Menu
03/12/2007
Troops Out As Iraqis Taking More Control
Policing the Iraqi city of Basra is to be handed over to the local security forces.
Despite failing in its goal to establish proper security there, an MPs' report has said that, even though the city is dominated by militias and the police contains "murderous" and "corrupt" elements, the UK will hand over control of Basra to Iraqi forces shortly.
While Defence Secretary Des Browne has said security forces in Basra had grown in ability during the past year, the report said: "The initial goal of UK forces in south eastern Iraq was to establish the security necessary for the development of representative political institutions and for economic reconstruction.
"Although progress has been made, this goal remains unfulfilled."
It also suggested that the relative security of Basra did not mean that the root causes of violence had been tackled.
The Defence Committee report added: "There remain murderous, corrupt and militia-infiltrated elements within the police which must be rooted out as a matter of priority."
It went on to speculate on the future role of UK forces in Iraq.
The report said: "If there is still a role for UK forces in Iraq, those forces must be capable of doing more than just protecting themselves at Basra Air Station.
The report said the Iraqi Army had made significant progress but still required logistical support from the British.
MPs welcomed the reduction of attacks on UK forces since they pulled out of their last base in the city but pointed out that there had been no corresponding reduction in the number of attacks against civilians.
The report explained: "The relative security of Basra is said to owe more to the dominance of militias and criminal gangs, who are said to have achieved a fragile balance in the city, than to the success of the multinational and Iraqi security forces in tackling the root causes of the violence."
It also warned that it was important not to overstate the success of the US troop surge in and around Baghdad, adding that it was still unclear whether recent improvements in the security situation would remain for the long term.
Furthermore, the committee expressed concerns over whether the Ministry of Defence budget would be able to complete the necessary amount of refurbishment work required to be carried out on British Army equipment.
The committee also said there was a discrepancy between the number of troops the Minister for Armed Forces said was needed to perform the 'overwatch role' and the numbers given by the prime minister.
Bob Ainsworth said in July 2007 anything below 5,000 would be "difficult to sustain".
But the prime minister announced in October 2007 that forces would be reduced to 2,500 from spring 2008.
Mr Browne added that he was satisfied that on the basis of the evidence he had received the prime minister's "figure of troops to tasks is the right figure."
Defence Secretary Des Browne said: "We have always said that our obligations to the Iraqi nation will not end when all four provinces within our area of operations have been transferred to Iraqi control.
"The local security forces in Basra have grown in confidence and ability throughout the year."
But Mr Browne accepted that the Iraqi forces were "not the finished article".
But he added: "Our commitment in this role is undiminished. We will continue until the Iraqis themselves are confident they no longer need our assistance."
The chairman of the committee, Conservative MP James Arbuthnot, said the handover should go ahead despite the violence.
"Development of the Iraqi army is going much better than the development of the Iraqi police and the army in Iraq is able I think, in the south eastern part anyway, to take over control from British forces," he said.
(BMcC)
Despite failing in its goal to establish proper security there, an MPs' report has said that, even though the city is dominated by militias and the police contains "murderous" and "corrupt" elements, the UK will hand over control of Basra to Iraqi forces shortly.
While Defence Secretary Des Browne has said security forces in Basra had grown in ability during the past year, the report said: "The initial goal of UK forces in south eastern Iraq was to establish the security necessary for the development of representative political institutions and for economic reconstruction.
"Although progress has been made, this goal remains unfulfilled."
It also suggested that the relative security of Basra did not mean that the root causes of violence had been tackled.
The Defence Committee report added: "There remain murderous, corrupt and militia-infiltrated elements within the police which must be rooted out as a matter of priority."
It went on to speculate on the future role of UK forces in Iraq.
The report said: "If there is still a role for UK forces in Iraq, those forces must be capable of doing more than just protecting themselves at Basra Air Station.
The report said the Iraqi Army had made significant progress but still required logistical support from the British.
MPs welcomed the reduction of attacks on UK forces since they pulled out of their last base in the city but pointed out that there had been no corresponding reduction in the number of attacks against civilians.
The report explained: "The relative security of Basra is said to owe more to the dominance of militias and criminal gangs, who are said to have achieved a fragile balance in the city, than to the success of the multinational and Iraqi security forces in tackling the root causes of the violence."
It also warned that it was important not to overstate the success of the US troop surge in and around Baghdad, adding that it was still unclear whether recent improvements in the security situation would remain for the long term.
Furthermore, the committee expressed concerns over whether the Ministry of Defence budget would be able to complete the necessary amount of refurbishment work required to be carried out on British Army equipment.
The committee also said there was a discrepancy between the number of troops the Minister for Armed Forces said was needed to perform the 'overwatch role' and the numbers given by the prime minister.
Bob Ainsworth said in July 2007 anything below 5,000 would be "difficult to sustain".
But the prime minister announced in October 2007 that forces would be reduced to 2,500 from spring 2008.
Mr Browne added that he was satisfied that on the basis of the evidence he had received the prime minister's "figure of troops to tasks is the right figure."
Defence Secretary Des Browne said: "We have always said that our obligations to the Iraqi nation will not end when all four provinces within our area of operations have been transferred to Iraqi control.
"The local security forces in Basra have grown in confidence and ability throughout the year."
But Mr Browne accepted that the Iraqi forces were "not the finished article".
But he added: "Our commitment in this role is undiminished. We will continue until the Iraqis themselves are confident they no longer need our assistance."
The chairman of the committee, Conservative MP James Arbuthnot, said the handover should go ahead despite the violence.
"Development of the Iraqi army is going much better than the development of the Iraqi police and the army in Iraq is able I think, in the south eastern part anyway, to take over control from British forces," he said.
(BMcC)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
15 June 2009
UK Forces To Lead New Afghan Training School
British forces in Afghanistan are to take the lead in developing a new Combined Arms Training School providing training courses to the Afghan National Army (ANA), it has been announced.
UK Forces To Lead New Afghan Training School
British forces in Afghanistan are to take the lead in developing a new Combined Arms Training School providing training courses to the Afghan National Army (ANA), it has been announced.
29 April 2004
Ten US soldiers killed in Baghdad attacks
Ten American soldiers have been killed and four wounded in attacks by insurgents in Iraq. Eight soldiers died in a car bomb attack in the Mahmudiya district of south Baghdad, around 11:30 am local time (7:30 am GMT). A US military spokesman confirmed the soldiers were US Army personnel. Two other American soldiers have also been killed in Iraq.
Ten US soldiers killed in Baghdad attacks
Ten American soldiers have been killed and four wounded in attacks by insurgents in Iraq. Eight soldiers died in a car bomb attack in the Mahmudiya district of south Baghdad, around 11:30 am local time (7:30 am GMT). A US military spokesman confirmed the soldiers were US Army personnel. Two other American soldiers have also been killed in Iraq.
08 February 2006
Reid suggests UK troops could soon leave Iraq
Defence Secretary John Reid has suggested that UK troops could begin withdrawing from Iraq this year. In a speech to the Foreign Press Association in London yesterday, Mr Reid said that the "time is approaching" when coalition forces could begin leaving Iraq. However, he stressed that the government would not "cut and run".
Reid suggests UK troops could soon leave Iraq
Defence Secretary John Reid has suggested that UK troops could begin withdrawing from Iraq this year. In a speech to the Foreign Press Association in London yesterday, Mr Reid said that the "time is approaching" when coalition forces could begin leaving Iraq. However, he stressed that the government would not "cut and run".
09 November 2004
Coalition forces push further into Fallujah
US forces are pushing further into Fallujah and have gained control over the northern third of the city, according to news agencies. On the second day of the assault, the 15-strong coalition force has been met with pockets of strong resistance from militants armed with rifles and rocket-propelled grenades.
Coalition forces push further into Fallujah
US forces are pushing further into Fallujah and have gained control over the northern third of the city, according to news agencies. On the second day of the assault, the 15-strong coalition force has been met with pockets of strong resistance from militants armed with rifles and rocket-propelled grenades.
01 July 2003
Attacks on US troops continue in Iraq
The US Defence Secretary has declared that Iraq is “no new Vietnam”, but within hours of those comments a vehicle carrying US troops in Baghdad was bombed and there were two further grenade attacks on US forces.
Attacks on US troops continue in Iraq
The US Defence Secretary has declared that Iraq is “no new Vietnam”, but within hours of those comments a vehicle carrying US troops in Baghdad was bombed and there were two further grenade attacks on US forces.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
