Menu
04/12/2008
Landmark DNA Database Ruling Made
A landmark legal ruling could soon force ministers to remove DNA samples of innocent people from the British database.
The European Court of Human Rights (pictured) ruled that two British men should not have had their DNA and fingerprints retained by police. The case was brought by the two men from Sheffield, who were arrested, but never convicted.
Currently, all DNA evidence taken during criminal proceedings in England and Wales is retained, even on acquittal or when charges are dropped.
As a result of the unanimous judgment by 17 senior judges from across Europe, thousands of those samples may have to be destroyed.
The details of around 4.5 million people are currently held, and one in five of them do not have a criminal record.
The judges in the case said keeping this information "could not be regarded as necessary in a democratic society".
One of the men, Michael Marper, was arrested for harassing a partner in 2001, and the case was dropped, while the other - a teenager known only as 'S' - was charged with robbery and later acquitted.
In both cases, police refused to destroy their fingerprints and DNA samples taken when both men were in custody.
Their claims were later thrown out by the House of Lords, after it ruled that under the Criminal Justice and Police Act, it was not breaching their human rights.
However, earlier this year, they went to the European Court of Human Rights and argued that by retaining their DNA profiles, it was discrimination and breached their right to a private life.
The judges ruled the retention of the men's DNA "failed to strike a fair balance between the competing public and private interests", and added the British government had "overstepped any acceptable margin of appreciation in this regard".
The court also ruled "the retention in question constituted a disproportionate interference with the applicants' right to respect for private life and could not be regarded as necessary in a democratic society".
(JM)
The European Court of Human Rights (pictured) ruled that two British men should not have had their DNA and fingerprints retained by police. The case was brought by the two men from Sheffield, who were arrested, but never convicted.
Currently, all DNA evidence taken during criminal proceedings in England and Wales is retained, even on acquittal or when charges are dropped.
As a result of the unanimous judgment by 17 senior judges from across Europe, thousands of those samples may have to be destroyed.
The details of around 4.5 million people are currently held, and one in five of them do not have a criminal record.
The judges in the case said keeping this information "could not be regarded as necessary in a democratic society".
One of the men, Michael Marper, was arrested for harassing a partner in 2001, and the case was dropped, while the other - a teenager known only as 'S' - was charged with robbery and later acquitted.
In both cases, police refused to destroy their fingerprints and DNA samples taken when both men were in custody.
Their claims were later thrown out by the House of Lords, after it ruled that under the Criminal Justice and Police Act, it was not breaching their human rights.
However, earlier this year, they went to the European Court of Human Rights and argued that by retaining their DNA profiles, it was discrimination and breached their right to a private life.
The judges ruled the retention of the men's DNA "failed to strike a fair balance between the competing public and private interests", and added the British government had "overstepped any acceptable margin of appreciation in this regard".
The court also ruled "the retention in question constituted a disproportionate interference with the applicants' right to respect for private life and could not be regarded as necessary in a democratic society".
(JM)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
17 May 2007
Nearly 200 crimes missed by DNA failings
Nearly 200 crimes went undetected due to failings over DNA samples, it has been revealed. The failure to archive DNA evidence resulted in 183 crimes going undetected, including one paedophile offence, three robberies, nine burglaries, 19 drugs offences and 62 thefts, the National DNA Database annual report revealed.
Nearly 200 crimes missed by DNA failings
Nearly 200 crimes went undetected due to failings over DNA samples, it has been revealed. The failure to archive DNA evidence resulted in 183 crimes going undetected, including one paedophile offence, three robberies, nine burglaries, 19 drugs offences and 62 thefts, the National DNA Database annual report revealed.
16 April 2015
Mass DNA Swabbing Operation Underway In Leeds
Police in Leeds are carrying out a mass DNA swabbing operation as part of a rape and attempted murder investigation. An 18-year-old woman was attacked on 06 March in Beeston. She was dragged from a bus stop and bludgeoned with a stone before being sexually assaulted.
Mass DNA Swabbing Operation Underway In Leeds
Police in Leeds are carrying out a mass DNA swabbing operation as part of a rape and attempted murder investigation. An 18-year-old woman was attacked on 06 March in Beeston. She was dragged from a bus stop and bludgeoned with a stone before being sexually assaulted.
05 January 2006
Black police officers' group slams DNA figures
A black police officers' group has called for an investigation into the national DNA database, after a report suggested that black people were over-represented on the system. According to research conducted by the 'Guardian' newspaper, 37% of all black men are included on the database, compared to 9% of white men.
Black police officers' group slams DNA figures
A black police officers' group has called for an investigation into the national DNA database, after a report suggested that black people were over-represented on the system. According to research conducted by the 'Guardian' newspaper, 37% of all black men are included on the database, compared to 9% of white men.
24 March 2005
Ethiopian army branded ‘murderers and rapists’
The Ethiopian military has committed widespread murder, rape and torture against the Anuak population since December 2003, Human Rights Watch (HRW) said in a report released today.
Ethiopian army branded ‘murderers and rapists’
The Ethiopian military has committed widespread murder, rape and torture against the Anuak population since December 2003, Human Rights Watch (HRW) said in a report released today.
24 November 2003
DNA-testing on prisoners solves 64 old crimes
Police have cleared up 64 old crimes - including murder, rape and robbery – and are reinvestigating a further 78 unsolved crimes following DNA testing of prisoners and mentally disordered offenders, Home Office Minister Hazel Blears announced today.
DNA-testing on prisoners solves 64 old crimes
Police have cleared up 64 old crimes - including murder, rape and robbery – and are reinvestigating a further 78 unsolved crimes following DNA testing of prisoners and mentally disordered offenders, Home Office Minister Hazel Blears announced today.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherThis Evening and Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
