Menu
18/06/2009
Journalist Wins Landmark Case
A Belfast judge has ruled journalist Suzanne Breen's life would be at risk if she was forced to disclose details of Real IRA sources.
Judge Burgess said a police application to obtain the material would breach Ms Breen's right to life, under Article 2 of the European Convention of Human Rights.
Ms Breen defied police requests to divulge information on the terrorists, who said they were responsible for the murders of two soldiers Mark Quinsey, 23, and Patrick Azimkar, 21, (pictured here).
They were gunned down by the Real IRA and died in a hail of 60 bullets as they were taking delivery of a pizza at the Army base on the eve of depolyment to Afghanistan.
Investigators had asked the Sunday Tribune's northern editor to hand over her mobile telephone, computer records and notes about the Real IRA.
Last week, Ms Breen told the High Court her life would be in grave danger if a police application forced her to disclose material collated in her capacity as a reporter.
She said dissident republicans would show no hesitation in killing her or her family.
Today, the presiding judge said there was objective evidence that the Real IRA is a "ruthless and murderous group of people who would regard any handing over of any information in the possession of Ms Breen over and above the publication of their claim for responsibility, as exposing her to be treated as a legitimate target with the murderous consequences that could and may well follow from that".
Judge Burgess said if the court believed Ms Breen's Article 2 rights outweighed the public interest in the investigation of crime, then it should not make the order.
The judge said it was likely the material would be of substantial value to the PSNI investigation.
However, Judge Burgess said he had to place "very considerable weight" on the protection of Ms Breen and her family's lives.
Despite looking at possible means of protecting Ms Breen, the judge said it "would be close to inconceivable as to how she, and potentially her family, could be protected for what could well be for many years to come. Because the risk is not just real and immediate. It is continuing".
Ms Breen received momentous support from the National Union of Journalist and many other high profile writers, who all backed her stance on source confidentiality.
Outside court this afternoon, she said: "I couldn't be happier with the decision.
"Hopefully this will set a precedent. I hope no other journalist will find themselves hauled before the court."
Sappers Mark Quinsey, 23, from Birmingham, and Patrick Azimkar, 21, from London, were shot dead as they collected pizzas outside Massereene Army base. Several civilians were also seriously wounded.
See: Polish Pizza Gun Victim 'Recovering' After Surgery
(PR/BMcC)
Judge Burgess said a police application to obtain the material would breach Ms Breen's right to life, under Article 2 of the European Convention of Human Rights.
Ms Breen defied police requests to divulge information on the terrorists, who said they were responsible for the murders of two soldiers Mark Quinsey, 23, and Patrick Azimkar, 21, (pictured here).
They were gunned down by the Real IRA and died in a hail of 60 bullets as they were taking delivery of a pizza at the Army base on the eve of depolyment to Afghanistan.
Investigators had asked the Sunday Tribune's northern editor to hand over her mobile telephone, computer records and notes about the Real IRA.
Last week, Ms Breen told the High Court her life would be in grave danger if a police application forced her to disclose material collated in her capacity as a reporter.
She said dissident republicans would show no hesitation in killing her or her family.
Today, the presiding judge said there was objective evidence that the Real IRA is a "ruthless and murderous group of people who would regard any handing over of any information in the possession of Ms Breen over and above the publication of their claim for responsibility, as exposing her to be treated as a legitimate target with the murderous consequences that could and may well follow from that".
Judge Burgess said if the court believed Ms Breen's Article 2 rights outweighed the public interest in the investigation of crime, then it should not make the order.
The judge said it was likely the material would be of substantial value to the PSNI investigation.
However, Judge Burgess said he had to place "very considerable weight" on the protection of Ms Breen and her family's lives.
Despite looking at possible means of protecting Ms Breen, the judge said it "would be close to inconceivable as to how she, and potentially her family, could be protected for what could well be for many years to come. Because the risk is not just real and immediate. It is continuing".
Ms Breen received momentous support from the National Union of Journalist and many other high profile writers, who all backed her stance on source confidentiality.
Outside court this afternoon, she said: "I couldn't be happier with the decision.
"Hopefully this will set a precedent. I hope no other journalist will find themselves hauled before the court."
Sappers Mark Quinsey, 23, from Birmingham, and Patrick Azimkar, 21, from London, were shot dead as they collected pizzas outside Massereene Army base. Several civilians were also seriously wounded.
See: Polish Pizza Gun Victim 'Recovering' After Surgery
(PR/BMcC)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
15 October 2009
Website Focuses On Workplace Safety
The NI Enterprise Minister Arlene Foster has launched a new website, to help small businesses manage their workplace health and safety - and especially those in the construction sector.
Website Focuses On Workplace Safety
The NI Enterprise Minister Arlene Foster has launched a new website, to help small businesses manage their workplace health and safety - and especially those in the construction sector.
02 March 2004
Boxing champ suffers broken leg in attack
WBU welterweight boxing champion, Eamonn Magee has had his leg broken in an attack in Belfast. The 32-year-old west Belfast man was dragged from his car and attacked by a gang of men at the weekend. He suffered a compound fracture of the tibia and fibula as well as a possible punctured lung during the incident.
Boxing champ suffers broken leg in attack
WBU welterweight boxing champion, Eamonn Magee has had his leg broken in an attack in Belfast. The 32-year-old west Belfast man was dragged from his car and attacked by a gang of men at the weekend. He suffered a compound fracture of the tibia and fibula as well as a possible punctured lung during the incident.
08 May 2009
Police Seek Private High Court Challenge To Journalist
The Chief Constable has applied to have the case forcing a journalist to hand over information about the Real IRA held in private. The latest development comes today after the journalist continued to defy police requests to handover source information on dissident republicans, despite a High Court challenge.
Police Seek Private High Court Challenge To Journalist
The Chief Constable has applied to have the case forcing a journalist to hand over information about the Real IRA held in private. The latest development comes today after the journalist continued to defy police requests to handover source information on dissident republicans, despite a High Court challenge.
12 May 2009
Judge Undecided On IRA Sources Case
A Belfast judge has said he is "minded" to give police permission to legally induce a reporter to reveal her dissident republican sources. However, Judge Tom Burgess insisted no decision will be made until both sides have stated their case.
Judge Undecided On IRA Sources Case
A Belfast judge has said he is "minded" to give police permission to legally induce a reporter to reveal her dissident republican sources. However, Judge Tom Burgess insisted no decision will be made until both sides have stated their case.
11 June 2009
Journalist Breen Back In Court
An Irish journalist continued her fight to protect Real IRA sources at Belfast's High Court today. Sunday Tribune northern editor Suzanne Breen has defied police requests to hand over journalist material relating to dissident republicans. Today a court heard she faces "grave danger" if she is forced to elaborate on confidential sources.
Journalist Breen Back In Court
An Irish journalist continued her fight to protect Real IRA sources at Belfast's High Court today. Sunday Tribune northern editor Suzanne Breen has defied police requests to hand over journalist material relating to dissident republicans. Today a court heard she faces "grave danger" if she is forced to elaborate on confidential sources.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
