Menu
07/07/2003
MPs clear Campbell amid questioning of WMD claims
MPs have cleared Alastair Campbell of “sexing up” a crucial intelligence report but have agreed that too much credence was put on certain claims about Iraq’s weapons capability.
Noting that investigations in Iraq are still proceeding, the cross-party foreign affairs committee has ruled that claims that Iraq could employ biological or chemical weapons within 45 minutes should not have been played up to such an extent by the government in the run up to the conflict with Iraq.
Contrary to claims made by the BBC, they further found that “Alastair Campbell did not exert or seek to exert improper influence on the drafting of the September dossier”.
The committee’s report stated: “We conclude that the 45 minutes claim did not warrant the prominence given to it in the dossier, because it was based on intelligence from a single, uncorroborated source. We recommend that the Government explain why the claim was given such prominence.”
However, the MPs concluded that it was “wrong for Alastair Campbell or any Special Adviser to have chaired a meeting on an intelligence matter” and recommended that this practice cease.
The foreign affairs committee concluded that in all probability the claims made in the September dossier were “well founded on the basis of intelligence then available". The committee went on to note that the language used in the dossier was “in places more assertive” than that usually reserved for use in intelligence documents of its type.
Today's report made a number of recommendations including that BBC correspondent Andrew Gilligan’s contacts be “thoroughly investigated”.
The MPs were also highly critical of the “plagiarism” of work included in the intelligence briefing dossier without attribution, and of subsequent amendments to the work, which were made without either highlighting the changes or the assent of the author.
Among the recommendations included in the MP’s report was that all documents submitted to parliament to explain foreign policy should be signed off, and where appropriate, include sources and attribution.
Foreign Secretary Jack Straw called on the BBC to issue an immediate apology, claiming that the BBC had “got it wrong”.
However, BBC director of news Richard Sambrook pointed out that there were big questions to be answered on both the 45-minute claim and on the assertiveness of the language used in the September dossier.
Conservative and Liberal Democrat MPs have called for a full judicial inquiry into the issues surrounding the WMD dossier in September 2002 and a later dossier produced in February 2003.
(SP)
Noting that investigations in Iraq are still proceeding, the cross-party foreign affairs committee has ruled that claims that Iraq could employ biological or chemical weapons within 45 minutes should not have been played up to such an extent by the government in the run up to the conflict with Iraq.
Contrary to claims made by the BBC, they further found that “Alastair Campbell did not exert or seek to exert improper influence on the drafting of the September dossier”.
The committee’s report stated: “We conclude that the 45 minutes claim did not warrant the prominence given to it in the dossier, because it was based on intelligence from a single, uncorroborated source. We recommend that the Government explain why the claim was given such prominence.”
However, the MPs concluded that it was “wrong for Alastair Campbell or any Special Adviser to have chaired a meeting on an intelligence matter” and recommended that this practice cease.
The foreign affairs committee concluded that in all probability the claims made in the September dossier were “well founded on the basis of intelligence then available". The committee went on to note that the language used in the dossier was “in places more assertive” than that usually reserved for use in intelligence documents of its type.
Today's report made a number of recommendations including that BBC correspondent Andrew Gilligan’s contacts be “thoroughly investigated”.
The MPs were also highly critical of the “plagiarism” of work included in the intelligence briefing dossier without attribution, and of subsequent amendments to the work, which were made without either highlighting the changes or the assent of the author.
Among the recommendations included in the MP’s report was that all documents submitted to parliament to explain foreign policy should be signed off, and where appropriate, include sources and attribution.
Foreign Secretary Jack Straw called on the BBC to issue an immediate apology, claiming that the BBC had “got it wrong”.
However, BBC director of news Richard Sambrook pointed out that there were big questions to be answered on both the 45-minute claim and on the assertiveness of the language used in the September dossier.
Conservative and Liberal Democrat MPs have called for a full judicial inquiry into the issues surrounding the WMD dossier in September 2002 and a later dossier produced in February 2003.
(SP)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
30 May 2003
Blair rejects weapons dossier doctoring claim
Tony Blair has rejected suggestions that a Government dossier on Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction was rewritten to make it “sexier”, branding the claims “completely absurd”.
Blair rejects weapons dossier doctoring claim
Tony Blair has rejected suggestions that a Government dossier on Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction was rewritten to make it “sexier”, branding the claims “completely absurd”.
03 March 2015
Footballer Released On Bail Over Underage Sex Claims
England and Sunderland footballer, Adam Johnson, has been released on bail after being arrested on suspicion of having sexual activity with a 15-year-old girl. The footballer, 27, was questioned by Durham Police on Monday. Sunderland AFC have suspended the player pending the outcome of the investigation.
Footballer Released On Bail Over Underage Sex Claims
England and Sunderland footballer, Adam Johnson, has been released on bail after being arrested on suspicion of having sexual activity with a 15-year-old girl. The footballer, 27, was questioned by Durham Police on Monday. Sunderland AFC have suspended the player pending the outcome of the investigation.
23 April 2012
Consumers Told To Make PPI Claims Directly
A summit will be held today aiming to shed light on the cost of using claims management companies for payment protection insurance (PPI) claims.
Consumers Told To Make PPI Claims Directly
A summit will be held today aiming to shed light on the cost of using claims management companies for payment protection insurance (PPI) claims.
15 November 2011
Business To Benefit From Express Patents
The Government has confirmed a new small claims service at the patent court to help small and medium sized businesses protect their copyright, patents, trade marks and designs. Currently small firms have to pay high costs and undergo lengthy procedures to bring claims against those who infringe their Intellectual Property (IP) rights.
Business To Benefit From Express Patents
The Government has confirmed a new small claims service at the patent court to help small and medium sized businesses protect their copyright, patents, trade marks and designs. Currently small firms have to pay high costs and undergo lengthy procedures to bring claims against those who infringe their Intellectual Property (IP) rights.
21 January 2008
Afganistan Conflict Claims 87th UK Soldier's Life
Another soldier has been killed in southern Afghanistan, the Ministry of Defence (MoD) has said. The death brings the number of UK troops killed on operations in Afghanistan since 2001 to 87. He was killed and several others were injured when their vehicle was blown up by a mine 3km (1.8 miles) north east of Musa Qala, the MoD statement said.
Afganistan Conflict Claims 87th UK Soldier's Life
Another soldier has been killed in southern Afghanistan, the Ministry of Defence (MoD) has said. The death brings the number of UK troops killed on operations in Afghanistan since 2001 to 87. He was killed and several others were injured when their vehicle was blown up by a mine 3km (1.8 miles) north east of Musa Qala, the MoD statement said.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherThis Evening and Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
