Menu
03/03/2009
Expert Warns Of 'Staggering' Consequences Of New Data-Sharing Proposals
The health consequences of the Government's new data-sharing proposals could be "staggering", warns an expert in an editorial published on bmj.com today.
Dr Vivienne Nathanson, Director of Professional Activities at the British Medical Association (BMA) has expressed concerns about Clause 152 of the Coroners and Justice Bill which, in its current form, appears to grant the government unprecedented powers to access people's confidential medical records, and share them with third parties.
This means that laws which currently limit health data sharing could be set aside, including the protections of the Data Protection Act, says Dr Nathanson.
Even the Venereal Diseases Regulations and the provisions of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology act would not be immune to the potential for removal.
Health data is not privileged in the manner of legal information, but for many years it has been recognised as special, and as sensitive, she writes.
Research shows that patients expect the health professional with whom they share information will hold it in confidence, and share it sparingly and on a need-to-know basis, usually those also involved in offering them care.
Yet, Dr Nathanson believes that data in the current draft of the Bill suggests blindness to the special sensitivity of health data.
If the current draft legislation goes through with minimal changes, the effect could be to undermine doctor and patient confidence in the future control of data that neither is willing to record the most sensitive information the doctor warns.
"This week many of the leading medical organisations have written a joint letter to the Justice Secretary seeking the complete removal of health data and the provisions of the Bill," Dr Nathanson concluded. "We are seeking a meeting, to provide him with the reasons behind our concerns and to emphasise why we can see no problems in the health sector to which this legislation is an acceptable solution."
(JM/BMcC)
Dr Vivienne Nathanson, Director of Professional Activities at the British Medical Association (BMA) has expressed concerns about Clause 152 of the Coroners and Justice Bill which, in its current form, appears to grant the government unprecedented powers to access people's confidential medical records, and share them with third parties.
This means that laws which currently limit health data sharing could be set aside, including the protections of the Data Protection Act, says Dr Nathanson.
Even the Venereal Diseases Regulations and the provisions of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology act would not be immune to the potential for removal.
Health data is not privileged in the manner of legal information, but for many years it has been recognised as special, and as sensitive, she writes.
Research shows that patients expect the health professional with whom they share information will hold it in confidence, and share it sparingly and on a need-to-know basis, usually those also involved in offering them care.
Yet, Dr Nathanson believes that data in the current draft of the Bill suggests blindness to the special sensitivity of health data.
If the current draft legislation goes through with minimal changes, the effect could be to undermine doctor and patient confidence in the future control of data that neither is willing to record the most sensitive information the doctor warns.
"This week many of the leading medical organisations have written a joint letter to the Justice Secretary seeking the complete removal of health data and the provisions of the Bill," Dr Nathanson concluded. "We are seeking a meeting, to provide him with the reasons behind our concerns and to emphasise why we can see no problems in the health sector to which this legislation is an acceptable solution."
(JM/BMcC)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
28 May 2014
More People Accept NHS Health Check
More people than ever before are accepting the offer to attend an NHS Health Check according to new figures from Public Health England (PHE). The figures, published today, show that in the last year over 1.
More People Accept NHS Health Check
More people than ever before are accepting the offer to attend an NHS Health Check according to new figures from Public Health England (PHE). The figures, published today, show that in the last year over 1.
12 September 2013
Salmonella Outbreak In England And Wales Has Links To Cooked Meat
Investigations show that an outbreak of salmonella seen in England and Wales has links to the consumption of cooked ham bought from small independent butchers' shops. The results of tests carried out by environmental health officers on the product did not show the presence of salmonella although it did reveal other hygiene issues.
Salmonella Outbreak In England And Wales Has Links To Cooked Meat
Investigations show that an outbreak of salmonella seen in England and Wales has links to the consumption of cooked ham bought from small independent butchers' shops. The results of tests carried out by environmental health officers on the product did not show the presence of salmonella although it did reveal other hygiene issues.
20 August 2013
Leading GP Condemns Health MOTs
The UK's leading GP has condemned health checks carried out on millions of people over the age of 40, as a waste of time. The NHS Health Check is being promoted by the government "against good evidence", Dr Clare Gerada, Chair of the Royal College of GPs, has said.
Leading GP Condemns Health MOTs
The UK's leading GP has condemned health checks carried out on millions of people over the age of 40, as a waste of time. The NHS Health Check is being promoted by the government "against good evidence", Dr Clare Gerada, Chair of the Royal College of GPs, has said.
30 April 2013
Ex-Military To Receive Mental Health Training
Former military personnel and their families are to be offered training to help veterans experiencing mental health problems. Up to 6,400 ex-soldiers, sailors, airmen and their families will receive the training, Health Minister Dr Dan Poulter announced on Tuesday.
Ex-Military To Receive Mental Health Training
Former military personnel and their families are to be offered training to help veterans experiencing mental health problems. Up to 6,400 ex-soldiers, sailors, airmen and their families will receive the training, Health Minister Dr Dan Poulter announced on Tuesday.
23 June 2010
NHS Backs 'Psychological Therapies'
Psychological therapies will continue to be rolled out across the NHS in the coming year Health Secretary Andrew Lansley has announced.
NHS Backs 'Psychological Therapies'
Psychological therapies will continue to be rolled out across the NHS in the coming year Health Secretary Andrew Lansley has announced.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
