosphere, to place power-sharing devolution on a stable footing, and to hold out the prospect of a normal society.
(MB)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
25 November 2024
DfI Outlines Congestion Mitigation Measures In Belfast City Centre
The Department for Infrastructure (DfI) has announced a series of measures aimed at alleviating traffic congestion in Belfast City Centre. A strategic oversight group, comprising the DfI, Belfast City Council, PSNI, and Translink, has been formed to identify and implement effective solutions to reduce peak-time delays.
DfI Outlines Congestion Mitigation Measures In Belfast City Centre
The Department for Infrastructure (DfI) has announced a series of measures aimed at alleviating traffic congestion in Belfast City Centre. A strategic oversight group, comprising the DfI, Belfast City Council, PSNI, and Translink, has been formed to identify and implement effective solutions to reduce peak-time delays.
25 November 2024
Man Arrested In Connection With £150,000 Cannabis Seizure
Detectives from the Police Service of Northern Ireland's Organised Crime Unit, in partnership with Belfast Harbour Police, have made a significant breakthrough in their fight against drug crime. On Friday evening, November 22nd, a vehicle was intercepted and searched in the West Bank Road area of north Belfast.
Man Arrested In Connection With £150,000 Cannabis Seizure
Detectives from the Police Service of Northern Ireland's Organised Crime Unit, in partnership with Belfast Harbour Police, have made a significant breakthrough in their fight against drug crime. On Friday evening, November 22nd, a vehicle was intercepted and searched in the West Bank Road area of north Belfast.
25 November 2024
Visit Belfast Celebrates 25 Years of Transforming Tourism Landscape
Visit Belfast, the city's dedicated Destination Marketing and Management Organisation (DMMO), is celebrating a quarter-century of success.
Visit Belfast Celebrates 25 Years of Transforming Tourism Landscape
Visit Belfast, the city's dedicated Destination Marketing and Management Organisation (DMMO), is celebrating a quarter-century of success.
22 November 2024
Other News In Brief
Appeal Following Arson In Newtownabbey PSNI detectives have issues an appeal for information following a report of arson endangering life at residential premises at the Dermont Way area of Newtownabbey.
Other News In Brief
Appeal Following Arson In Newtownabbey PSNI detectives have issues an appeal for information following a report of arson endangering life at residential premises at the Dermont Way area of Newtownabbey.
22 November 2024
Pedestrian Injured In Belfast Hit-and-Run
The PSNI have issued an appeal for information following a hit-and-run incident in the Botanic Avenue area of Belfast in the early hours of Thursday morning. Officers were called to the scene shortly before 1.30am after a male pedestrian was struck by a maroon Mazda. Despite being injured, the pedestrian left the area before police arrived.
Pedestrian Injured In Belfast Hit-and-Run
The PSNI have issued an appeal for information following a hit-and-run incident in the Botanic Avenue area of Belfast in the early hours of Thursday morning. Officers were called to the scene shortly before 1.30am after a male pedestrian was struck by a maroon Mazda. Despite being injured, the pedestrian left the area before police arrived.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A chilly start with a widespread frost and some freezing fog, any freezing fog slow to clear. Otherwise bright with sunny spells and coastal showers. Light winds. Maximum temperature 6 °C.Tonight:Coastal showers dying out with a widespread frost developing along with freezing fog, which could become extensive. Winds remaining light. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
