19/06/2009

Baby P Doctor To Sue Over Sacking

The Great Ormond Street doctor who failed to spot Baby Peter's broken back and ribs is suing the hospital the hospital over her sacking.

Dr Sabah Al-Zayyat, 52, is demanding damages from the hospital for unfair dismissal.

The consultant paediatrician missed the injuries, which included a broken back and ribs, after deciding she could not carry out a full check-up because the 17-month-old was "miserable and cranky".

Two days later, on 3 August, Baby Peter died in a blood-splattered cot in Haringey, north London, at the home shared by his mother, her boyfriend and their lodger.

It is understood the 52-year-old is to argue she was made a scapegoat to cover wider failures.

She will be represented by lawyers from the Medical Protection Society.

A Great Ormond Street spokeswoman said: "We can confirm we have received notice of legal action. The trust will vigorously defend its position.

"We believe we acted fairly and in the interests of patients. Detailed rebuttal of Dr Al-Zayyat’s claims will have to wait for any hearing."

The spokeswoman added: "We didn't scapegoat her. The case surrounds her dismissal from GOSH following the decision not to renew her fixed-term contract. The trust denies that the issue in the case is systematic failures.

"Even a junior doctor should have recognised the risks in a situation where there was a letter on file clearly stating that there were child protection concerns, and the child had visible bruises.

"This should have prompted any doctor to contact the social worker."

Baby Peter's mother, boyfriend and their lodger Jason Owen were all given indefinite sentences.

The mother was given a minimum term of five years for allowing or causing the death. Her boyfriend received 12 years for his "major role" and Owen three years.

(JM/BMcC)

Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

31 July 2008
NHS 'Failing' On Prompt Access To GP's, Report Says
The NHS in England is failing to meet Government targets for giving people prompt access to GPs, a Healthcare Commission survey has revealed. It finds 13% of patients cannot get an appointment to see a family doctor within 48 hours, in breach of undertakings given by Ministers four years ago.
05 August 2009
Missing Baby Found 'Safe And Well'
A nine-month-old baby girl who was reported missing from her home in Glouchestershire on Monday has been found safe and well. Maylayah Delaney had been reported missing by her mother shortly before lunch-time on Monday. Police have confirmed that a man from the West Midlands is helping them with their inquiries.
20 September 2010
Baby P Doctor To Sue NHS
A Consultant Paediatrician involved in the Baby P case, who claimed she was forced out of her job, is to sue the NHS. Dr Kim Holt, who raised concerns about the clinic where Baby P was seen just days before his death, is seeking £100,000 from her former employer Great Ormond Street Hospital (Gosh).
08 July 2010
Baby P Doctor 'Breached Professional Duty'
A GP who missed the opportunity to save Baby P before he died has been found guilty of a serious breach of professional duty by the General Medical Council. Dr Jerome Ikwueke had seen Peter Connelly (referred to as Baby P in court) more than a dozen times before he died, the last time just eight days before his death in August 2007.
22 February 2010
Baby P Doctor 'Suicidal'
A paediatrician who allegedly failed to spot signs of injury on Baby P's body just days before his death was unfit to appear before a medical tribunal today. Dr Sabah Al-Zayyat, who was at the centre of a media furore, is said to be suicidal.