Menu
07/07/2009
Castlereagh Break-in 'Frustrating': Orde
The outgoing PSNI Chief Constable has said he is "frustrated" that the case against Larry Zaitschek collapsed.
Sir Hugh Orde (who is pictured here) was commenting today in a BBC Radio Ulster interview on the collapse of the case against an American chef wanted over the hugely damaging Castlereagh Special Branch office break-in.
However, he made it clear that he had no problem supplying any necessary material to the defence - and said that the material being withheld was from another agency - implying that it might possibly be MI5 or other security agency.
The Public Prosecution Service said last Friday that the extradition of Larry Zaitschek from New York over the 2002 robbery would not go ahead because not "all intelligence material could be disclosed to the defence".
There was a risk he would not get a fair trial as a consequence.
Orde revealed that the failure to disclose was due to the risk to life and human rights of people other than the US chef who had worked in Castlereagh at the time of the break-in.
He said it was not the first time such a situation had arisen.
"That's my real frustration because we can't talk in detail about these cases because of competing human rights basically, other people's rights to life," he said.
Intelligence material kept secret had nothing to do with the PSNI and he was holding nothing back, he insisted.
"What I can say is that there is nothing within my intelligence systems that I was not prepared to release to enable a fair trial to take place.
"There is a clue in that the issues that arose were out with my jurisdiction and I will not have my service criticised for something that was out with my responsibility. I think that would be very unfair," he said.
See: No Charges Over Special Branch Heist
(BMcC/JM)
Sir Hugh Orde (who is pictured here) was commenting today in a BBC Radio Ulster interview on the collapse of the case against an American chef wanted over the hugely damaging Castlereagh Special Branch office break-in.
However, he made it clear that he had no problem supplying any necessary material to the defence - and said that the material being withheld was from another agency - implying that it might possibly be MI5 or other security agency.
The Public Prosecution Service said last Friday that the extradition of Larry Zaitschek from New York over the 2002 robbery would not go ahead because not "all intelligence material could be disclosed to the defence".
There was a risk he would not get a fair trial as a consequence.
Orde revealed that the failure to disclose was due to the risk to life and human rights of people other than the US chef who had worked in Castlereagh at the time of the break-in.
He said it was not the first time such a situation had arisen.
"That's my real frustration because we can't talk in detail about these cases because of competing human rights basically, other people's rights to life," he said.
Intelligence material kept secret had nothing to do with the PSNI and he was holding nothing back, he insisted.
"What I can say is that there is nothing within my intelligence systems that I was not prepared to release to enable a fair trial to take place.
"There is a clue in that the issues that arose were out with my jurisdiction and I will not have my service criticised for something that was out with my responsibility. I think that would be very unfair," he said.
See: No Charges Over Special Branch Heist
(BMcC/JM)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
29 January 2004
Trimble backs calls for 'intelligence' inquiry
Following the publication of Lord Hutton’s Report into the circumstances surrounding the death of Dr David Kelly, the Ulster Unionist Leader David Trimble said the findings had left a "lingering anxiety about the reliability of the intelligence".
Trimble backs calls for 'intelligence' inquiry
Following the publication of Lord Hutton’s Report into the circumstances surrounding the death of Dr David Kelly, the Ulster Unionist Leader David Trimble said the findings had left a "lingering anxiety about the reliability of the intelligence".
22 November 2024
Consumer Council Advice On Online Shopping Rights
With Black Friday and Cyber Monday just around the corner, consumers in Northern Ireland are gearing up for a flurry of online shopping. While many retailers have already started offering deals, concerns about potential delivery issues such as delays, lost parcels, and damaged goods are on the rise.
Consumer Council Advice On Online Shopping Rights
With Black Friday and Cyber Monday just around the corner, consumers in Northern Ireland are gearing up for a flurry of online shopping. While many retailers have already started offering deals, concerns about potential delivery issues such as delays, lost parcels, and damaged goods are on the rise.
21 November 2024
Other News In Brief
Mike Nesbitt Pays Tribute To Ken Reid Health Minister Mike Nesbitt has paid tribute to Ken Reid, the veteran journalist who has passed away after a long period of ill health. The Minister said: "I want to first and foremost express my deepest condolences to Ken’s wife Liz, his children and grandchildren and the whole family circle.
Other News In Brief
Mike Nesbitt Pays Tribute To Ken Reid Health Minister Mike Nesbitt has paid tribute to Ken Reid, the veteran journalist who has passed away after a long period of ill health. The Minister said: "I want to first and foremost express my deepest condolences to Ken’s wife Liz, his children and grandchildren and the whole family circle.
29 July 2009
NI Informant Payouts Revealed
Northern Ireland police informers were paid £299,000 during the last financial year, a Freedom of Information request has revealed. The BBC, who submitted the request, learned that across the UK, police forces had handed out more than £6m for information on criminal activity while NI pay-outs ranked the third largest behind the £1.
NI Informant Payouts Revealed
Northern Ireland police informers were paid £299,000 during the last financial year, a Freedom of Information request has revealed. The BBC, who submitted the request, learned that across the UK, police forces had handed out more than £6m for information on criminal activity while NI pay-outs ranked the third largest behind the £1.
12 August 2024
Two Men Due In Court On Disorder Charges
Magistrates' Court today, Monday, 12 August, charged in connection with incidents of violent disorder.
Two Men Due In Court On Disorder Charges
Magistrates' Court today, Monday, 12 August, charged in connection with incidents of violent disorder.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
