Menu
03/04/2002
McGuinness slams NI's "world-class education myth"
The Education Minister Martin McGuinness launched a stinging criticism of the 11+ testing procedure in a speech to the Irish National Teachers Organisation (INTO) in Limerick.
The minister, in an address on the Review of Post-Primary Education, told the conference that the belief that Northern Ireland had a "world-class education system" was based on a "myth".
He added: "The facts do not support the myths of a world-class education system; of grammar schools as an essential route for entry to higher education and university or of academic selection as a ladder to success for working class children. In fact, it is working-class Protestant children who are most disadvantaged by our current system, and who consequently are most in need of change."
The Education Minister said that only eight per cent of pupils in grammar schools are from low-income families and around 50 per cent of students at the University of Ulster come from non A-level routes.
Mr McGuinness said that the best way for him to clarify his feelings on the selection procedure was to refer to Save The Children Fund research which had surveyed 140 pupils at the selection stage. He quoted the experience of two children involved in the research.
One child said: "I felt so nervous on the morning of the 11 plus I was nearly sick. I barely got to sleep the night before and when I did, I woke up at 3.00 am to find myself sleepwalking".
Another said: "If you’re smart you go to a grammar school but if you’re stupid you go to a secondary school and that’s where I’m going, to a secondary school because …I’m stupid."
Mr McGuinness continued: "I cannot, and will not, accept an education system which makes children physically sick with nerves, which makes children feel stupid, or which determines the future of children on the basis of two hours of their life. No society has the right to tell any child at age 10 or 11 that he or she is a failure."
Referring to academic selection, the minister said: "There is a clear need for change, but the 11+ is a symptom of the present system, which is academic selection and academic rejection. That is what the debate must be about and I welcome the growing concentration on this key issue in public discussions."
The research into children’s attitudes to the transfer procedure tests was commissioned by Save the Children Fund and undertaken by the School of Sociology and Social Policy at Queen’s University, Belfast. The Department of Education funded the costs of employing the Research Assistant which amounted to about £25,000.
(GMcG)
The minister, in an address on the Review of Post-Primary Education, told the conference that the belief that Northern Ireland had a "world-class education system" was based on a "myth".
He added: "The facts do not support the myths of a world-class education system; of grammar schools as an essential route for entry to higher education and university or of academic selection as a ladder to success for working class children. In fact, it is working-class Protestant children who are most disadvantaged by our current system, and who consequently are most in need of change."
The Education Minister said that only eight per cent of pupils in grammar schools are from low-income families and around 50 per cent of students at the University of Ulster come from non A-level routes.
Mr McGuinness said that the best way for him to clarify his feelings on the selection procedure was to refer to Save The Children Fund research which had surveyed 140 pupils at the selection stage. He quoted the experience of two children involved in the research.
One child said: "I felt so nervous on the morning of the 11 plus I was nearly sick. I barely got to sleep the night before and when I did, I woke up at 3.00 am to find myself sleepwalking".
Another said: "If you’re smart you go to a grammar school but if you’re stupid you go to a secondary school and that’s where I’m going, to a secondary school because …I’m stupid."
Mr McGuinness continued: "I cannot, and will not, accept an education system which makes children physically sick with nerves, which makes children feel stupid, or which determines the future of children on the basis of two hours of their life. No society has the right to tell any child at age 10 or 11 that he or she is a failure."
Referring to academic selection, the minister said: "There is a clear need for change, but the 11+ is a symptom of the present system, which is academic selection and academic rejection. That is what the debate must be about and I welcome the growing concentration on this key issue in public discussions."
The research into children’s attitudes to the transfer procedure tests was commissioned by Save the Children Fund and undertaken by the School of Sociology and Social Policy at Queen’s University, Belfast. The Department of Education funded the costs of employing the Research Assistant which amounted to about £25,000.
(GMcG)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
05 March 2009
Education Minister Drums Up Support For Integration
With over 18,000 children and young people being educated in integrated schools across Northern Ireland already, the sector has an important role to play.
Education Minister Drums Up Support For Integration
With over 18,000 children and young people being educated in integrated schools across Northern Ireland already, the sector has an important role to play.
17 April 2002
Catholic Bishops declare opposition to academic selection
The Stormont Education Minister Martin McGuinness has welcomed the Northern Catholic Bishops’ statement on the future process of academic selection. The Northern Bishops said in a statement on Tuesday April 16 that they wanted to “maintain and enhance quality but not promote elitism”.
Catholic Bishops declare opposition to academic selection
The Stormont Education Minister Martin McGuinness has welcomed the Northern Catholic Bishops’ statement on the future process of academic selection. The Northern Bishops said in a statement on Tuesday April 16 that they wanted to “maintain and enhance quality but not promote elitism”.
04 December 2007
Funds Warning For Grammar Schools Testing At 11-plus
The traditional 11-plus transfer test will no longer be taking place, replaced instead by a new concept of transfer to secondary education at age 14. Testing of Northern Ireland's P7 children will be scrapped from next year, the Assembly Education Minister has said.
Funds Warning For Grammar Schools Testing At 11-plus
The traditional 11-plus transfer test will no longer be taking place, replaced instead by a new concept of transfer to secondary education at age 14. Testing of Northern Ireland's P7 children will be scrapped from next year, the Assembly Education Minister has said.
12 June 2006
Deadline set for decision on academic selection process
The government has today put off the final decision on removing the academic selection process until the restoration of devolution deadline is reached on November 24.
Deadline set for decision on academic selection process
The government has today put off the final decision on removing the academic selection process until the restoration of devolution deadline is reached on November 24.
02 March 2010
Post Primary Education In Focus
The education of children leaving primary schools in NI was again in the spotlight yesterday.
Post Primary Education In Focus
The education of children leaving primary schools in NI was again in the spotlight yesterday.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
