Menu
23/11/2010
Homebuilder Fined After Forklift Crush Death
A leading homebuilder and one of its construction plant operators have been fined £14,500 after an incident on a site in Banbury left one man dead and two others severely injured.
In January 2008, three ceramic tilers, Michael Whateley, his brother Robert Whateley, and Paul Keen, all from Northampton, were waiting in a car for a building plot to be unlocked in Broughton Road, Banbury, in Oxfordshire.
Near the car, Keith Payne, from Banbury, was undertaking routine checks of a telescopic materials handler - a forklift truck with an extendable arm or boom commonly referred to as a telehandler.
Mr Payne climbed into the cab of the truck, raised and then fully extended the unloaded boom of the telehandler in what he considered to be part of his routine daily checks. However, the truck tipped over and the forks at the end of the boom landed on the car, crushing the roof of the vehicle.
Michael Whateley died from his injuries. Robert Whateley suffered fractures to his spine, and a brain injury. Paul Keen suffered neck and spinal injuries, a broken ankle, broken ribs and a fractured breastbone.
At the time of the incident, Linden Limited was the principal contractor on the site and Mr Payne worked as a self-employed construction plant operator.
The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) investigation showed the incident was preventable if Mr Payne had followed the operating instructions in the machinery manual and ensured the telehandler was being operated on firm level ground.
Also, Linden Limited failed to ensure the equipment was maintained properly and tyre pressures were found to be lower than recommended.
Following the hearing, HSE Inspector James Powell said: “This was a horrific accident that was totally avoidable. Construction sites have inherent risks, and even rough-terrain lift trucks have strict operational limits that need to be observed. With competent operation and suitable maintenance, tragedies like this should not happen.
“Lives have been destroyed here and sentencing must serve to remind all employers and employees of their duties and responsibilities while using this type of machinery.”
Keith Payne, from Oxfordshire, was found guilty of breaching the Health and Safety at Work Act. He was fined £7,000.
Linden Limited pleaded guilty to the provision and use of work equipment regulations. The company was fined £7,500 and ordered to pay costs of £25,000.
(BMcN/GK)
In January 2008, three ceramic tilers, Michael Whateley, his brother Robert Whateley, and Paul Keen, all from Northampton, were waiting in a car for a building plot to be unlocked in Broughton Road, Banbury, in Oxfordshire.
Near the car, Keith Payne, from Banbury, was undertaking routine checks of a telescopic materials handler - a forklift truck with an extendable arm or boom commonly referred to as a telehandler.
Mr Payne climbed into the cab of the truck, raised and then fully extended the unloaded boom of the telehandler in what he considered to be part of his routine daily checks. However, the truck tipped over and the forks at the end of the boom landed on the car, crushing the roof of the vehicle.
Michael Whateley died from his injuries. Robert Whateley suffered fractures to his spine, and a brain injury. Paul Keen suffered neck and spinal injuries, a broken ankle, broken ribs and a fractured breastbone.
At the time of the incident, Linden Limited was the principal contractor on the site and Mr Payne worked as a self-employed construction plant operator.
The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) investigation showed the incident was preventable if Mr Payne had followed the operating instructions in the machinery manual and ensured the telehandler was being operated on firm level ground.
Also, Linden Limited failed to ensure the equipment was maintained properly and tyre pressures were found to be lower than recommended.
Following the hearing, HSE Inspector James Powell said: “This was a horrific accident that was totally avoidable. Construction sites have inherent risks, and even rough-terrain lift trucks have strict operational limits that need to be observed. With competent operation and suitable maintenance, tragedies like this should not happen.
“Lives have been destroyed here and sentencing must serve to remind all employers and employees of their duties and responsibilities while using this type of machinery.”
Keith Payne, from Oxfordshire, was found guilty of breaching the Health and Safety at Work Act. He was fined £7,000.
Linden Limited pleaded guilty to the provision and use of work equipment regulations. The company was fined £7,500 and ordered to pay costs of £25,000.
(BMcN/GK)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
24 April 2015
Police Searching Lake In Nicola Payne Investigation
Police investigating the disappearance of Nicola Payne in 1991 are searching an area of water within Coombe Abbey Country Park. It is understood that Home Office scientists have already conducted a preliminary sonar examination of the lake, and will take focus on a stretch of shallow water.
Police Searching Lake In Nicola Payne Investigation
Police investigating the disappearance of Nicola Payne in 1991 are searching an area of water within Coombe Abbey Country Park. It is understood that Home Office scientists have already conducted a preliminary sonar examination of the lake, and will take focus on a stretch of shallow water.
30 October 2014
Father Of Sarah Payne Dies Aged 45
Michael Payne, the father of murdered schoolgirl Sarah Payne, has died. Mr Payne, 45, developed a drinking problem after his daughter was brutally murdered in West Sussex in 2000. He was found dead at his home in Kent on Monday. His daughter Charlotte posted on Facebook: "No matter what happened and how many mistakes we all made.
Father Of Sarah Payne Dies Aged 45
Michael Payne, the father of murdered schoolgirl Sarah Payne, has died. Mr Payne, 45, developed a drinking problem after his daughter was brutally murdered in West Sussex in 2000. He was found dead at his home in Kent on Monday. His daughter Charlotte posted on Facebook: "No matter what happened and how many mistakes we all made.
01 May 2014
Two Rearrested In Nicola Payne Case
Police investigating the disappearance of Nicola Payne have rearrested two people. A man, aged 50, and a 51-year-old woman are currently on police bail in connection with the inquiry. Ms Payne, 18 and a mother-of-one, was last seen on 14 December 1991 in the Henley Green area.
Two Rearrested In Nicola Payne Case
Police investigating the disappearance of Nicola Payne have rearrested two people. A man, aged 50, and a 51-year-old woman are currently on police bail in connection with the inquiry. Ms Payne, 18 and a mother-of-one, was last seen on 14 December 1991 in the Henley Green area.
21 June 2012
Two Men Arrested In Connection With Nicola Payne Disappearance
Two men have been arrested in connection with the disappearance of Nicola Payne in Coventry 21 years ago. Police have now been given more time to question the two men as part of the renewed investigation. Nicola Payne was 18 when she went missing from the Wood End area in December 1991. She had a six-month-old son.
Two Men Arrested In Connection With Nicola Payne Disappearance
Two men have been arrested in connection with the disappearance of Nicola Payne in Coventry 21 years ago. Police have now been given more time to question the two men as part of the renewed investigation. Nicola Payne was 18 when she went missing from the Wood End area in December 1991. She had a six-month-old son.
20 June 2012
'Areas Of Interest' Discovered In Nicola Payne Search
Police investigating the disappearance of a Nicola Payne, last seen 21 years ago, said they had discovered "areas of interest" in woodland being searched. The Coventry mother went missing from the Wood End area in December 1991. She was 18 and had a six-month-old son.
'Areas Of Interest' Discovered In Nicola Payne Search
Police investigating the disappearance of a Nicola Payne, last seen 21 years ago, said they had discovered "areas of interest" in woodland being searched. The Coventry mother went missing from the Wood End area in December 1991. She was 18 and had a six-month-old son.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherThis Evening and Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
