Menu
09/11/2005
Blair defeated on terror vote
Tony Blair has been handed the first defeat of his Premiership as MPs voted against controversial plans to increase the maximum detention period for terror suspects to 90 days.
The government lost the vote by 322 votes to 291 - a majority of 31.
The vote was expected to be tight. Chancellor Gordon Brown and Foreign Secretary Jack Straw were both recalled from foreign trips – in Israel and Russia, respectively - to return to Parliament for today’s crucial vote on the Terrorism Bill.
Mr Blair had remained confident all week that MPs will back the detention measures.
Last week, the Bill narrowly avoided defeat, passing its second reading by a majority of just one. Home Secretary Charles Clarke had appeared to hint at compromise with an offer of all-party talks on the detention plans. However, the government pledged to stand firm on the 90-day proposal following a meeting of the Parliamentary Labour Party on Monday evening.
Mr Clarke did, however, propose a ‘sunset clause’, allowing the legislation to be examined again by Parliament in a year’s time.
Both the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats were opposed to the 90-day detention proposal. The Liberal Democrats want the maximum detention period for terror suspects to remain at the current level of 14 days, while the Conservatives want it increased to no more than 28 days.
Mr Blair made an appeal to MPs to back the Bill in the Commons today, saying it was the “duty of every member of this House” to back the plans.
The Prime Minister also said that two terror plots had been foiled since the July 7 attacks in London, but he did not specify any details.
However, he did address the possible defeat of the Bill, saying: “Sometimes it is better to lose and do the right thing than win and do the wrong thing.”
There were heated exchanges between Mr Blair and the Conservative leader Michael Howard and Liberal Democrat leader Charles Kennedy during Prime Minister’s question time. Both party leaders questioned the need to hold suspects for ninety days, while Mr Howard warned that minority ethnic communities could be alienated by the legislation.
Mr Blair said: “We are not living in a police state, but we are living in a country that faces a real and serious threat of terrorism.”
He told Mr Howard that he and his colleagues would have to make their decision today. He said: “We have made ours. We believe it’s necessary to protect our country from terrorism and I’m only sorry you don’t agree.”
MPs are now voting on a proposal, tabled by Labour MP David Winnick, to increase the maximum detention time to 28 days.
(KMcA/GB)
The government lost the vote by 322 votes to 291 - a majority of 31.
The vote was expected to be tight. Chancellor Gordon Brown and Foreign Secretary Jack Straw were both recalled from foreign trips – in Israel and Russia, respectively - to return to Parliament for today’s crucial vote on the Terrorism Bill.
Mr Blair had remained confident all week that MPs will back the detention measures.
Last week, the Bill narrowly avoided defeat, passing its second reading by a majority of just one. Home Secretary Charles Clarke had appeared to hint at compromise with an offer of all-party talks on the detention plans. However, the government pledged to stand firm on the 90-day proposal following a meeting of the Parliamentary Labour Party on Monday evening.
Mr Clarke did, however, propose a ‘sunset clause’, allowing the legislation to be examined again by Parliament in a year’s time.
Both the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats were opposed to the 90-day detention proposal. The Liberal Democrats want the maximum detention period for terror suspects to remain at the current level of 14 days, while the Conservatives want it increased to no more than 28 days.
Mr Blair made an appeal to MPs to back the Bill in the Commons today, saying it was the “duty of every member of this House” to back the plans.
The Prime Minister also said that two terror plots had been foiled since the July 7 attacks in London, but he did not specify any details.
However, he did address the possible defeat of the Bill, saying: “Sometimes it is better to lose and do the right thing than win and do the wrong thing.”
There were heated exchanges between Mr Blair and the Conservative leader Michael Howard and Liberal Democrat leader Charles Kennedy during Prime Minister’s question time. Both party leaders questioned the need to hold suspects for ninety days, while Mr Howard warned that minority ethnic communities could be alienated by the legislation.
Mr Blair said: “We are not living in a police state, but we are living in a country that faces a real and serious threat of terrorism.”
He told Mr Howard that he and his colleagues would have to make their decision today. He said: “We have made ours. We believe it’s necessary to protect our country from terrorism and I’m only sorry you don’t agree.”
MPs are now voting on a proposal, tabled by Labour MP David Winnick, to increase the maximum detention time to 28 days.
(KMcA/GB)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
07 November 2005
Blair defends 90-day detention plans
Prime Minister Tony Blair remains hopeful over plans to introduction 90-day detention for terror suspects, even as Home Secretary Charles Clarke apparently prepares a compromise deal on the controversial issue.
Blair defends 90-day detention plans
Prime Minister Tony Blair remains hopeful over plans to introduction 90-day detention for terror suspects, even as Home Secretary Charles Clarke apparently prepares a compromise deal on the controversial issue.
12 October 2005
Blair backs 90-day detention plans
Prime Minister Tony Blair has backed controversial plans to detain terror suspects for 90 days without charge, as the government published its proposed anti-terror legislation. Speaking during the Prime Minister’s monthly press conference, Mr Blair said that there was a “compelling” case for a three-month detention period for terror suspects.
Blair backs 90-day detention plans
Prime Minister Tony Blair has backed controversial plans to detain terror suspects for 90 days without charge, as the government published its proposed anti-terror legislation. Speaking during the Prime Minister’s monthly press conference, Mr Blair said that there was a “compelling” case for a three-month detention period for terror suspects.
10 June 2008
Brown Expected To Face Tough Vote Over Terror Laws
Prime Minister Gordon Brown is expected to face a tough battle as the government continues to try and secure support for its controversial anti-terror plans, as MPs begin debating the package. MPs will vote on controversial plans to increase the period that suspects can be held without charge to 42 days on Wednesday.
Brown Expected To Face Tough Vote Over Terror Laws
Prime Minister Gordon Brown is expected to face a tough battle as the government continues to try and secure support for its controversial anti-terror plans, as MPs begin debating the package. MPs will vote on controversial plans to increase the period that suspects can be held without charge to 42 days on Wednesday.
10 November 2005
Blair faces calls to resign following terror defeat
Tony Blair has faced calls to resign as Prime Minister following the defeat in the House of Commons of proposals to detain terror suspects for 90 days. Conservative leader Michael Howard said that Mr Blair should stand aside, as he had been “utterly humiliated” by Wednesday’s vote.
Blair faces calls to resign following terror defeat
Tony Blair has faced calls to resign as Prime Minister following the defeat in the House of Commons of proposals to detain terror suspects for 90 days. Conservative leader Michael Howard said that Mr Blair should stand aside, as he had been “utterly humiliated” by Wednesday’s vote.
29 June 2005
ID cards bill survives Commons vote
The government’s controversial Identity Cards Bill has survived a House of Commons vote, in spite of a rebellion by some Labour backbenchers. Folowing the close vote Tony Blair said that he was prepared to "listen to concerns" about the ID card issue.
ID cards bill survives Commons vote
The government’s controversial Identity Cards Bill has survived a House of Commons vote, in spite of a rebellion by some Labour backbenchers. Folowing the close vote Tony Blair said that he was prepared to "listen to concerns" about the ID card issue.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherThis Evening and Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
