Menu
15/10/2010
Extending Patient Choice 'Challenging'
Government plans to introduce wider choice and shared decision making within the NHS may be challenging to implement, says an expert on bmj.com today.
In its new plans for the NHS, the government wants to extend the offer of choice beyond what is currently available to include choice of specialist team, choice of general practice, and choice of treatment.
Angela Coulter, Director of Global Initiatives at the Foundation for Informed Medical Decision Making in the USA reviews the evidence and finds that choice has intrinsic value to patients. The evidence suggests that most patients like the idea that they should be offered a choice of provider and, in particular, a choice of treatment. However, it also suggests reluctance on the part of clinicians to offer a choice.
Since choice of treatment location was introduced in 2005, regular surveys have shown that patients’ awareness of the right to choose and general practitioners’ willingness to offer a choice have been slow to grow. More recent evidence confirms that most patients are keen on having a choice, even if they choose to remain at their local hospital, but many general practitioners remain ambivalent or antagonistic to the idea.
Clinicians have also been slow to respond to the evidence that most patients want to participate in decisions about their care, citing concerns about time constraints and doubts about its relevance to their patients, said Coulter.
The government’s new commitment to shared decision making tackles this directly and implies a challenge to entrenched attitudes and the need for big change in practice styles.
There is also little evidence that patients use performance data to inform their decisions, despite the government’s promise to publish more detailed information on patients’ experience, health outcomes, and safety indicators.
Coulter commented: “The evidence reviewed here suggests a reluctance on the part of general practitioners, coupled with a gulf between what patients say they want and what general practitioners believe they want.
“This is worrying because the government’s plans assume that general practitioners understand patients’ preferences and will commission services accordingly.”
She believes implementation of the plans for extending choice will be “a major test of the effectiveness of general practitioner led commissioning.”
This view is supported in a second article which looks at how to better involve patients in decisions about their care. Professor Glyn Elwyn and colleagues say that, despite considerable interest in shared decision making, and clear evidence of benefit, implementation within the NHS “has proved difficult and slow.”
High quality decision aids for many conditions already exist, but the challenge is how to embed the tools, attitudes and skills required into routine practice. This will require substantial investment and collaboration between many agencies but, if created, “it would go a long way towards developing a patient led revolution in health care – one that is fuelled by evidence,” they concluded.
(BMcN)
In its new plans for the NHS, the government wants to extend the offer of choice beyond what is currently available to include choice of specialist team, choice of general practice, and choice of treatment.
Angela Coulter, Director of Global Initiatives at the Foundation for Informed Medical Decision Making in the USA reviews the evidence and finds that choice has intrinsic value to patients. The evidence suggests that most patients like the idea that they should be offered a choice of provider and, in particular, a choice of treatment. However, it also suggests reluctance on the part of clinicians to offer a choice.
Since choice of treatment location was introduced in 2005, regular surveys have shown that patients’ awareness of the right to choose and general practitioners’ willingness to offer a choice have been slow to grow. More recent evidence confirms that most patients are keen on having a choice, even if they choose to remain at their local hospital, but many general practitioners remain ambivalent or antagonistic to the idea.
Clinicians have also been slow to respond to the evidence that most patients want to participate in decisions about their care, citing concerns about time constraints and doubts about its relevance to their patients, said Coulter.
The government’s new commitment to shared decision making tackles this directly and implies a challenge to entrenched attitudes and the need for big change in practice styles.
There is also little evidence that patients use performance data to inform their decisions, despite the government’s promise to publish more detailed information on patients’ experience, health outcomes, and safety indicators.
Coulter commented: “The evidence reviewed here suggests a reluctance on the part of general practitioners, coupled with a gulf between what patients say they want and what general practitioners believe they want.
“This is worrying because the government’s plans assume that general practitioners understand patients’ preferences and will commission services accordingly.”
She believes implementation of the plans for extending choice will be “a major test of the effectiveness of general practitioner led commissioning.”
This view is supported in a second article which looks at how to better involve patients in decisions about their care. Professor Glyn Elwyn and colleagues say that, despite considerable interest in shared decision making, and clear evidence of benefit, implementation within the NHS “has proved difficult and slow.”
High quality decision aids for many conditions already exist, but the challenge is how to embed the tools, attitudes and skills required into routine practice. This will require substantial investment and collaboration between many agencies but, if created, “it would go a long way towards developing a patient led revolution in health care – one that is fuelled by evidence,” they concluded.
(BMcN)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
10 February 2004
NHS to exchange targets for greater patient choice, says Reid
The NHS will have fewer performance targets and a stronger emphasis on the quality of patient care from 2005-2006, Health Secretary John Reid announced today.
NHS to exchange targets for greater patient choice, says Reid
The NHS will have fewer performance targets and a stronger emphasis on the quality of patient care from 2005-2006, Health Secretary John Reid announced today.
09 December 2003
Patient choice at forefront of government's NHS plans
The government has unveiled plans aimed at relieving the strain on doctors and increasing choice for NHS patients, through the 'Building on the Best' Command Paper presented before Parliament today.
Patient choice at forefront of government's NHS plans
The government has unveiled plans aimed at relieving the strain on doctors and increasing choice for NHS patients, through the 'Building on the Best' Command Paper presented before Parliament today.
27 June 2012
Oldham Explosion Inquiry Continues
Oldham Council and a range of partner organisations across all sectors are continuing work to assist residents affected by Tuesday's explosion in Shaw. Police now say the death of the two-year-old, named as Jamie Heaton, is being treated as suspicious. The explosion in Buckley Street, also left a 27-year-old man in hospital with burns.
Oldham Explosion Inquiry Continues
Oldham Council and a range of partner organisations across all sectors are continuing work to assist residents affected by Tuesday's explosion in Shaw. Police now say the death of the two-year-old, named as Jamie Heaton, is being treated as suspicious. The explosion in Buckley Street, also left a 27-year-old man in hospital with burns.
16 February 2005
Howard launches plan to tackle 'MRSA 'superbug scandal'
Conservative leader Michael Howard has launched plans to grant hospital matrons new powers to help halt the spread of the MRSA 'superbug'. Speaking at the launch of his party's health manifesto, Mr Howard, criticised the government's attempts to stop the spread of the infection.
Howard launches plan to tackle 'MRSA 'superbug scandal'
Conservative leader Michael Howard has launched plans to grant hospital matrons new powers to help halt the spread of the MRSA 'superbug'. Speaking at the launch of his party's health manifesto, Mr Howard, criticised the government's attempts to stop the spread of the infection.
14 November 2011
Lansley Criticised Over Minimum Wait Ban
Health Secretary Andrew Lansley has come under criticism on Monday after banning Primary Care Trusts (PCTs) from enforcing minimum waiting times on referrals. Mr Lanley claimed the move was in the interests of "patient choice", while he also announced caps on operations that "do not take account of the healthcare needs of individual patients".
Lansley Criticised Over Minimum Wait Ban
Health Secretary Andrew Lansley has come under criticism on Monday after banning Primary Care Trusts (PCTs) from enforcing minimum waiting times on referrals. Mr Lanley claimed the move was in the interests of "patient choice", while he also announced caps on operations that "do not take account of the healthcare needs of individual patients".
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
