Menu
24/09/2012
Tagging Has 'Little Effect On Cutting Offending Rates' Says Senior Police
A senior police officer has claimed that despite the almost £1bn spent on the electronic tagging of criminals over the past 13 years there has been little effect on cutting offending rates, offering little value for money and serving only to enrich two or three private security companies, one of which is G4S.
Former expert on tagging at the Association of Chief Police Officers, Chris Miller, who stood down as Hertfordshire's assistant chief constable last year, said that much of the potential of electronic monitoring to keep communities safe in Britain has not been realised.
In a foreword to a report by the Policy Exchange thinktank, published on Monday, he says: "The current contracting arrangements for electronic monitoring have all but squeezed innovation out of the picture and stifled progress."
"Electronic tag technology used in most cases today is hardly any different from what it was in 1989, when it was first used in the UK. The future arrangements must not be allowed to continue to hold us back," writes Miller.
He says the problem has centred on a "sclerotic, centrally controlled, top-down system that has enriched two or three large suppliers, that lacks the innovation and flexibility of international comparators and that fails to demonstrate either that it is value for money or that it does anything to reduce offending."
The Ministry of Justice has spent £963m on tagging contracts over the past 13 years. Two companies, Serco and G4S, have taken the bulk of the work, putting ankle and wrist tags on more than 100,000 offenders every year, mainly to monitor their compliance with night-time curfew orders which do little to cut reoffending during the day.
Ministry officials are about to invite bids for contracts for the next nine years, thought to be worth up to £3bn. The Policy Exchange report, Future of Corrections, says one in four police forces regards electronic tagging as ineffective.
"In the US there are a number of localised suppliers, meaning that the police and probation service are given the most up to date GPS technology to track the movements of a criminal 24/7," said Rory Geoghegan, the report's author.
He said in the US ankle bracelets had become smaller, smarter and more durable and were GPS-enabled so that police can pinpoint offenders' locations at all times, but the lack of competition in Britain meant the taxpayer was losing out.
"We desperately need to create a real market so that the police can get the technology they need to cut burglary, cut robbery and other crimes that have a massive impact on victims and community," he said.
(H)
Former expert on tagging at the Association of Chief Police Officers, Chris Miller, who stood down as Hertfordshire's assistant chief constable last year, said that much of the potential of electronic monitoring to keep communities safe in Britain has not been realised.
In a foreword to a report by the Policy Exchange thinktank, published on Monday, he says: "The current contracting arrangements for electronic monitoring have all but squeezed innovation out of the picture and stifled progress."
"Electronic tag technology used in most cases today is hardly any different from what it was in 1989, when it was first used in the UK. The future arrangements must not be allowed to continue to hold us back," writes Miller.
He says the problem has centred on a "sclerotic, centrally controlled, top-down system that has enriched two or three large suppliers, that lacks the innovation and flexibility of international comparators and that fails to demonstrate either that it is value for money or that it does anything to reduce offending."
The Ministry of Justice has spent £963m on tagging contracts over the past 13 years. Two companies, Serco and G4S, have taken the bulk of the work, putting ankle and wrist tags on more than 100,000 offenders every year, mainly to monitor their compliance with night-time curfew orders which do little to cut reoffending during the day.
Ministry officials are about to invite bids for contracts for the next nine years, thought to be worth up to £3bn. The Policy Exchange report, Future of Corrections, says one in four police forces regards electronic tagging as ineffective.
"In the US there are a number of localised suppliers, meaning that the police and probation service are given the most up to date GPS technology to track the movements of a criminal 24/7," said Rory Geoghegan, the report's author.
He said in the US ankle bracelets had become smaller, smarter and more durable and were GPS-enabled so that police can pinpoint offenders' locations at all times, but the lack of competition in Britain meant the taxpayer was losing out.
"We desperately need to create a real market so that the police can get the technology they need to cut burglary, cut robbery and other crimes that have a massive impact on victims and community," he said.
(H)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
22 March 2005
Terror suspect takes overdose
One of the recently released terror suspects has been treated in hospital after he took a drugs overdose. The High Court was told today that Abu Rideh, who was freed from Broadmoor earlier this month, following the introduction of the new Prevention of Terrorism Act, had been admitted to a London hospital at the weekend. He has since been released.
Terror suspect takes overdose
One of the recently released terror suspects has been treated in hospital after he took a drugs overdose. The High Court was told today that Abu Rideh, who was freed from Broadmoor earlier this month, following the introduction of the new Prevention of Terrorism Act, had been admitted to a London hospital at the weekend. He has since been released.
13 October 2005
Prisoner early release plan criticised
Home Office plans to release prisoners early under an electronic tagging scheme have sparked controversy. Under the plans, criminals sentenced to four years in prisons could be released after 18 months, while a two-year sentence would involve just six months in jail.
Prisoner early release plan criticised
Home Office plans to release prisoners early under an electronic tagging scheme have sparked controversy. Under the plans, criminals sentenced to four years in prisons could be released after 18 months, while a two-year sentence would involve just six months in jail.
23 January 2013
Corruption Report Reveals Police Steroid Use
An anti-corruption report has revealed that dozens of police officers are under investigation over use of anabolic steroids, allegedly supplied to them in gyms by criminals. Transparency International, an anti-corruption group, were commissioned to compile the report by the Association of Chief Police Officers (Acpo).
Corruption Report Reveals Police Steroid Use
An anti-corruption report has revealed that dozens of police officers are under investigation over use of anabolic steroids, allegedly supplied to them in gyms by criminals. Transparency International, an anti-corruption group, were commissioned to compile the report by the Association of Chief Police Officers (Acpo).
15 March 2012
Police Officers To Face Annual Fitness Test
Police officers could be due to face annual fitness tests with disciplinary procedures for offices that fail three times in a row. The recommendation is one of many made in an independent review commissioned by Home Secretary Theresa May to look at police pay and recruitment procedures.
Police Officers To Face Annual Fitness Test
Police officers could be due to face annual fitness tests with disciplinary procedures for offices that fail three times in a row. The recommendation is one of many made in an independent review commissioned by Home Secretary Theresa May to look at police pay and recruitment procedures.
19 June 2008
Detainees Escape Oxfordshire Detention Centre
Four immigration detainees have escaped an Oxfordshire centre overnight. Police hunting the fugitives have closed a road leading to Campsfield House in Kidlington and are searching the area. A Home Office spokesman said that seven detainees had managed to escape but three had been recaptured.
Detainees Escape Oxfordshire Detention Centre
Four immigration detainees have escaped an Oxfordshire centre overnight. Police hunting the fugitives have closed a road leading to Campsfield House in Kidlington and are searching the area. A Home Office spokesman said that seven detainees had managed to escape but three had been recaptured.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
