Menu
10/09/2002
Commission faces backlash after resignations
There has been a backlash against the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission with two high-profile politicians questioning the body's independence and direction following the resignation of two members yesterday.
Professor Christine Bell and Inez McCormack wrote individually to the Secretary of State John Reid expressing their concerns at the failure of the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission to effectively promote and protect human rights, as mandated by the Good Friday Agreement.
Sinn Féin chairman Mitchel McLaughlin said the resignations raised "fundamental doubts about whether this Commission, as currently constituted, is the independent human rights advocate it was intended to be under the Good Friday Agreement".
He said the reasons given by the individuals for their resignations should "therefore be a matter of urgent concern to the two governments that these legitimate grievances are honestly and speedily addressed if public confidence is to be restored".
Ulster Unionist South Down MLA Dermot Nesbitt said the news was hardly surprising.
He added: “It is not surprising that the Commission has run short of funding after receiving a substantial increase from the Northern Ireland Office in regard to a Bill of Rights. The Commission went to grandiose lengths to do that which it was not prescribed to do in the Belfast Agreement and did not do that which it was supposed to do.
“Its remit was to deal with rights particular to Northern Ireland but it dealt with the whole gambit of rights which obviously cost a lot of money and was simply not justified.
“Let me make it clear, I am all for equality and rights but they must come through proper interpretation, based on international principles and standards.”
The harshest criticisms of the Commission were, however, reserved for the resignation letters of Prof Bell and Ms McCormack.
In her letter of resignation, Christine Bell expressed her disappointment at the ineffectiveness of the Commission in protecting and promoting rights, citing both lack of powers and resources coupled with the lack of a sufficiently strategic approach to using what powers existed.
Inez McCormack, citing concern about ineffectiveness, also expressed particular concern about the Bill of Rights process.
She said: "Political parties and civil society are just the beginning of… the debate on a Bill of Rights. This difficult, serious process needs time and space.
"The Commission, however, in my view, still is pursuing an approach to this debate that risks polarising it and rushing it, thereby closing its potential as a process that can assist in building peace."
This brings to three the number of people who have resigned their posts since the Commission was created in March 1999.
(MB)
Professor Christine Bell and Inez McCormack wrote individually to the Secretary of State John Reid expressing their concerns at the failure of the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission to effectively promote and protect human rights, as mandated by the Good Friday Agreement.
Sinn Féin chairman Mitchel McLaughlin said the resignations raised "fundamental doubts about whether this Commission, as currently constituted, is the independent human rights advocate it was intended to be under the Good Friday Agreement".
He said the reasons given by the individuals for their resignations should "therefore be a matter of urgent concern to the two governments that these legitimate grievances are honestly and speedily addressed if public confidence is to be restored".
Ulster Unionist South Down MLA Dermot Nesbitt said the news was hardly surprising.
He added: “It is not surprising that the Commission has run short of funding after receiving a substantial increase from the Northern Ireland Office in regard to a Bill of Rights. The Commission went to grandiose lengths to do that which it was not prescribed to do in the Belfast Agreement and did not do that which it was supposed to do.
“Its remit was to deal with rights particular to Northern Ireland but it dealt with the whole gambit of rights which obviously cost a lot of money and was simply not justified.
“Let me make it clear, I am all for equality and rights but they must come through proper interpretation, based on international principles and standards.”
The harshest criticisms of the Commission were, however, reserved for the resignation letters of Prof Bell and Ms McCormack.
In her letter of resignation, Christine Bell expressed her disappointment at the ineffectiveness of the Commission in protecting and promoting rights, citing both lack of powers and resources coupled with the lack of a sufficiently strategic approach to using what powers existed.
Inez McCormack, citing concern about ineffectiveness, also expressed particular concern about the Bill of Rights process.
She said: "Political parties and civil society are just the beginning of… the debate on a Bill of Rights. This difficult, serious process needs time and space.
"The Commission, however, in my view, still is pursuing an approach to this debate that risks polarising it and rushing it, thereby closing its potential as a process that can assist in building peace."
This brings to three the number of people who have resigned their posts since the Commission was created in March 1999.
(MB)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
08 March 2007
HRC calls for improvements in treatment of women prisoners
The Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission (NIHRC) has marked today’s International Women’s Day by calling for improvements in the way women prisoners are treated in Northern Ireland.
HRC calls for improvements in treatment of women prisoners
The Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission (NIHRC) has marked today’s International Women’s Day by calling for improvements in the way women prisoners are treated in Northern Ireland.
08 June 2005
Queen’s to debate future of Human Rights Commissions
The future of Human Rights Commissions in the UK and Ireland will be examined at Queen's University Belfast this week. The Human Rights Centre at the Queen's School of Law, in co-operation with the Faculty of Law, University of Bristol, will hold a half-day conference in Belfast on Friday on the role of both Commissions.
Queen’s to debate future of Human Rights Commissions
The future of Human Rights Commissions in the UK and Ireland will be examined at Queen's University Belfast this week. The Human Rights Centre at the Queen's School of Law, in co-operation with the Faculty of Law, University of Bristol, will hold a half-day conference in Belfast on Friday on the role of both Commissions.
24 March 2009
Teen Denies Police Murder Charge
A teenager has appeared in court to deny murdering police officer Constable Stephen Carroll, 48, who was shot dead in Craigavon on Monday 9 March. He was in the dock at Lisburn Magistrates Court where the court was told he "made no reply to the charges", when they were put to him.
Teen Denies Police Murder Charge
A teenager has appeared in court to deny murdering police officer Constable Stephen Carroll, 48, who was shot dead in Craigavon on Monday 9 March. He was in the dock at Lisburn Magistrates Court where the court was told he "made no reply to the charges", when they were put to him.
28 January 2005
Belfast to hold international Human Rights conference
A major conference, bringing together over 20 international human rights leaders from 12 countries, will take place in Belfast this weekend.
Belfast to hold international Human Rights conference
A major conference, bringing together over 20 international human rights leaders from 12 countries, will take place in Belfast this weekend.
04 September 2001
Provisional Bill of Rights is unveiled
The Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission has published its provisional proposals for what should be contained in a Bill of Rights for Northern Ireland.
Provisional Bill of Rights is unveiled
The Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission has published its provisional proposals for what should be contained in a Bill of Rights for Northern Ireland.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherThis Evening and Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
