Menu
13/06/2003
Court rules in favour of Gulf War veteran
A British army veteran has won in his bid to be awarded a war pension after the High Court recognised that he had developed a condition resulting from his service during the 1991 Gulf War.
Former Parachute Regiment medic Shaun Rusling was discharged from the army on health grounds in 1995 and 'Gulf War Syndrome' was cited as the reason. When the former Para tried to claim his pension he was turned down on the basis that Gulf War Syndrome was not recognised by the MoD a generic medical condition.
However, while the court ruled in favour of former Mr Rusling today, it was isolated to the merits of that single case. Mr Justice Newman said that the ruling was not a recognition of the condition 'Gulf War Syndrome'.
In his judgment, Mr Justice Newman said: "This court is not in a position to express any views on the merits of the dispute as to whether, according to current medical research, Gulf War Syndrome is or is not a 'single medical entity'. It has not done so by this judgment."
Nonetheless, the case is a landmark ruling for veterans who believe they are suffering from a condition known as Gulf War Syndrome. It means that cases brought forward on an individual basis can be resolved successfully for the veteran.
Veterans groups claim that soldiers fell ill after they took a cocktail of drugs to protect them against the effects of chemical warfare. They allege that vaccinations against anthrax, pertussis, botulism, yellow fever, cholera and tetanus, and the issuing of NAPs tablets and anti-malaria tablets, contributed to the syndrome.
Also, veterans claim that they were exposed to organophosphates, depleted uranium munitions and contamination from burning oil wells – in addition to stresses of warfare – which also had a profound effect on their mental and physical wellbeing.
However, the MoD has said that on medical advice there is no evidence that Gulf War Syndrome exists.
Minister of State for the Armed Forces, Adam Ingram, said: "I must stress that the judgment was case-specific to Mr Rusling. The judge took pains to explain that he was not ruling on whether 'Gulf War Syndrome' exists. Shaun Rusling's pension, which he already receives, will not be affected by today's judgment."
Earlier today, an MoD spokesperson said: "We accept that some Gulf veterans have become ill and that many veterans believe this ill-health is related to their Gulf experience. There is no medical or scientific consensus about the causes of this ill health, and we remain open-minded about the various causes that have been suggested.
"The overwhelming consensus of medical and scientific opinion is that the symptoms reported by some Gulf veterans do not constitute a discrete medical disorder or syndrome. The MoD's position must always be based on the best available science."
(GMcG)
Former Parachute Regiment medic Shaun Rusling was discharged from the army on health grounds in 1995 and 'Gulf War Syndrome' was cited as the reason. When the former Para tried to claim his pension he was turned down on the basis that Gulf War Syndrome was not recognised by the MoD a generic medical condition.
However, while the court ruled in favour of former Mr Rusling today, it was isolated to the merits of that single case. Mr Justice Newman said that the ruling was not a recognition of the condition 'Gulf War Syndrome'.
In his judgment, Mr Justice Newman said: "This court is not in a position to express any views on the merits of the dispute as to whether, according to current medical research, Gulf War Syndrome is or is not a 'single medical entity'. It has not done so by this judgment."
Nonetheless, the case is a landmark ruling for veterans who believe they are suffering from a condition known as Gulf War Syndrome. It means that cases brought forward on an individual basis can be resolved successfully for the veteran.
Veterans groups claim that soldiers fell ill after they took a cocktail of drugs to protect them against the effects of chemical warfare. They allege that vaccinations against anthrax, pertussis, botulism, yellow fever, cholera and tetanus, and the issuing of NAPs tablets and anti-malaria tablets, contributed to the syndrome.
Also, veterans claim that they were exposed to organophosphates, depleted uranium munitions and contamination from burning oil wells – in addition to stresses of warfare – which also had a profound effect on their mental and physical wellbeing.
However, the MoD has said that on medical advice there is no evidence that Gulf War Syndrome exists.
Minister of State for the Armed Forces, Adam Ingram, said: "I must stress that the judgment was case-specific to Mr Rusling. The judge took pains to explain that he was not ruling on whether 'Gulf War Syndrome' exists. Shaun Rusling's pension, which he already receives, will not be affected by today's judgment."
Earlier today, an MoD spokesperson said: "We accept that some Gulf veterans have become ill and that many veterans believe this ill-health is related to their Gulf experience. There is no medical or scientific consensus about the causes of this ill health, and we remain open-minded about the various causes that have been suggested.
"The overwhelming consensus of medical and scientific opinion is that the symptoms reported by some Gulf veterans do not constitute a discrete medical disorder or syndrome. The MoD's position must always be based on the best available science."
(GMcG)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
09 April 2008
Bradley Jailed For Multiple Murders
David Bradley, an ex-soldier who killed four members of his family, will serve at least 15 years in jail. Bradley was sentenced to four life sentences at Newcastle Crown Court. Bradley, 41, shot his uncle, aunt and two cousins at close range with a handgun he reportedly smuggled back from Bosnia while serving in the Army, in July 2006.
Bradley Jailed For Multiple Murders
David Bradley, an ex-soldier who killed four members of his family, will serve at least 15 years in jail. Bradley was sentenced to four life sentences at Newcastle Crown Court. Bradley, 41, shot his uncle, aunt and two cousins at close range with a handgun he reportedly smuggled back from Bosnia while serving in the Army, in July 2006.
10 November 2003
Legion urges public inquiry into Gulf War vaccinations
On the eve of Armistice Day, the Royal British Legion has repeated its calls for a public inquiry into the government’s administration of vaccines to troops deployed in the first Gulf War.
Legion urges public inquiry into Gulf War vaccinations
On the eve of Armistice Day, the Royal British Legion has repeated its calls for a public inquiry into the government’s administration of vaccines to troops deployed in the first Gulf War.
27 January 2010
Goldsmith Before Iraq Inquiry
The Government's former chief legal adviser Lord Goldsmith did change his stance on the legality of the Iraq war prior to the invasion, he admitted today. Lord Goldsmith, the ex-Attorney General, said his first ruling that a second UN resolution was necessary had been "too cautious".
Goldsmith Before Iraq Inquiry
The Government's former chief legal adviser Lord Goldsmith did change his stance on the legality of the Iraq war prior to the invasion, he admitted today. Lord Goldsmith, the ex-Attorney General, said his first ruling that a second UN resolution was necessary had been "too cautious".
08 May 2003
Returning UK forces to face medical screenings
All of the UK's 45,000 military personnel will face medical screenings after returning from the Gulf, the government has announced today.
Returning UK forces to face medical screenings
All of the UK's 45,000 military personnel will face medical screenings after returning from the Gulf, the government has announced today.
02 April 2003
French anti-war protesters vandalise British war cemetery
There has been widespread disgust voiced today after anti-war graffiti was daubed across a war memorial in France commemorating the sacrifice of 11,000 Commonwealth troops in the First World War.
French anti-war protesters vandalise British war cemetery
There has been widespread disgust voiced today after anti-war graffiti was daubed across a war memorial in France commemorating the sacrifice of 11,000 Commonwealth troops in the First World War.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A very mild, but mostly cloudy day, although with some bright or sunny spells. It will be mostly dry in the morning, but a little patchy light rain or drizzle at times in the afternoon. Maximum temperature 14 °C.Tonight:A band of heavier rain will move east during the evening before clearing eastwards after midnight. then mostly dry through the early hours, but a little rain towards dawn. Minimum temperature 8 °C.
