Menu
10/05/2011
'Review Stormont Count Fiasco' Says Kinahan
A newly returned MLA has suggested a solution after a chorus of condemnation on the Assembly 'election fiasco', which at times, decended into a near chaotic process.
Danny Kinahan, a UUP South Antrim MLA (pictured) said last night: "It's only when you see an election count at close quarters that you realise just how complex an operation it can be."
Suggesting a comprehensive review of the whole count process, he said: "With an absolute need for a scrupulous result you understand the intolerable pressures on those in charge.
"We all had plenty of time on Friday and Saturday to ask difficult questions of returning officers across the province and we all became instant 'experts' - yet from election to election we barely give the matter a second thought," he said, suggesting a solution to problems in the future.
"The count 'fiasco' as it was quickly labelled simply boils down to a matter of resourcing.
"If we are going to make such a fuss when things go wrong, then the least we can do for the next time around it to resource the process properly.
"It's a bit like managing an international football team - you only get your team together for the big games. The count teams don't have the luxury of 'friendlies' nor in fact any opportunity for practice matches between elections," he continued.
"As candidates, we often speak of the 'sacred' nature of the vote and the privilege it confers on us - this equally applies to the end of the process and we need to ensure that the Electoral Commission has the necessary resources to deliver a better result," he said.
"Having said that, I can see no valid reason for failing to count or at least verify through the night and I am certainly not going to buy the 'Health and Safety' excuse.
"Many counters appeared to me to spend long periods of the count doing nothing at all constructive," he concluded, suggesting that the electoral boss and his senior management "spend more time reviewing the system and less effort defending it".
News Letter
The News Letter was forced to produce a Sunday edition for the first time since the 1990s to cover last week's Assembly elections, so long was the delay in the poll count as it couldn't make it into Saturday's paper.
Editor Darwin Templeton said: "We had planned to do the special edition, but as it turned out, because of shambolic scenes at the counts, most seats were not decided until Saturday."
"Even when we went to press, we still had only 105 of the 108 seats," he said.
His comments came just days after Sinn Fein MLA Francie Molloy made an official complaint to the Chief Electoral Office over the slowness of the count in the NI Assembly elections.
Mr Molloy described the process of counting the votes as "appalling" and said the electorate had been "treated with contempt".
"We are not complaining about the election workers and those that were exhausted, but by the whole process that we went through," he said.
The outgoing Speaker of the Northern Ireland Assembly, the DUP's Willie Hay, has also strongly criticised the system for counting votes in NI elections.
He said anger was building among politicians over why it was taking a lot longer here than in other parts of the UK.
"It's the system," he said. "We need a better system."
Desite all the critics, the NIO Minister of State, Hugo Swire has defended the process: "Holding three polls at the same time was an unprecedented challenge for the Electoral Office and all those involved in the administration of the process.
"I am grateful to the Chief Electoral Officer and all those who worked tirelessly in the run up to, during and after these polls for their efforts," he enthused on Tuesday, just hours after the final ballot was counted.
Commenting on concerns expressed about the time taken to count votes at the Assembly election, the Minister said: "The Chief Electoral Officer's main priority was 'getting it right' and ensuring that all Assembly members and councillors were properly returned. He has achieved this."
See: Council Election Counting Underway As SF/DUP Consider Stormont Executive Ministries
(BMcC/GK)
Danny Kinahan, a UUP South Antrim MLA (pictured) said last night: "It's only when you see an election count at close quarters that you realise just how complex an operation it can be."
Suggesting a comprehensive review of the whole count process, he said: "With an absolute need for a scrupulous result you understand the intolerable pressures on those in charge.
"We all had plenty of time on Friday and Saturday to ask difficult questions of returning officers across the province and we all became instant 'experts' - yet from election to election we barely give the matter a second thought," he said, suggesting a solution to problems in the future.
"The count 'fiasco' as it was quickly labelled simply boils down to a matter of resourcing.
"If we are going to make such a fuss when things go wrong, then the least we can do for the next time around it to resource the process properly.
"It's a bit like managing an international football team - you only get your team together for the big games. The count teams don't have the luxury of 'friendlies' nor in fact any opportunity for practice matches between elections," he continued.
"As candidates, we often speak of the 'sacred' nature of the vote and the privilege it confers on us - this equally applies to the end of the process and we need to ensure that the Electoral Commission has the necessary resources to deliver a better result," he said.
"Having said that, I can see no valid reason for failing to count or at least verify through the night and I am certainly not going to buy the 'Health and Safety' excuse.
"Many counters appeared to me to spend long periods of the count doing nothing at all constructive," he concluded, suggesting that the electoral boss and his senior management "spend more time reviewing the system and less effort defending it".
News Letter
The News Letter was forced to produce a Sunday edition for the first time since the 1990s to cover last week's Assembly elections, so long was the delay in the poll count as it couldn't make it into Saturday's paper.
Editor Darwin Templeton said: "We had planned to do the special edition, but as it turned out, because of shambolic scenes at the counts, most seats were not decided until Saturday."
"Even when we went to press, we still had only 105 of the 108 seats," he said.
His comments came just days after Sinn Fein MLA Francie Molloy made an official complaint to the Chief Electoral Office over the slowness of the count in the NI Assembly elections.
Mr Molloy described the process of counting the votes as "appalling" and said the electorate had been "treated with contempt".
"We are not complaining about the election workers and those that were exhausted, but by the whole process that we went through," he said.
The outgoing Speaker of the Northern Ireland Assembly, the DUP's Willie Hay, has also strongly criticised the system for counting votes in NI elections.
He said anger was building among politicians over why it was taking a lot longer here than in other parts of the UK.
"It's the system," he said. "We need a better system."
Desite all the critics, the NIO Minister of State, Hugo Swire has defended the process: "Holding three polls at the same time was an unprecedented challenge for the Electoral Office and all those involved in the administration of the process.
"I am grateful to the Chief Electoral Officer and all those who worked tirelessly in the run up to, during and after these polls for their efforts," he enthused on Tuesday, just hours after the final ballot was counted.
Commenting on concerns expressed about the time taken to count votes at the Assembly election, the Minister said: "The Chief Electoral Officer's main priority was 'getting it right' and ensuring that all Assembly members and councillors were properly returned. He has achieved this."
See: Council Election Counting Underway As SF/DUP Consider Stormont Executive Ministries
(BMcC/GK)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
28 October 2011
Count Begins For Irish President Election
Counting of the ballots, to decide the next President of Ireland,is underway but it is understood that it could be tomorrow before the results are revealed. The results from the first counts in the 43 constituencies are expected early in the evening or, depending on the official turnout, later tonight.
Count Begins For Irish President Election
Counting of the ballots, to decide the next President of Ireland,is underway but it is understood that it could be tomorrow before the results are revealed. The results from the first counts in the 43 constituencies are expected early in the evening or, depending on the official turnout, later tonight.
02 July 2014
McCallister To Quit NI21
John McCallister is to leave NI21, the political party he helped create with fellow ex-Ulster Unionist Basil McCrea in 2013. The deputy leader is now expected to sit as an Independent unionist MLA in the Assembly.
McCallister To Quit NI21
John McCallister is to leave NI21, the political party he helped create with fellow ex-Ulster Unionist Basil McCrea in 2013. The deputy leader is now expected to sit as an Independent unionist MLA in the Assembly.
27 February 2013
Bomb Alert Was Hoax Says PSNI
A bomb alert in Newtownabbey has been declared a hoax. PSNI have described the security alert as an "elaborate hoax". The M5, was closed in both directions from Hazelbank to Doagh Road, on Tuesday night. All roads have re-opened.
Bomb Alert Was Hoax Says PSNI
A bomb alert in Newtownabbey has been declared a hoax. PSNI have described the security alert as an "elaborate hoax". The M5, was closed in both directions from Hazelbank to Doagh Road, on Tuesday night. All roads have re-opened.
02 March 2011
Sinn Fein 'Winners' As Dáil Count Completed
All the Irish Republic's politicians now know their fate as the counting of votes in the general election has ended - with Sinn Fein making massive gains. Fine Gael won 76 seats; the Labour Party, 37; Fianna Fail, 20; Independents, 14; Sinn Fein, 14, and Others, five. The Green Party won no seats.
Sinn Fein 'Winners' As Dáil Count Completed
All the Irish Republic's politicians now know their fate as the counting of votes in the general election has ended - with Sinn Fein making massive gains. Fine Gael won 76 seats; the Labour Party, 37; Fianna Fail, 20; Independents, 14; Sinn Fein, 14, and Others, five. The Green Party won no seats.
07 March 2005
Peace process in ‘deep crisis’, says McGuinness
Sinn Fein’s Martin McGuinness has said that the peace process is in “deep crisis” and that a collective effort is needed to rebuild it. Speaking at a meeting of party election workers in Belfast on Monday, the Mid Ulster MP said that the British and Irish governments wanted to reduce all problematic issues to one single issue – the IRA.
Peace process in ‘deep crisis’, says McGuinness
Sinn Fein’s Martin McGuinness has said that the peace process is in “deep crisis” and that a collective effort is needed to rebuild it. Speaking at a meeting of party election workers in Belfast on Monday, the Mid Ulster MP said that the British and Irish governments wanted to reduce all problematic issues to one single issue – the IRA.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
