Menu
18/04/2008
No Inquiry On Fractured Body Mystery
The family of a woman who suffered mysterious injuries after her death in hospital are incensed over a high level decision not to hold a full investigation.
Stormont Health Minister Michael McGimpsey has decided not to hold a public inquiry into how a pensioner's body suffered 34 broken bones after her death in an Ulster hospital.
Mr McGimpsey said an independent probe would be unlikely to shed any further light on what happened to the body of 78-year-old Maureen McGinley.
Explaining his decision yesterday, he said: "My understanding is that events surrounding Mrs McGinley's death have been subjected to a very comprehensive examination, both internally by the trust and by the coroner's service, who took responsibility for delivering her body to the Belfast City Mortuary for post-mortem.
"Despite that comprehensive investigation it has not been possible to provide a totally satisfactory explanation for the fractures which Mrs McGinley sustained after her death.
However, Dr Kieran Deeney, and medical practitioner and Independent MLA has said that for the sake of the family, a full, external and independent inquiry, where people who had dealings with Maureen's body after her death are interviewed, is needed.
"I am of the view that any further review, or indeed a public inquiry, into the circumstances is unlikely to shed any further light on how this unfortunate incident occurred."
Between the pensioner's death in January 2007 and examination by the coroner, Mrs McGinley's body sustained numerous fractures, primarily to her rib cage.
Internal inquiries at the hospital and the Coroner's Office failed to establish who was responsible.
Mrs McGinley's children have campaigned vigorously for answers and collected more than 14,000 signatures on a petition calling for a public inquiry.
Dr Deeney, who himself sits on the Stormont Health Committee, said "internal inquiries do not boost public confidence".
The Strabane woman died in Altnagelvin Hospital in January 2007.
(BMcC)
Stormont Health Minister Michael McGimpsey has decided not to hold a public inquiry into how a pensioner's body suffered 34 broken bones after her death in an Ulster hospital.
Mr McGimpsey said an independent probe would be unlikely to shed any further light on what happened to the body of 78-year-old Maureen McGinley.
Explaining his decision yesterday, he said: "My understanding is that events surrounding Mrs McGinley's death have been subjected to a very comprehensive examination, both internally by the trust and by the coroner's service, who took responsibility for delivering her body to the Belfast City Mortuary for post-mortem.
"Despite that comprehensive investigation it has not been possible to provide a totally satisfactory explanation for the fractures which Mrs McGinley sustained after her death.
However, Dr Kieran Deeney, and medical practitioner and Independent MLA has said that for the sake of the family, a full, external and independent inquiry, where people who had dealings with Maureen's body after her death are interviewed, is needed.
"I am of the view that any further review, or indeed a public inquiry, into the circumstances is unlikely to shed any further light on how this unfortunate incident occurred."
Between the pensioner's death in January 2007 and examination by the coroner, Mrs McGinley's body sustained numerous fractures, primarily to her rib cage.
Internal inquiries at the hospital and the Coroner's Office failed to establish who was responsible.
Mrs McGinley's children have campaigned vigorously for answers and collected more than 14,000 signatures on a petition calling for a public inquiry.
Dr Deeney, who himself sits on the Stormont Health Committee, said "internal inquiries do not boost public confidence".
The Strabane woman died in Altnagelvin Hospital in January 2007.
(BMcC)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
21 November 2024
Work Underway For Free Hospital Parking In Northern Ireland
Work has begun at several hospital sites across Northern Ireland as part of the preparations for the introduction of free car parking in May 2026. Health and Social Care Trusts have been actively preparing for the implementation of a new traffic management system since the Hospital Parking Charges Act was passed in 2022.
Work Underway For Free Hospital Parking In Northern Ireland
Work has begun at several hospital sites across Northern Ireland as part of the preparations for the introduction of free car parking in May 2026. Health and Social Care Trusts have been actively preparing for the implementation of a new traffic management system since the Hospital Parking Charges Act was passed in 2022.
01 October 2010
Fresh Lead On Dead Pensioner's Injuries
The grieving family members of a Strabane pensioner whose post mortem injuries shocked NI over two years ago are now calling for a new probe. They said they have uncovered new evidence about how her ribs were broken following her death. Maureen McGinley, who was 78, died of natural causes at Altnagelvin Hospital in January 2007.
Fresh Lead On Dead Pensioner's Injuries
The grieving family members of a Strabane pensioner whose post mortem injuries shocked NI over two years ago are now calling for a new probe. They said they have uncovered new evidence about how her ribs were broken following her death. Maureen McGinley, who was 78, died of natural causes at Altnagelvin Hospital in January 2007.
02 November 2001
Human Organs Inquiry set to answer public’s questions
The Human Organs Inquiry set up by the Department of Health has invited members of the public to come and air their views and listen to health service staff as well as relatives affected by the retention of human organs in Northern Ireland.
Human Organs Inquiry set to answer public’s questions
The Human Organs Inquiry set up by the Department of Health has invited members of the public to come and air their views and listen to health service staff as well as relatives affected by the retention of human organs in Northern Ireland.
25 June 2008
No Inquiry In Post Mortem Fractures Case
A public inquiry would not provide the answers sought by the family of a woman whose body suffered injuries after her death in hospital.
No Inquiry In Post Mortem Fractures Case
A public inquiry would not provide the answers sought by the family of a woman whose body suffered injuries after her death in hospital.
12 May 2010
Hamill Probe Seeks Public's Views
The Robert Hamill Inquiry is inviting members of the public to submit their views on any issues they believe the Inquiry should cover in its recommendations. The Inquiry intends to deliver its report, together with a series of recommendations, to the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland by the end of the year.
Hamill Probe Seeks Public's Views
The Robert Hamill Inquiry is inviting members of the public to submit their views on any issues they believe the Inquiry should cover in its recommendations. The Inquiry intends to deliver its report, together with a series of recommendations, to the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland by the end of the year.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
