Menu
30/06/2022
Govt Urged To 'Be On The Side Of Justice'
The DUP has urged the government to "be on the side of justice and victims rather than perpetrators" as East Belfast MP Gavin Robinson outlined the party's opposition to the proposed Legacy Legislation.
Highlighting that the Northern Ireland peace process has too often taken the opposite approach, Mr Robinson said: "The past twenty-five years in Northern Ireland have been marked by a corruption of justice in the name of the peace and reconciliation. Shamefully, what began with immoral prisoner release schemes led to scant prison time for convicted terrorists and eventually to letters of comfort issued to so-called on the runs.
"The Democratic Unionist Party rejected each of these provisions and we continue to stand four-square behind the principle that everyone should be equal under - and equally subject to - the law. The flame of justice must be preserved. Access to justice must be protected. There can be no amnesty for wrongdoing and no rewriting of the past.
"Sadly, with the introduction of the Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Bill, the Government has fallen into the trap of believing that it would be best to simply draw a line under the issue of legacy and move on. This is a position that has been universally rejected by innocent victims and their advocates, as well as all political parties in Northern Ireland. It is an affront to justice.
"The Government's proposals would grant an amnesty for those responsible for Troubles-related crimes on the basis of a dubious information recovery scheme. This would create an equivalence between the terrorist who was intent only on bloodshed and the soldier or police officer who served our community with distinction. Such an outcome would be indefensible.
"We oppose this bill but since the Government is pressing ahead, we will be bringing forward amendments in a number of areas. To repeal the early release provisions of the Belfast Agreement, to prohibit anyone granted immunity from glorifying terrorism, allow immunity to be revoked, to establish larger fines for those who fail to cooperate and to ensure only innocent victims are treated as victims in any memorialisation strategy."
Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart added: "The DUP will be resisting, and voting against, the Bill at every available opportunity. We will also be seeking support from MPs to help limit the damage should the Government choose to steamroller through these provisions without the consent of communities in Northern Ireland.
"The drafting of this Bill is such that there would be absolutely no incentive for paramilitaries to engage. In fact, it would erase the two-year prison sentence an individual would have to serve if convicted for offences committed before 1998. There would also be minimal repercussions should anyone who chooses not to engage with the Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery - or indeed those who are proven to have lied - while those who have openly evaded the authorities for years would seemingly be able to reap the benefits of immunity.
"This will inevitably lead to a situation where terrorists who have openly evaded the authorities for years being able to retire in dignity. All the while a disproportionate focus would rest on the minority of state-related cases - for which a mountain of information exists and which we can assume would be meticulously provided to the information recovery process.
"Ultimately, anyone who broke the law should face the threat of prosecution and eventual conviction for their crimes. The law should apply equally and be applied without fear or favour. Nobody denies that the passage of time presents prosecutorial difficulties but the answer is not to arbitrarily close down legal routes for innocent victims. This holds implications for the integrity of the criminal justice system not just in Northern Ireland but across the United Kingdom. It wouldn't be tolerated for hate crime or gang crime. It shouldn't be deemed acceptable toward the victims of terrorism."
Highlighting that the Northern Ireland peace process has too often taken the opposite approach, Mr Robinson said: "The past twenty-five years in Northern Ireland have been marked by a corruption of justice in the name of the peace and reconciliation. Shamefully, what began with immoral prisoner release schemes led to scant prison time for convicted terrorists and eventually to letters of comfort issued to so-called on the runs.
"The Democratic Unionist Party rejected each of these provisions and we continue to stand four-square behind the principle that everyone should be equal under - and equally subject to - the law. The flame of justice must be preserved. Access to justice must be protected. There can be no amnesty for wrongdoing and no rewriting of the past.
"Sadly, with the introduction of the Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Bill, the Government has fallen into the trap of believing that it would be best to simply draw a line under the issue of legacy and move on. This is a position that has been universally rejected by innocent victims and their advocates, as well as all political parties in Northern Ireland. It is an affront to justice.
"The Government's proposals would grant an amnesty for those responsible for Troubles-related crimes on the basis of a dubious information recovery scheme. This would create an equivalence between the terrorist who was intent only on bloodshed and the soldier or police officer who served our community with distinction. Such an outcome would be indefensible.
"We oppose this bill but since the Government is pressing ahead, we will be bringing forward amendments in a number of areas. To repeal the early release provisions of the Belfast Agreement, to prohibit anyone granted immunity from glorifying terrorism, allow immunity to be revoked, to establish larger fines for those who fail to cooperate and to ensure only innocent victims are treated as victims in any memorialisation strategy."
Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart added: "The DUP will be resisting, and voting against, the Bill at every available opportunity. We will also be seeking support from MPs to help limit the damage should the Government choose to steamroller through these provisions without the consent of communities in Northern Ireland.
"The drafting of this Bill is such that there would be absolutely no incentive for paramilitaries to engage. In fact, it would erase the two-year prison sentence an individual would have to serve if convicted for offences committed before 1998. There would also be minimal repercussions should anyone who chooses not to engage with the Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery - or indeed those who are proven to have lied - while those who have openly evaded the authorities for years would seemingly be able to reap the benefits of immunity.
"This will inevitably lead to a situation where terrorists who have openly evaded the authorities for years being able to retire in dignity. All the while a disproportionate focus would rest on the minority of state-related cases - for which a mountain of information exists and which we can assume would be meticulously provided to the information recovery process.
"Ultimately, anyone who broke the law should face the threat of prosecution and eventual conviction for their crimes. The law should apply equally and be applied without fear or favour. Nobody denies that the passage of time presents prosecutorial difficulties but the answer is not to arbitrarily close down legal routes for innocent victims. This holds implications for the integrity of the criminal justice system not just in Northern Ireland but across the United Kingdom. It wouldn't be tolerated for hate crime or gang crime. It shouldn't be deemed acceptable toward the victims of terrorism."
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
15 January 2007
Victims Commissioner appointment not quashed
A High Court ruling has not quashed the appointment of Bertha McDougall as the Northern Ireland Interim Victims Commissioner. However, in his ruling Lord Justice Girvan said that the appointment was "improper and politically motivated.
Victims Commissioner appointment not quashed
A High Court ruling has not quashed the appointment of Bertha McDougall as the Northern Ireland Interim Victims Commissioner. However, in his ruling Lord Justice Girvan said that the appointment was "improper and politically motivated.
06 May 2021
Consultation Launches On Victims' Experiences Of The Criminal Justice System
A public consultation has launched on proposals to improve the experiences of victims and witnesses within the criminal justice system. The consultation will seek views on two areas: • a new three-year draft Victim and Witness Strategy for Northern Ireland • proposals for the establishment of a Victims of Crime Commissioner for Northern Ireland.
Consultation Launches On Victims' Experiences Of The Criminal Justice System
A public consultation has launched on proposals to improve the experiences of victims and witnesses within the criminal justice system. The consultation will seek views on two areas: • a new three-year draft Victim and Witness Strategy for Northern Ireland • proposals for the establishment of a Victims of Crime Commissioner for Northern Ireland.
22 September 2021
Victims To Be Placed At The Centre Of The Justice System
The needs and interests of victims are to be placed at the centre of the justice system with the establishment of a new Victims of Crime Commissioner Designate for Northern Ireland, Justice Minister Naomi Long has announced.
Victims To Be Placed At The Centre Of The Justice System
The needs and interests of victims are to be placed at the centre of the justice system with the establishment of a new Victims of Crime Commissioner Designate for Northern Ireland, Justice Minister Naomi Long has announced.
21 July 2023
DoJ Publishes New Protocol For Delivery Of Restorative Justice
A new Protocol for the delivery of restorative justice in Northern Ireland has been published by the Department of Justice (DoJ). The new 2023 Protocol will govern the use of restorative interventions in the criminal justice system in NI and details how a new accreditation process will work for organisations and individuals.
DoJ Publishes New Protocol For Delivery Of Restorative Justice
A new Protocol for the delivery of restorative justice in Northern Ireland has been published by the Department of Justice (DoJ). The new 2023 Protocol will govern the use of restorative interventions in the criminal justice system in NI and details how a new accreditation process will work for organisations and individuals.
18 October 2010
Justice Bill Seeks Better Deal For Victims
For the first time in four decades, a new Justice Bill has been published in Northern Ireland.
Justice Bill Seeks Better Deal For Victims
For the first time in four decades, a new Justice Bill has been published in Northern Ireland.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
