Menu
19/05/2010
NHS Whistleblowers 'Face Sanctions': BMJ
Despite laws to protect health service sector workers who wish to raise concerns about patient care, a BMJ investigation reveals that some NHS trusts still make it hard for staff to speak out.
The BMJ obtained 'whistleblowing' policy documents valid up to November 2009 from 118 of the 122 NHS foundation trusts.
The documents were then compared against six standards set out in guidance produced by Public Concern at Work, an independent authority on public interest whistleblowing that also runs a helpline for NHS staff.
These include taking malpractice seriously, giving staff the option to raise concerns outside of the trust, and respecting the confidentiality of staff raising concerns.
The results, published on the British Medical Journal's website, bmj.com, show that some trusts do not have measures in place to protect whistleblowers.
Twenty two of the 118 trust policies do not give examples of types of concerns to be raised, while four do not mention the option for a person to raise concerns outside of the trust.
More than a third of trust policies say staff can go outside the trust with a concern, but insist that a person goes through management first. Some mention that staff must go to an outside organisation "in good faith" but warn that there may be disciplinary action if they go to them unjustifiably.
A fifth of trust policies do not specifically say they will respect the confidentiality of the whistleblower, or it is not clear that they will do, and 106 trusts mention sanctions against any malicious or false claims made.
Twenty two trusts mention "disciplinary" in their policies, a term unlikely to make potential whistleblowers comfortable in coming forward with a concern, while 30 trusts mention staff have a duty, implied duty, or loyalty to the trust as well as to patient confidentiality.
Commenting on the results, Peter Gooderham, a law lecturer at the University of Manchester, said trusts should give assurances of protecting the whistleblower’s confidentiality.
"It should be made clear that the finger won't be pointed at them if they take steps to raise a genuine concern," he commented.
He argues that policies need to be user friendly and encourage people to raise concerns. "We need some positive recognition for people who have raised concerns....they shouldn't be treated as troublemakers, ostracising them, suspending them from work, and so on," he wrote.
To address these issues, Public Concern at Work will launch a policy pack, developed in conjunction with a Social Partnership Forum working group, on whistleblowing for distribution throughout the NHS in June.
It also recommends that trusts audit, review, and check how their whistleblowing policies are performing in practice and promote their use to staff regularly.
The BMA is also aware of the problems that some whistleblowers can face with Dr Mark Porter, Chairman of the BMA Consultants' Committee, saying: "We get very concerned about doctors who fall foul of these whistleblowing policies while following their professional duty.
"Members continue to raise examples with us, and there are high profile cases, some of which take place in organisations that have good policies. The BMA will support members before, during and after they raise concerns.'
According to a BMA survey, around one in seven hospital doctors in England and Wales who reported concerns said that their trusts had indicated that by speaking up, their employment could be negatively affected.
(BMcC/GK)
The BMJ obtained 'whistleblowing' policy documents valid up to November 2009 from 118 of the 122 NHS foundation trusts.
The documents were then compared against six standards set out in guidance produced by Public Concern at Work, an independent authority on public interest whistleblowing that also runs a helpline for NHS staff.
These include taking malpractice seriously, giving staff the option to raise concerns outside of the trust, and respecting the confidentiality of staff raising concerns.
The results, published on the British Medical Journal's website, bmj.com, show that some trusts do not have measures in place to protect whistleblowers.
Twenty two of the 118 trust policies do not give examples of types of concerns to be raised, while four do not mention the option for a person to raise concerns outside of the trust.
More than a third of trust policies say staff can go outside the trust with a concern, but insist that a person goes through management first. Some mention that staff must go to an outside organisation "in good faith" but warn that there may be disciplinary action if they go to them unjustifiably.
A fifth of trust policies do not specifically say they will respect the confidentiality of the whistleblower, or it is not clear that they will do, and 106 trusts mention sanctions against any malicious or false claims made.
Twenty two trusts mention "disciplinary" in their policies, a term unlikely to make potential whistleblowers comfortable in coming forward with a concern, while 30 trusts mention staff have a duty, implied duty, or loyalty to the trust as well as to patient confidentiality.
Commenting on the results, Peter Gooderham, a law lecturer at the University of Manchester, said trusts should give assurances of protecting the whistleblower’s confidentiality.
"It should be made clear that the finger won't be pointed at them if they take steps to raise a genuine concern," he commented.
He argues that policies need to be user friendly and encourage people to raise concerns. "We need some positive recognition for people who have raised concerns....they shouldn't be treated as troublemakers, ostracising them, suspending them from work, and so on," he wrote.
To address these issues, Public Concern at Work will launch a policy pack, developed in conjunction with a Social Partnership Forum working group, on whistleblowing for distribution throughout the NHS in June.
It also recommends that trusts audit, review, and check how their whistleblowing policies are performing in practice and promote their use to staff regularly.
The BMA is also aware of the problems that some whistleblowers can face with Dr Mark Porter, Chairman of the BMA Consultants' Committee, saying: "We get very concerned about doctors who fall foul of these whistleblowing policies while following their professional duty.
"Members continue to raise examples with us, and there are high profile cases, some of which take place in organisations that have good policies. The BMA will support members before, during and after they raise concerns.'
According to a BMA survey, around one in seven hospital doctors in England and Wales who reported concerns said that their trusts had indicated that by speaking up, their employment could be negatively affected.
(BMcC/GK)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
04 January 2005
Five further health trusts make foundation grade
Following approval by the independent regulatory body, five Trusts have been granted Foundation Trust status.
Five further health trusts make foundation grade
Following approval by the independent regulatory body, five Trusts have been granted Foundation Trust status.
08 March 2010
Hospitals 'Quality Of Care' Slammed
More than half of hospital trusts inspected last year provided the public with incorrect information on their performance and quality of care. A Panorama investigation will reveal the news tonight in Panorama: Trust Us – We're An NHS Hospital on BBC One, at 8.30pm.
Hospitals 'Quality Of Care' Slammed
More than half of hospital trusts inspected last year provided the public with incorrect information on their performance and quality of care. A Panorama investigation will reveal the news tonight in Panorama: Trust Us – We're An NHS Hospital on BBC One, at 8.30pm.
13 May 2009
NHS Criticised Over Baby P 'Systematic Failings'
The National Health Service (NHS) has come under fire for a catalogue of "systematic failings" which contributed to Baby P's death.
NHS Criticised Over Baby P 'Systematic Failings'
The National Health Service (NHS) has come under fire for a catalogue of "systematic failings" which contributed to Baby P's death.
27 July 2005
Report reveals fewer hospitals receiving top rating
Fewer UK hospitals are receiving excellent ratings, according to the latest annual star ratings report from the Healthcare Commission. The latest figures showed that there was a drop in the number of acute hospital trusts achieving the top three-star rating for the first time in four years.
Report reveals fewer hospitals receiving top rating
Fewer UK hospitals are receiving excellent ratings, according to the latest annual star ratings report from the Healthcare Commission. The latest figures showed that there was a drop in the number of acute hospital trusts achieving the top three-star rating for the first time in four years.
15 October 2009
Concerns Raised On 'Weak' NHS Trusts
The Care Quality Commission (CQC) has raised doubts about 20 NHS trusts in England rated "weak" on quality, and a further 27 that have not been higher than "fair" for quality and Financial Management in the last four years.
Concerns Raised On 'Weak' NHS Trusts
The Care Quality Commission (CQC) has raised doubts about 20 NHS trusts in England rated "weak" on quality, and a further 27 that have not been higher than "fair" for quality and Financial Management in the last four years.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A very mild, but mostly cloudy day, although with some bright or sunny spells. It will be mostly dry in the morning, but a little patchy light rain or drizzle at times in the afternoon. Maximum temperature 14 °C.Tonight:A band of heavier rain will move east during the evening before clearing eastwards after midnight. then mostly dry through the early hours, but a little rain towards dawn. Minimum temperature 8 °C.
