Menu
22/02/2011
One In Three Still Don’t Know When Ambulance Is Not Needed
Most people know when an ambulance is needed, but fewer than one in three understand when emergency services are not required, finds research published online in Emergency Medicine Journal. And, worryingly, one in four people don’t realise that an ambulance is required for a suspected stroke, the study shows.
The authors base their findings on the responses of 150 people to vignettes of 12 common medical scenarios, seven of which would not require an ambulance to be called.
Respondents were asked whether they would or would not dial 999 for an ambulance, and if not, what other options they would take, such as seeking medical advice from elsewhere, self medication, or doing nothing.
The scenarios included a range of conditions from chronic back pain and being drunk, to going into labour and a suspected stroke.
Two thirds (68) of participants had undertaken some first aid training; 37 had medical training; and 45 had neither. Just under three quarters were aged between 18 and 44.
Almost all participants correctly identified when an ambulance was needed in three out of five scenarios in which such assistance would have been required.
These were: a middle aged man with sudden severe pains in his chest and arm (heart attack); a paracetamol overdose; an older person slurring his words after not having drunk any alcohol (stroke); a road traffic accident victim; a 4 year old with a high temperature and a stiff neck (meningitis).
Nevertheless, one in four did not recognise the need to call an ambulance for a suspected stroke, prompting the authors to comment that the finding is “concerning,” and to question whether the government’s recent stroke awareness campaign (FAST), which was launched in 1999, is working. The understanding of when an ambulance was not needed was not particularly good.
Most participants correctly identified when an ambulance was not needed in only two out of the seven scenarios, and between 5% and 48% would have dialled 999.
The scenarios in which an ambulance was not required were: a woman going into labour; a man with chronic back pain who has run out of painkillers; a drunk man being sick; a 3 year old with piece of Lego stuck in his nose; a single episode of blood in the urine; a toddler with a bruise on his head; and a knife cut on the palm of a hand that is not bleeding heavily.
The Authors said: “All of these scenarios may require medical advice or help, ranging from first aid at home to an urgent emergency department visit, but none requires ambulance attendance.
“It is highly likely that there is confusion between the need for medical treatment and the need for an ambulance.”
They conclude that more widespread first aid training and education on when and how to access emergency care might be useful and could help cut costs from unnecessary ambulance call-outs and ensure that those who do need emergency assistance are responded to promptly.
(BMcN/GK)
The authors base their findings on the responses of 150 people to vignettes of 12 common medical scenarios, seven of which would not require an ambulance to be called.
Respondents were asked whether they would or would not dial 999 for an ambulance, and if not, what other options they would take, such as seeking medical advice from elsewhere, self medication, or doing nothing.
The scenarios included a range of conditions from chronic back pain and being drunk, to going into labour and a suspected stroke.
Two thirds (68) of participants had undertaken some first aid training; 37 had medical training; and 45 had neither. Just under three quarters were aged between 18 and 44.
Almost all participants correctly identified when an ambulance was needed in three out of five scenarios in which such assistance would have been required.
These were: a middle aged man with sudden severe pains in his chest and arm (heart attack); a paracetamol overdose; an older person slurring his words after not having drunk any alcohol (stroke); a road traffic accident victim; a 4 year old with a high temperature and a stiff neck (meningitis).
Nevertheless, one in four did not recognise the need to call an ambulance for a suspected stroke, prompting the authors to comment that the finding is “concerning,” and to question whether the government’s recent stroke awareness campaign (FAST), which was launched in 1999, is working. The understanding of when an ambulance was not needed was not particularly good.
Most participants correctly identified when an ambulance was not needed in only two out of the seven scenarios, and between 5% and 48% would have dialled 999.
The scenarios in which an ambulance was not required were: a woman going into labour; a man with chronic back pain who has run out of painkillers; a drunk man being sick; a 3 year old with piece of Lego stuck in his nose; a single episode of blood in the urine; a toddler with a bruise on his head; and a knife cut on the palm of a hand that is not bleeding heavily.
The Authors said: “All of these scenarios may require medical advice or help, ranging from first aid at home to an urgent emergency department visit, but none requires ambulance attendance.
“It is highly likely that there is confusion between the need for medical treatment and the need for an ambulance.”
They conclude that more widespread first aid training and education on when and how to access emergency care might be useful and could help cut costs from unnecessary ambulance call-outs and ensure that those who do need emergency assistance are responded to promptly.
(BMcN/GK)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
18 December 2008
Ambulance Service Under Pressure As 999 Calls Soar
People are being asked to avoid calling 999 unless it is an emergency, as ambulance services are struggling to cope with outbreaks of illness the cold winter weather has brought.
Ambulance Service Under Pressure As 999 Calls Soar
People are being asked to avoid calling 999 unless it is an emergency, as ambulance services are struggling to cope with outbreaks of illness the cold winter weather has brought.
20 August 2014
Man Dies After Fall From Eastbourne Pier
Essex Police have reported the death of a man who fell from Eastbourne Pier, while carrying out construction work. It is understood that a 44-year-old man from Cumbria was working on the recently fire-damaged pier when he fell to the beach below on Tuesday afternoon.
Man Dies After Fall From Eastbourne Pier
Essex Police have reported the death of a man who fell from Eastbourne Pier, while carrying out construction work. It is understood that a 44-year-old man from Cumbria was working on the recently fire-damaged pier when he fell to the beach below on Tuesday afternoon.
07 August 2014
Prince William To Become Air Ambulance Pilot
Kensington Palace has announced that Prince William is to join the East Anglian Air Ambulance from next spring. The Duke of Cambridge will take on the role of an air ambulance pilot, working both day and night shifts, while also continuing to undertake duties on behalf of the Queen. The Duke is said to be "hugely excited and motivated" by the role.
Prince William To Become Air Ambulance Pilot
Kensington Palace has announced that Prince William is to join the East Anglian Air Ambulance from next spring. The Duke of Cambridge will take on the role of an air ambulance pilot, working both day and night shifts, while also continuing to undertake duties on behalf of the Queen. The Duke is said to be "hugely excited and motivated" by the role.
02 July 2014
Woman Gives Birth In Birmingham City Centre
A woman has given birth to a girl outside a Primark store in Birmingham city centre. Reports say the woman was surrounded by a crowd of people who cheered and showered her with money as paramedics were helping the new mum.
Woman Gives Birth In Birmingham City Centre
A woman has given birth to a girl outside a Primark store in Birmingham city centre. Reports say the woman was surrounded by a crowd of people who cheered and showered her with money as paramedics were helping the new mum.
31 January 2014
Inspectors Find Series of Failures In Private Ambulance Service
Private ambulance service NSL Care Services is facing closure after the Care Quality Commission (CQC) found that it was failing to meet mandatory standards in four out of five areas. Inspectors found a number of failings, including patients experiencing long waits and that some staff had not undergone criminal record checks.
Inspectors Find Series of Failures In Private Ambulance Service
Private ambulance service NSL Care Services is facing closure after the Care Quality Commission (CQC) found that it was failing to meet mandatory standards in four out of five areas. Inspectors found a number of failings, including patients experiencing long waits and that some staff had not undergone criminal record checks.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
