Menu
21/06/2012
Census Faces Right To Privacy Challenge In High Court
Two men who say that the 2011 census was unlawful because of a provision in the act that governs it which allows data to be passed to third parties, will bring their case in front of a high court judge on Thursday.
In a judicial review, lawyers representing a British Muslim and an Afghan refugee will argue that the Office for National Statistics' decision to grant a data processing contract to a UK subsidiary of the US defence contractor Lockheed Martin breaches the two men's right to privacy as guaranteed by the European convention on human rights.
The hearing before Mr Justice Beatson at the high court in Birmingham comes as more than 250 people have been prosecuted for failing to fill in the census.
The 2007 Statistics and Registration Service Act protects the privacy of information gathered for the census.
However an exemption was added that allows information to be handed over if the requesting state requires it for a criminal investigation.
In addition to this, under the US's Patriot Act, the American government can compel any US company to hand over information it holds for the purposes of a criminal investigation.
Lawyers for the two men will argue that Lockheed Martin's UK subsidiary would also be subject to that demand.
"It may be inadvertent, but there is a double loyalty," said Ramby de Mello, the lawyer representing the two men at the hearing. "We believe that the subsidiary and its parent company, which are not public bodies, are outside the reach of the Human Rights Act and the Data Protection Act."
"I think that the reason the exemption about disclosure was inserted into the act was to open out the tendering process to US companies who otherwise would not have been competitive," said de Mello. "If we are correct, then it would affect every other tendering process."
A spokesman for the ONS, the executive office of the UK Statistics Authority, said it would comment after the hearing.
(H)
In a judicial review, lawyers representing a British Muslim and an Afghan refugee will argue that the Office for National Statistics' decision to grant a data processing contract to a UK subsidiary of the US defence contractor Lockheed Martin breaches the two men's right to privacy as guaranteed by the European convention on human rights.
The hearing before Mr Justice Beatson at the high court in Birmingham comes as more than 250 people have been prosecuted for failing to fill in the census.
The 2007 Statistics and Registration Service Act protects the privacy of information gathered for the census.
However an exemption was added that allows information to be handed over if the requesting state requires it for a criminal investigation.
In addition to this, under the US's Patriot Act, the American government can compel any US company to hand over information it holds for the purposes of a criminal investigation.
Lawyers for the two men will argue that Lockheed Martin's UK subsidiary would also be subject to that demand.
"It may be inadvertent, but there is a double loyalty," said Ramby de Mello, the lawyer representing the two men at the hearing. "We believe that the subsidiary and its parent company, which are not public bodies, are outside the reach of the Human Rights Act and the Data Protection Act."
"I think that the reason the exemption about disclosure was inserted into the act was to open out the tendering process to US companies who otherwise would not have been competitive," said de Mello. "If we are correct, then it would affect every other tendering process."
A spokesman for the ONS, the executive office of the UK Statistics Authority, said it would comment after the hearing.
(H)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
09 March 2010
Bilingual Juries 'Cannot Outweigh' Justice
Selecting juries randomly from the community outweighs the benefits of selecting exclusively bilingual juries for some trials in Wales, the Government has said. The decision announced today, follows a consultation on whether to select juries for certain criminal trials in Wales, all of whose members would be bilingual in Welsh and English.
Bilingual Juries 'Cannot Outweigh' Justice
Selecting juries randomly from the community outweighs the benefits of selecting exclusively bilingual juries for some trials in Wales, the Government has said. The decision announced today, follows a consultation on whether to select juries for certain criminal trials in Wales, all of whose members would be bilingual in Welsh and English.
25 February 2010
Pipe Bomb Maker Jailed
A man caught with a home-made pipe bomb and gun at his home in Gwent, Wales, has been jailed for three years, following an investigation counter terror police.
Pipe Bomb Maker Jailed
A man caught with a home-made pipe bomb and gun at his home in Gwent, Wales, has been jailed for three years, following an investigation counter terror police.
03 March 2004
Plans for regulating countryside access considered
Plans to look after important conservation sites and areas of high visitor pressure, when the new public right to walk on access land is introduced across England, were unveiled today by Rural Affairs Minister Alun Michael.
Plans for regulating countryside access considered
Plans to look after important conservation sites and areas of high visitor pressure, when the new public right to walk on access land is introduced across England, were unveiled today by Rural Affairs Minister Alun Michael.
05 May 2015
Four Men Arrested At Gatwick After Being Refused Entry To Turkey
Four men have been arrested at Gatwick Airport after returning to the UK when they were refused entry into Turkey. The Metropolitan Police said that the men, aged 32, 36, 37 and 38, had flown to Turkey last week, but had been refused entry at Antalya Airport.
Four Men Arrested At Gatwick After Being Refused Entry To Turkey
Four men have been arrested at Gatwick Airport after returning to the UK when they were refused entry into Turkey. The Metropolitan Police said that the men, aged 32, 36, 37 and 38, had flown to Turkey last week, but had been refused entry at Antalya Airport.
14 March 2013
Journalist Arrested In Hacking Investigation
Officers investigation alleged phone hacking have arrested three men and one woman on Thursday morning. They are thought to be journalists or former journalists at Mirror Group Newspapers. Scotland Yard said it had identified a suspected conspiracy to intercept telephone voicemails at the newspaper group.
Journalist Arrested In Hacking Investigation
Officers investigation alleged phone hacking have arrested three men and one woman on Thursday morning. They are thought to be journalists or former journalists at Mirror Group Newspapers. Scotland Yard said it had identified a suspected conspiracy to intercept telephone voicemails at the newspaper group.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
