Menu
08/10/2010
Double Jeopardy Reforms Commence
A Bill to reform the centuries-old law which prevents a person being tried twice for the same offence in Scotland has been introduced.
The 'double jeopardy' principle dates back over 800 years, but questions have been raised in recent years about whether the law now needs to be updated for the 21st Century.
Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill said there is a 'strong case' for modernising the current law and, following a consultation with Scotland's legal profession, the public, victims and their families earlier this year, has taken formal steps to now make the legislative changes required.
The Justice Secretary also announced that the Bill will go further than previously proposed by the Scottish Law Commission (SLC).
The SLC had recommended that any changes on new evidence should only apply to murder and rape cases. However, the Bill goes further and also includes the offences of culpable homicide and serious sexual offences, including those against children.
It is not proposed to remove the rule - double jeopardy is a fundamental principle of Scots law which provides essential protection against the state repeatedly pursuing an individual for the same act.
However, the Bill proposes that certain exceptions should apply. The key elements of the Double Jeopardy (Scotland) Bill are:
* Restating and clarifying the ancient law on double jeopardy, removing the anomalies and uncertainties identified by the Scottish Law Commission in its 2009 Report on double jeopardy.
* Allowing a second trial where, after an acquittal, compelling new evidence emerges to substantially strengthen the case against the accused.
* Allowing a second trial where the original trial was "tainted", e.g. by intimidation.
* Allowing a second trial where, after an acquittal, evidence becomes available that the acquitted person has admitted committing the offence.
* To permit the prosecution of a person on a more serious charge where the victim has died after the original trial (e.g. on culpable homicide, rather than serious assault).
* Any changes to the double jeopardy law will be retrospective and apply to old cases.
Mr MacAskill said: "The principle of double jeopardy dates back over 800 years, but we now live in a very different world and it is clear that the law needs to be modernised to ensure that it is fit for the 21st century.
"In this day and age, people shouldn't be able to walk free from court and subsequently boast with impunity about their guilt. If new evidence emerges which shows the original ruling was fundamentally flawed, it should be possible to have a second trial. And trials which are tainted by threats or corruption should be re-run.
"Prosecutors should not have their hands tied, and this Bill will ensure that in such cases there will be no escape from justice," he continued.
"There is a growing consensus across Scotland that reform is needed and needed now, and we have acted swiftly in the interests of Scottish justice, victims and their families.
"I look forward to the Bill going through the proper Parliamentary process and hope that MSPs of all political persuasion come together to back these important and truly historic changes to Scots law," the minister concluded.
On November 20, 2007 the Cabinet Secretary for Justice, Kenny MacAskill MSP, asked the Scottish Law Commission to consider the principle of double jeopardy, whether there should be exceptions to it and to make any appropriate recommendations for reform.
The SLC published its Report on double jeopardy in December 2009 having previously published a Discussion Paper and conducted its own consultation exercise in early 2009.
The Government launched a consultation exercise based upon the SLC's proposals in March 2010. The consultation paper is focused the question of whether there should be an exception to the rule against double jeopardy in cases where important new evidence has emerged following the original trial.
(GK)
The 'double jeopardy' principle dates back over 800 years, but questions have been raised in recent years about whether the law now needs to be updated for the 21st Century.
Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill said there is a 'strong case' for modernising the current law and, following a consultation with Scotland's legal profession, the public, victims and their families earlier this year, has taken formal steps to now make the legislative changes required.
The Justice Secretary also announced that the Bill will go further than previously proposed by the Scottish Law Commission (SLC).
The SLC had recommended that any changes on new evidence should only apply to murder and rape cases. However, the Bill goes further and also includes the offences of culpable homicide and serious sexual offences, including those against children.
It is not proposed to remove the rule - double jeopardy is a fundamental principle of Scots law which provides essential protection against the state repeatedly pursuing an individual for the same act.
However, the Bill proposes that certain exceptions should apply. The key elements of the Double Jeopardy (Scotland) Bill are:
* Restating and clarifying the ancient law on double jeopardy, removing the anomalies and uncertainties identified by the Scottish Law Commission in its 2009 Report on double jeopardy.
* Allowing a second trial where, after an acquittal, compelling new evidence emerges to substantially strengthen the case against the accused.
* Allowing a second trial where the original trial was "tainted", e.g. by intimidation.
* Allowing a second trial where, after an acquittal, evidence becomes available that the acquitted person has admitted committing the offence.
* To permit the prosecution of a person on a more serious charge where the victim has died after the original trial (e.g. on culpable homicide, rather than serious assault).
* Any changes to the double jeopardy law will be retrospective and apply to old cases.
Mr MacAskill said: "The principle of double jeopardy dates back over 800 years, but we now live in a very different world and it is clear that the law needs to be modernised to ensure that it is fit for the 21st century.
"In this day and age, people shouldn't be able to walk free from court and subsequently boast with impunity about their guilt. If new evidence emerges which shows the original ruling was fundamentally flawed, it should be possible to have a second trial. And trials which are tainted by threats or corruption should be re-run.
"Prosecutors should not have their hands tied, and this Bill will ensure that in such cases there will be no escape from justice," he continued.
"There is a growing consensus across Scotland that reform is needed and needed now, and we have acted swiftly in the interests of Scottish justice, victims and their families.
"I look forward to the Bill going through the proper Parliamentary process and hope that MSPs of all political persuasion come together to back these important and truly historic changes to Scots law," the minister concluded.
On November 20, 2007 the Cabinet Secretary for Justice, Kenny MacAskill MSP, asked the Scottish Law Commission to consider the principle of double jeopardy, whether there should be exceptions to it and to make any appropriate recommendations for reform.
The SLC published its Report on double jeopardy in December 2009 having previously published a Discussion Paper and conducted its own consultation exercise in early 2009.
The Government launched a consultation exercise based upon the SLC's proposals in March 2010. The consultation paper is focused the question of whether there should be an exception to the rule against double jeopardy in cases where important new evidence has emerged following the original trial.
(GK)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
28 November 2011
Double Jeopardy Tried Again
The Scottish Government has announced changes to the double 'jeopardy rule' that will see those acquitted of crimes tried again in a broader range of circumstances.
Double Jeopardy Tried Again
The Scottish Government has announced changes to the double 'jeopardy rule' that will see those acquitted of crimes tried again in a broader range of circumstances.
30 January 2014
Lords Back Smoking In Cars Ban Amendment
The House of Lords have backed a Labour amendment that will see the introduction of a ban on smoking in cars carrying children. Labour brought the Children and Families Bill amendment before the House of Lords on Wednesday. Following the backing of peers, MPs have now been told that they will be given a free vote on the issue.
Lords Back Smoking In Cars Ban Amendment
The House of Lords have backed a Labour amendment that will see the introduction of a ban on smoking in cars carrying children. Labour brought the Children and Families Bill amendment before the House of Lords on Wednesday. Following the backing of peers, MPs have now been told that they will be given a free vote on the issue.
20 November 2009
Christmas Scripts For Eastenders Stolen
Scripts for the festive specials of Eastenders have reportedly been stolen. According to the BBC, a laptop containing the scripts was stolen during a burglary at a writer's home. It is now feared that details of the soap's Christmas plots could now be leaked online.
Christmas Scripts For Eastenders Stolen
Scripts for the festive specials of Eastenders have reportedly been stolen. According to the BBC, a laptop containing the scripts was stolen during a burglary at a writer's home. It is now feared that details of the soap's Christmas plots could now be leaked online.
15 October 2015
Record Fine Over 'High Pressure Tactics' Used By PPI Firm
A Swansea-based company has been fined more than £500,000 for using "high pressure tactics" to get customers to make PPI claims. The Claims Management Regulator (CMR) fined Rock Law Ltd £570,000 for coercing clients into signing contracts, without giving them enough time to understand the terms and conditions before taking unauthorised payments.
Record Fine Over 'High Pressure Tactics' Used By PPI Firm
A Swansea-based company has been fined more than £500,000 for using "high pressure tactics" to get customers to make PPI claims. The Claims Management Regulator (CMR) fined Rock Law Ltd £570,000 for coercing clients into signing contracts, without giving them enough time to understand the terms and conditions before taking unauthorised payments.
14 March 2013
Journalist Arrested In Hacking Investigation
Officers investigation alleged phone hacking have arrested three men and one woman on Thursday morning. They are thought to be journalists or former journalists at Mirror Group Newspapers. Scotland Yard said it had identified a suspected conspiracy to intercept telephone voicemails at the newspaper group.
Journalist Arrested In Hacking Investigation
Officers investigation alleged phone hacking have arrested three men and one woman on Thursday morning. They are thought to be journalists or former journalists at Mirror Group Newspapers. Scotland Yard said it had identified a suspected conspiracy to intercept telephone voicemails at the newspaper group.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
