Menu
25/02/2022
Resolving Protocol Essential For Peace And Stability
The Protocol continues to divide opinion in Northern Ireland, but the majority agree that solving it is essential for peace and stability, according to a report from Queen's University Belfast (QUB).
The latest in a series of polls conducted for a research project at QUB shows opinion on the Protocol among voters in Northern Ireland continues to be deeply divided, with only a small portion of respondents having 'no opinion' on the topic.
Almost two-thirds of respondents (64%) indicate that they see a failure of the UK and EU to reach a solution to the outstanding issues regarding the Protocol as putting peace and stability at risk.
The greatest levels of concern relating to the Protocol's impact are for political stability; its economic impact is viewed by more respondents to be positive than negative.
Whilst opinions continue to be divided, the latest poll shows that 50% of respondents agreed, compared to 41% who disagreed.
Part of a three-year ESRC-funded research project on the Protocol on Ireland/Northern Ireland, this is the fourth in a series of surveys to 'temperature test' voter attitudes on a range of issues relating to Brexit, the Protocol, and their implications for Northern Ireland.
The poll was undertaken 4-7 February 2022, at the end of a significant week for politics in Northern Ireland centring upon the Protocol. It uses the LucidTalk Northern Ireland Online Opinion Panel and the results are from a weighted sample of 1516 respondents that is representative of the Northern Ireland voting population, including by age, area of residence and community.
While 7 out of 10 respondents believe that Northern Ireland does need specific arrangements to manage the effects of Brexit, opinions are divided on the Protocol itself. There is a narrow majority (51%) who see the Protocol as the appropriate means for managing the impact of Brexit on Northern Ireland with half (50%) seeing it as overall 'a good thing for Northern Ireland', with 40% disagreeing. 6 out of 10 respondents disagree that Brexit is overall 'a good thing' for the UK.
Comparison between this poll and the ones conducted in March, June and October 2021 shows that there has been a notable shift since summer 2021 towards greater acceptance of the Protocol. This is particularly evident in opinion on the economic effects of the Protocol. 48% see the Protocol as having a positive economic impact on Northern Ireland (whilst 43% see its economic impact as negative). And 63% agree that the Protocol provides Northern Ireland with a 'unique set of post-Brexit economic opportunities compared to the rest of the UK which if exploited could benefit Northern Ireland', whilst 26% disagree.
When asked about a set of issues identified by the UK Government as being problems with the Protocol, a clear majority (75%) of respondents continue to be concerned to maintain the existing availability of medicines into Northern Ireland, with the next greatest concern (66%) being the lack of involvement of Northern Ireland's elected representatives and NI civil society in the governance of the Protocol. Of least concern were the change in suppliers from GB to local or EU sources (47% unconcerned by this) and the role of the European Court of Justice in disputes over the Protocol (46% unconcerned).
The poll shows the significance of the Protocol for the upcoming Assembly election. 4 out of 5 respondents say they will vote for candidates who share their view on the Protocol. 43% say they will vote for candidates in favour of the full application of the Protocol; 37% say they will vote for candidates opposed. With respect to the democratic consent vote in 2024, 50% favour MLAs voting for the full application of the Protocol; 42% want MLAs to vote against.
Nevertheless, the Protocol is not the issue that currently causes most concern to most voters. More respondents (44%) ranked the Protocol among the three issues of least concern to them whilst one third (32%) ranked the Protocol among the three issues of most concern to them.
There remain high levels of distrust of those involved in managing the Protocol in Northern Ireland; most particularly so for the UK government (84% distrust and 4% trust the UK government). Levels of distrust in political parties to manage the interests of Northern Ireland with respect to the Protocol are generally higher than levels of trust in them to do so. The only actor trusted by the majority (59%) in this area continue to be NI business representatives.
Principal Investigator of the project, Professor David Phinnemore, Professor of European Politics at Queen's University Belfast, said: "This survey is an important live and evolving indication of the views and concerns of people in Northern Ireland in relation to the effects of the Protocol.
"Whilst opinion in Northern Ireland appears to be becoming more accepting of the Protocol and a growing proportion view its effects as positive, it is clear that there remain high levels of concern relating to the Protocol and its negative impacts, especially relating to political stability.
"This is particularly significant given that, thanks to the grace periods, the Protocol has not yet been fully implemented. Looking ahead, when it comes to any 'Protocol solutions', the building of trust and confidence across communities in Northern Ireland remains key for the UK, the EU and local politicians. Part of this will be addressing the issues that matter most to people here, such as medicines supply and NI having an effective 'voice' in the governance of the Protocol."
Co-investigator on the project, Professor Katy Hayward, Professor of Political Sociology at Queen's and Senior Fellow of the UK in a Changing Europe, noted: "This poll confirms what we know anecdotally, namely that there are strong opinions and concerns about the Protocol. But it also reveals an urgent need for greater information, knowledge and trust-building. Although 70% self-report having good understanding of the Protocol, the poll shows a majority bemoan a lack of reliable information on the subject (including in print or broadcast media) and they don't trust political actors or institutions in handling Northern Ireland's interests in this area. And, when tested, levels of knowledge of the Protocol are worryingly low.
"This underscores the urgent need for more accurate and honest presentations of what the Protocol does and does not cover, especially in the lead-up to an election in which it is likely to feature prominently and opinions about it will potentially become more strongly-held and more polarised."
The latest in a series of polls conducted for a research project at QUB shows opinion on the Protocol among voters in Northern Ireland continues to be deeply divided, with only a small portion of respondents having 'no opinion' on the topic.
Almost two-thirds of respondents (64%) indicate that they see a failure of the UK and EU to reach a solution to the outstanding issues regarding the Protocol as putting peace and stability at risk.
The greatest levels of concern relating to the Protocol's impact are for political stability; its economic impact is viewed by more respondents to be positive than negative.
Whilst opinions continue to be divided, the latest poll shows that 50% of respondents agreed, compared to 41% who disagreed.
Part of a three-year ESRC-funded research project on the Protocol on Ireland/Northern Ireland, this is the fourth in a series of surveys to 'temperature test' voter attitudes on a range of issues relating to Brexit, the Protocol, and their implications for Northern Ireland.
The poll was undertaken 4-7 February 2022, at the end of a significant week for politics in Northern Ireland centring upon the Protocol. It uses the LucidTalk Northern Ireland Online Opinion Panel and the results are from a weighted sample of 1516 respondents that is representative of the Northern Ireland voting population, including by age, area of residence and community.
While 7 out of 10 respondents believe that Northern Ireland does need specific arrangements to manage the effects of Brexit, opinions are divided on the Protocol itself. There is a narrow majority (51%) who see the Protocol as the appropriate means for managing the impact of Brexit on Northern Ireland with half (50%) seeing it as overall 'a good thing for Northern Ireland', with 40% disagreeing. 6 out of 10 respondents disagree that Brexit is overall 'a good thing' for the UK.
Comparison between this poll and the ones conducted in March, June and October 2021 shows that there has been a notable shift since summer 2021 towards greater acceptance of the Protocol. This is particularly evident in opinion on the economic effects of the Protocol. 48% see the Protocol as having a positive economic impact on Northern Ireland (whilst 43% see its economic impact as negative). And 63% agree that the Protocol provides Northern Ireland with a 'unique set of post-Brexit economic opportunities compared to the rest of the UK which if exploited could benefit Northern Ireland', whilst 26% disagree.
When asked about a set of issues identified by the UK Government as being problems with the Protocol, a clear majority (75%) of respondents continue to be concerned to maintain the existing availability of medicines into Northern Ireland, with the next greatest concern (66%) being the lack of involvement of Northern Ireland's elected representatives and NI civil society in the governance of the Protocol. Of least concern were the change in suppliers from GB to local or EU sources (47% unconcerned by this) and the role of the European Court of Justice in disputes over the Protocol (46% unconcerned).
The poll shows the significance of the Protocol for the upcoming Assembly election. 4 out of 5 respondents say they will vote for candidates who share their view on the Protocol. 43% say they will vote for candidates in favour of the full application of the Protocol; 37% say they will vote for candidates opposed. With respect to the democratic consent vote in 2024, 50% favour MLAs voting for the full application of the Protocol; 42% want MLAs to vote against.
Nevertheless, the Protocol is not the issue that currently causes most concern to most voters. More respondents (44%) ranked the Protocol among the three issues of least concern to them whilst one third (32%) ranked the Protocol among the three issues of most concern to them.
There remain high levels of distrust of those involved in managing the Protocol in Northern Ireland; most particularly so for the UK government (84% distrust and 4% trust the UK government). Levels of distrust in political parties to manage the interests of Northern Ireland with respect to the Protocol are generally higher than levels of trust in them to do so. The only actor trusted by the majority (59%) in this area continue to be NI business representatives.
Principal Investigator of the project, Professor David Phinnemore, Professor of European Politics at Queen's University Belfast, said: "This survey is an important live and evolving indication of the views and concerns of people in Northern Ireland in relation to the effects of the Protocol.
"Whilst opinion in Northern Ireland appears to be becoming more accepting of the Protocol and a growing proportion view its effects as positive, it is clear that there remain high levels of concern relating to the Protocol and its negative impacts, especially relating to political stability.
"This is particularly significant given that, thanks to the grace periods, the Protocol has not yet been fully implemented. Looking ahead, when it comes to any 'Protocol solutions', the building of trust and confidence across communities in Northern Ireland remains key for the UK, the EU and local politicians. Part of this will be addressing the issues that matter most to people here, such as medicines supply and NI having an effective 'voice' in the governance of the Protocol."
Co-investigator on the project, Professor Katy Hayward, Professor of Political Sociology at Queen's and Senior Fellow of the UK in a Changing Europe, noted: "This poll confirms what we know anecdotally, namely that there are strong opinions and concerns about the Protocol. But it also reveals an urgent need for greater information, knowledge and trust-building. Although 70% self-report having good understanding of the Protocol, the poll shows a majority bemoan a lack of reliable information on the subject (including in print or broadcast media) and they don't trust political actors or institutions in handling Northern Ireland's interests in this area. And, when tested, levels of knowledge of the Protocol are worryingly low.
"This underscores the urgent need for more accurate and honest presentations of what the Protocol does and does not cover, especially in the lead-up to an election in which it is likely to feature prominently and opinions about it will potentially become more strongly-held and more polarised."
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
15 July 2021
DUP Leader Sets Out 'Seven Tests' On NI Protocol
Sir Jeffrey Donaldson MP has set out Seven Tests for any new arrangements the Government would announce regarding the Northern Ireland Protocol. The DUP Leader said that these tests are "grounded not in a unionist wish list, but in promises that have already been made in one form or another, to the people of Northern Ireland".
DUP Leader Sets Out 'Seven Tests' On NI Protocol
Sir Jeffrey Donaldson MP has set out Seven Tests for any new arrangements the Government would announce regarding the Northern Ireland Protocol. The DUP Leader said that these tests are "grounded not in a unionist wish list, but in promises that have already been made in one form or another, to the people of Northern Ireland".
26 July 2021
Economy Minister Urged To Take Advantage Of Special Economic Circumstances
The Economy Minister must act to take advantage of the special economic circumstances the protocol affords businesses in the north.
Economy Minister Urged To Take Advantage Of Special Economic Circumstances
The Economy Minister must act to take advantage of the special economic circumstances the protocol affords businesses in the north.
10 June 2022
Protocol Has 'Failed Economically And Politically' – Donaldson
The Protocol has 'failed economically and politically', Sir Jeffrey Donaldson has told the House of Lords Northern Ireland Protocol Sub-Committee.
Protocol Has 'Failed Economically And Politically' – Donaldson
The Protocol has 'failed economically and politically', Sir Jeffrey Donaldson has told the House of Lords Northern Ireland Protocol Sub-Committee.
11 January 2022
Govt Urged To Outline Delivery Of Command Paper
The DUP has called on the government to set out a plan of how they intend to deliver imminently on their Command Paper. Party Leader Sir Jeffrey Donaldson made the call after meeting with the Foreign Secretary Liz Truss ahead of the latest round of talks between the EU and UK Government.
Govt Urged To Outline Delivery Of Command Paper
The DUP has called on the government to set out a plan of how they intend to deliver imminently on their Command Paper. Party Leader Sir Jeffrey Donaldson made the call after meeting with the Foreign Secretary Liz Truss ahead of the latest round of talks between the EU and UK Government.
28 September 2021
Unionist Parties Unite To Oppose NI Protocol
Northern Ireland's Unionist parties have joined forces to appose the Northern Ireland Protocol and call for it to be replaced with arrangements that fully respect NI's position as a constituent and integral part of the United Kingdom.
Unionist Parties Unite To Oppose NI Protocol
Northern Ireland's Unionist parties have joined forces to appose the Northern Ireland Protocol and call for it to be replaced with arrangements that fully respect NI's position as a constituent and integral part of the United Kingdom.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherThis Evening and Tonight:Rain clearing away east by early evening with some clear spells but a few showers likely to affect the North coast and other areas towards dawn, remaining breezy and mild overnight. Minimum temperature 9 °C.
