Menu
18/08/2003
Judicial appointments under scrutiny
The Secretary of State for Constitutional Affairs and Lord Chancellor, Lord Falconer, has received a report that lists more than 100 ways in which the procedure for the appointment of judges and Queen’s Counsel in Northern Ireland could be improved.
The report is careful to stress that while suggesting that the present appointments processes can and should be improved in a series of changes, no criticism of those who hold these appointments at present is intended.
The theme of the report is that Northern Ireland should continue to sustain a judiciary that is distinguished, locally and internationally, by making appointments based on merit, defined on the basis of demanding criteria and competences, and where judges are aware of and reflect the diversity of this community: in short, by using judicial appointments procedures that are second to none.
The recommendations range from: a call for a formal application and selection process for every post up to that of High Court Judge; monitoring of community background, gender and disability status of applicants and the existing judiciary; a review of eligibility requirements; a register of external interests; to mandatory training for all newly appointed judges.
The report was drawn up by John Simpson who, on his appointment as the Commissioner for Judicial Appointments for Northern Ireland in early 2002, was tasked by the then Lord Chancellor to prepare a full audit of the judicial and Queen’s Counsel appointment systems currently in use and to make recommendations for improvements.
He said: “People appointed as judges hold exceptionally prominent and influential jobs. In the changing society that is Northern Ireland a judiciary that independently and impartially continues to uphold the law is a key element in building a more stable community.
“An enhanced professional approach to the appointment of judges in Northern Ireland has been suggested. Judicial appointments are, even now, handled professionally and with care. They could, however, be improved by greater transparency in the decision-making process, more carefully structured selection procedures and helped by encouraging applications from a wider range of people.”
The Audit Report has been forwarded to Lord Falconer. The Secretary of State has responded that many of the recommendations of an administrative nature will be accepted and a timetable for implementation is to be discussed. The Minister will be meeting John Simpson to discuss the other recommendations.
(MB)
The report is careful to stress that while suggesting that the present appointments processes can and should be improved in a series of changes, no criticism of those who hold these appointments at present is intended.
The theme of the report is that Northern Ireland should continue to sustain a judiciary that is distinguished, locally and internationally, by making appointments based on merit, defined on the basis of demanding criteria and competences, and where judges are aware of and reflect the diversity of this community: in short, by using judicial appointments procedures that are second to none.
The recommendations range from: a call for a formal application and selection process for every post up to that of High Court Judge; monitoring of community background, gender and disability status of applicants and the existing judiciary; a review of eligibility requirements; a register of external interests; to mandatory training for all newly appointed judges.
The report was drawn up by John Simpson who, on his appointment as the Commissioner for Judicial Appointments for Northern Ireland in early 2002, was tasked by the then Lord Chancellor to prepare a full audit of the judicial and Queen’s Counsel appointment systems currently in use and to make recommendations for improvements.
He said: “People appointed as judges hold exceptionally prominent and influential jobs. In the changing society that is Northern Ireland a judiciary that independently and impartially continues to uphold the law is a key element in building a more stable community.
“An enhanced professional approach to the appointment of judges in Northern Ireland has been suggested. Judicial appointments are, even now, handled professionally and with care. They could, however, be improved by greater transparency in the decision-making process, more carefully structured selection procedures and helped by encouraging applications from a wider range of people.”
The Audit Report has been forwarded to Lord Falconer. The Secretary of State has responded that many of the recommendations of an administrative nature will be accepted and a timetable for implementation is to be discussed. The Minister will be meeting John Simpson to discuss the other recommendations.
(MB)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
09 June 2006
Hain wins legal battle over Parades Commission appointments
Northern Ireland Secretary of State, Peter Hain has today won his legal battle over the appointment of two Orangemen to the Parades Commission. The Court of Appeal today overturned the decision to quash David Burrows` membership of the Parades Commission after last months High Court judicial review, which ruled that his appointment was "unlawful.
Hain wins legal battle over Parades Commission appointments
Northern Ireland Secretary of State, Peter Hain has today won his legal battle over the appointment of two Orangemen to the Parades Commission. The Court of Appeal today overturned the decision to quash David Burrows` membership of the Parades Commission after last months High Court judicial review, which ruled that his appointment was "unlawful.
19 March 2002
Task Software supplies ASP solution to Calthorpe
Calthorpe Response Maintenance has become the first customer to avail of the TASK Contractor ASP (Application Service Provision) service. Calthorpe is a growing presence in the local authority and RSL Registered Social Landlord property maintenance market, and required a functionally strong software application to manage its business effectively.
Task Software supplies ASP solution to Calthorpe
Calthorpe Response Maintenance has become the first customer to avail of the TASK Contractor ASP (Application Service Provision) service. Calthorpe is a growing presence in the local authority and RSL Registered Social Landlord property maintenance market, and required a functionally strong software application to manage its business effectively.
01 March 2007
Waiting lists targets still on track – Goggins
Health Minister for Northern Ireland, Paul Goggins said that there will be no let up in the drive to meet waiting time targets for surgery and outpatient appointments. Figures for the end of December 2006 show continued significant falls in the number of people waiting more than six months for surgery and outpatient appointments.
Waiting lists targets still on track – Goggins
Health Minister for Northern Ireland, Paul Goggins said that there will be no let up in the drive to meet waiting time targets for surgery and outpatient appointments. Figures for the end of December 2006 show continued significant falls in the number of people waiting more than six months for surgery and outpatient appointments.
25 November 2024
Other News In Brief
DfC Launch Public Consultation On Gender Pay Gap A consultation on proposed changes to Section 19 of the Employment Act (Northern Ireland) relating to the requirements for employers to publish information on the pay of male and female employees has been launched by the Department for Communities.
Other News In Brief
DfC Launch Public Consultation On Gender Pay Gap A consultation on proposed changes to Section 19 of the Employment Act (Northern Ireland) relating to the requirements for employers to publish information on the pay of male and female employees has been launched by the Department for Communities.
21 September 2021
New Legislation To Ban Public Appointment Of Those With Serious Convictions
The Executive is set to debate new legislation that would prohibit anyone with a serious criminal conviction from holding public office. The Political Appointments Bill has been proposed by TUV leader Jim Allister and come before the Assembly for its major second stage debate.
New Legislation To Ban Public Appointment Of Those With Serious Convictions
The Executive is set to debate new legislation that would prohibit anyone with a serious criminal conviction from holding public office. The Political Appointments Bill has been proposed by TUV leader Jim Allister and come before the Assembly for its major second stage debate.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherThis Evening and Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
