Menu
30/09/2004
NI PR system is flawed, claims academic
Northern Ireland’s PR voting system – known as Single Transferable Voting (STV) - needs to be reformed because it does not treat all voters equally, a leading University of Ulster academic has claimed.
Professor Vani Borooah, Professor of Applied Economics at the School of Economics and Politics, said an anomaly in the system means that many voters’ second and subsequent preferences are disregarded when the votes are counted.
Under STV, voters rank candidates in their constituency in order, putting a ‘1’ against their first choice candidate, ‘2’ against the next and so on.
Professor Borooah pointed out that, in last year’s Assembly elections, 54% of the voters had only their first preference votes taken into account. Their other preferences were disregarded because their first choice candidates were not elected on the first count.
The system, therefore, favours parties who have candidates elected on the first count. In the Assembly elections of November 2003, the DUP received 15,186 more first preference votes than Sinn Fein and won six more seats (30-24). The Ulster Unionist Party received 5,827 fewer first preference votes than Sinn Fein yet won three more seats.
Professor Borooah said: “At least part of this can be ascribed to the fact that the preferences of DUP and UUP supporters were more effective in making their way through the electoral system compared to the preferences of Sinn Fein supporters.”
He said the STV system is said by supporters to be fair because it allows each voter to express preferences over all the candidates in a constituency and it takes account of those preferences in determining who is elected.
But, he argued, the second point is not true. Some voters have more than their first preferences taken into account; others have just their first preferences counted. Implicit in the system is an unequal treatment of voters.
“In essence STV creates two classes of voters,” Professor Borooah said. “So while all voters may express their preferences over all the candidates, such expression is meaningful for only some voters and meaningless for the remainder.”
If this system had been used in the last NI Assembly elections Sinn Fein would have won six more seats, the UUP would have had four fewer and the smaller parties would have lost two seats. The final party strengths would have been: DUP and Sinn Fein 30 seats each; UUP 23; SDLP unchanged at 18 and Other Parties 7.
Professor Borooah concluded: “What I am pointing up is the inequality among voters that the present STV system creates. How serious that inequality is in terms of results will vary from election to election.
“There are ways to overcome the anomaly that exists in the present system. One builds on the current system and the other, while giving voters a more limited expression of preferences, ensures all votes have an equal influence on the result of the election.”
(MB/GMCG)
Professor Vani Borooah, Professor of Applied Economics at the School of Economics and Politics, said an anomaly in the system means that many voters’ second and subsequent preferences are disregarded when the votes are counted.
Under STV, voters rank candidates in their constituency in order, putting a ‘1’ against their first choice candidate, ‘2’ against the next and so on.
Professor Borooah pointed out that, in last year’s Assembly elections, 54% of the voters had only their first preference votes taken into account. Their other preferences were disregarded because their first choice candidates were not elected on the first count.
The system, therefore, favours parties who have candidates elected on the first count. In the Assembly elections of November 2003, the DUP received 15,186 more first preference votes than Sinn Fein and won six more seats (30-24). The Ulster Unionist Party received 5,827 fewer first preference votes than Sinn Fein yet won three more seats.
Professor Borooah said: “At least part of this can be ascribed to the fact that the preferences of DUP and UUP supporters were more effective in making their way through the electoral system compared to the preferences of Sinn Fein supporters.”
He said the STV system is said by supporters to be fair because it allows each voter to express preferences over all the candidates in a constituency and it takes account of those preferences in determining who is elected.
But, he argued, the second point is not true. Some voters have more than their first preferences taken into account; others have just their first preferences counted. Implicit in the system is an unequal treatment of voters.
“In essence STV creates two classes of voters,” Professor Borooah said. “So while all voters may express their preferences over all the candidates, such expression is meaningful for only some voters and meaningless for the remainder.”
If this system had been used in the last NI Assembly elections Sinn Fein would have won six more seats, the UUP would have had four fewer and the smaller parties would have lost two seats. The final party strengths would have been: DUP and Sinn Fein 30 seats each; UUP 23; SDLP unchanged at 18 and Other Parties 7.
Professor Borooah concluded: “What I am pointing up is the inequality among voters that the present STV system creates. How serious that inequality is in terms of results will vary from election to election.
“There are ways to overcome the anomaly that exists in the present system. One builds on the current system and the other, while giving voters a more limited expression of preferences, ensures all votes have an equal influence on the result of the election.”
(MB/GMCG)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
29 October 2009
Electoral Roll Grows - But More Try Fraud
The number of people on Northern Ireland's Electoral Register has increased by over 31,000. The new figures relate to the period 2008/09 and also show that the number of cases of suspected postal voting fraud reported to the PSNI has also risen.
Electoral Roll Grows - But More Try Fraud
The number of people on Northern Ireland's Electoral Register has increased by over 31,000. The new figures relate to the period 2008/09 and also show that the number of cases of suspected postal voting fraud reported to the PSNI has also risen.
05 December 2007
11-plus Legislation May Be Opposed
Academic selection in Northern Ireland may not yet be dead as unionist MLAs look set to block the legislation. Although Education Minister Caitriona Ruane said the transfer test for P7 pupils would be scrapped next year, the voting system at the Assembly effectively hands both unionists and nationalists a veto over new laws.
11-plus Legislation May Be Opposed
Academic selection in Northern Ireland may not yet be dead as unionist MLAs look set to block the legislation. Although Education Minister Caitriona Ruane said the transfer test for P7 pupils would be scrapped next year, the voting system at the Assembly effectively hands both unionists and nationalists a veto over new laws.
01 June 2009
ID Needed As EC Election Looms
Voters in this Thursday's European Parliamentary Election are today being reminded that them must make sure they bring the correct photographic ID to the polling station.
ID Needed As EC Election Looms
Voters in this Thursday's European Parliamentary Election are today being reminded that them must make sure they bring the correct photographic ID to the polling station.
05 May 2005
Slow start to voting in NI elections
Following a slow start, voting at Northern Ireland’s 620 polling stations is described as "steady" as voters select from the 105 local candidates contesting the province's 18 Westminster seats and the 918 representatives competing for 582 council seats. Polling stations across the province opened at 7am and will remain so until 10pm.
Slow start to voting in NI elections
Following a slow start, voting at Northern Ireland’s 620 polling stations is described as "steady" as voters select from the 105 local candidates contesting the province's 18 Westminster seats and the 918 representatives competing for 582 council seats. Polling stations across the province opened at 7am and will remain so until 10pm.
10 June 2004
Voting underway in European Elections
Voting for this year's European Elections got underway today with fears that apathy among Northern Ireland's public could result in one of the lowest ever turnouts.
Voting underway in European Elections
Voting for this year's European Elections got underway today with fears that apathy among Northern Ireland's public could result in one of the lowest ever turnouts.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
