Menu
14/04/2014
Report Says Zero-Hours Contracts 'Should Not Be Used'
An interim report has said that "in the majority of cases" zero-hours contracts should not be used at all.
In the report, published today, the Scottish Affairs Committee has described the increase in zero-hour contracts as "alarming" and say that the government should be using all the levers at its disposal, including legislation, to change this.
The Committee says the Government's consultation on zero hours contracts is too narrow, saying that it is focused on exclusivity and transparency. The Committee says addressing those concerns will do little to help workers who are exploited by unscrupulous employers.
Evidence to the Committee showed:
• 20% of workers on zero hours contracts are paid less than their permanent equivalents doing the same job
• 5% are paid less than the national minimum wage although this is illegal thousands of social care workers are illegally denied payment for time spent travelling between appointments
• 40% receive no notice of employment
• 6% turn up for work – having paid for childcare, travel etc – to find none available
• Thousands of others' employers evade the provision of basic employment rights
• Zero hours workers are entitled to limited employment rights but a significant proportion of employers are either ignorant of those rights or are wilfully blocking access to them.
The Committee describes the Government's suggestion that a low-paid worker can challenge their employer through the courts as "fanciful", as litigation is expensive, the lack of a legal definition of a zero hours contract hinders any legal challenge, and any zero hours worker who embarks on such a challenge may be penalised by the employer.
The Committee says:
• Zero hours contracts must only be used where the employer can objectively justify it
• The Government must do more to protect workers who wish to challenge unfair, unsafe or unlawful conditions of employment
• Workers should be told from the outset of their employment what type of contract they are on and a written contract setting out the terms and conditions must follow within two months
• There should be a minimum notice period of work and workers should not be punished for turning down offers of work made within that period
• Where workers arrive for work but find none available then the employer should compensate them for the inconvenience
• Travel time between appointments should be paid and pay for zero hours workers should accurately reflect the number of hours that are worked to fulfil contracted duties
• An employer-led Code of Practice is unlikely to help workers who are exploited – in fact it may serve to embed a form of employment that in most circumstances is hard to justify
• If a Code is produced it should only be as a stepping stone to, or following, legislative change aimed at reducing the use of zero hours contracts and ensuring workers receive the income, rights and protections to which they are entitled.
Chair of the Committee Ian Davidson MP said: "The overwhelming majority of zero hours contracts are abusive and exploitative and should be abolished. In most cases their use is evidence of sloppy, lazy or incompetent management, who intimidate their workforce by keeping them insecure.
"Zero hours contracts put workers in such a vulnerable position that they are unable even to assert their lawful right to the meagre benefits these contracts offer.
"We heard how workers, without any kind of job security, were fearful of questioning the terms of their employment, even when they knew they were being treated unfairly, and that they were reluctant to challenge unsafe working conditions.
"Many felt that they could not turn down work, no matter how short the notice or however inconvenient the shift offered, in case doing so jeopardised future offers of work.
"Zero hours make blacklisting easy. Our detailed recommendations would improve the operation of zero hours contracts but our overriding conclusion is that, in the majority of cases, zero hours contracts need not and should not be used at all.
"Organisations in the public and private sectors should look first to contracts of employment that offer guaranteed hours and full employment rights.
"We believe the UK and Scottish Governments must use every lever at their disposal to affect a cultural change against exploitative contracts."
This report is an interim one, as it is being timed to contribute to the UK Government's consultation on zero hours.
In the report, published today, the Scottish Affairs Committee has described the increase in zero-hour contracts as "alarming" and say that the government should be using all the levers at its disposal, including legislation, to change this.
The Committee says the Government's consultation on zero hours contracts is too narrow, saying that it is focused on exclusivity and transparency. The Committee says addressing those concerns will do little to help workers who are exploited by unscrupulous employers.
Evidence to the Committee showed:
• 20% of workers on zero hours contracts are paid less than their permanent equivalents doing the same job
• 5% are paid less than the national minimum wage although this is illegal thousands of social care workers are illegally denied payment for time spent travelling between appointments
• 40% receive no notice of employment
• 6% turn up for work – having paid for childcare, travel etc – to find none available
• Thousands of others' employers evade the provision of basic employment rights
• Zero hours workers are entitled to limited employment rights but a significant proportion of employers are either ignorant of those rights or are wilfully blocking access to them.
The Committee describes the Government's suggestion that a low-paid worker can challenge their employer through the courts as "fanciful", as litigation is expensive, the lack of a legal definition of a zero hours contract hinders any legal challenge, and any zero hours worker who embarks on such a challenge may be penalised by the employer.
The Committee says:
• Zero hours contracts must only be used where the employer can objectively justify it
• The Government must do more to protect workers who wish to challenge unfair, unsafe or unlawful conditions of employment
• Workers should be told from the outset of their employment what type of contract they are on and a written contract setting out the terms and conditions must follow within two months
• There should be a minimum notice period of work and workers should not be punished for turning down offers of work made within that period
• Where workers arrive for work but find none available then the employer should compensate them for the inconvenience
• Travel time between appointments should be paid and pay for zero hours workers should accurately reflect the number of hours that are worked to fulfil contracted duties
• An employer-led Code of Practice is unlikely to help workers who are exploited – in fact it may serve to embed a form of employment that in most circumstances is hard to justify
• If a Code is produced it should only be as a stepping stone to, or following, legislative change aimed at reducing the use of zero hours contracts and ensuring workers receive the income, rights and protections to which they are entitled.
Chair of the Committee Ian Davidson MP said: "The overwhelming majority of zero hours contracts are abusive and exploitative and should be abolished. In most cases their use is evidence of sloppy, lazy or incompetent management, who intimidate their workforce by keeping them insecure.
"Zero hours contracts put workers in such a vulnerable position that they are unable even to assert their lawful right to the meagre benefits these contracts offer.
"We heard how workers, without any kind of job security, were fearful of questioning the terms of their employment, even when they knew they were being treated unfairly, and that they were reluctant to challenge unsafe working conditions.
"Many felt that they could not turn down work, no matter how short the notice or however inconvenient the shift offered, in case doing so jeopardised future offers of work.
"Zero hours make blacklisting easy. Our detailed recommendations would improve the operation of zero hours contracts but our overriding conclusion is that, in the majority of cases, zero hours contracts need not and should not be used at all.
"Organisations in the public and private sectors should look first to contracts of employment that offer guaranteed hours and full employment rights.
"We believe the UK and Scottish Governments must use every lever at their disposal to affect a cultural change against exploitative contracts."
This report is an interim one, as it is being timed to contribute to the UK Government's consultation on zero hours.
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
25 June 2014
Union Slams Govt Plans To Ban Exclusivity Clauses On Zero-Hours Contracts
Unite the union has slammed government plans to ban exclusivity clauses in zero hours contracts. The union said the plans "will do nothing" to end the insecurity of zero hours working, and exclusivity clauses will stop an individual from working for another employer.
Union Slams Govt Plans To Ban Exclusivity Clauses On Zero-Hours Contracts
Unite the union has slammed government plans to ban exclusivity clauses in zero hours contracts. The union said the plans "will do nothing" to end the insecurity of zero hours working, and exclusivity clauses will stop an individual from working for another employer.
15 April 2005
Workplace racism is ‘damaging’ careers, TUC claims
Racism in the British workplace is “damaging” the career prospects of many black workers, the Trade Union Congress (TUC) has claimed. The TUC said that black workers get less training opportunities, although they are often better qualified than their white counterparts.
Workplace racism is ‘damaging’ careers, TUC claims
Racism in the British workplace is “damaging” the career prospects of many black workers, the Trade Union Congress (TUC) has claimed. The TUC said that black workers get less training opportunities, although they are often better qualified than their white counterparts.
19 December 2013
Cable Rules Out Ban On Zero-Hours Contracts
A ban on zero-hours contracts has been ruled out by Business Secretary Vince Cable, who has said they offer employers "welcome flexibility". Mr Cable was launching a public consultation on the use of zero-hours contracts, which the secretary has said have a place in the labour markets despite evidence of abuse. The consultation is to last 12 weeks.
Cable Rules Out Ban On Zero-Hours Contracts
A ban on zero-hours contracts has been ruled out by Business Secretary Vince Cable, who has said they offer employers "welcome flexibility". Mr Cable was launching a public consultation on the use of zero-hours contracts, which the secretary has said have a place in the labour markets despite evidence of abuse. The consultation is to last 12 weeks.
24 February 2012
Surge In Older Workers Doing Unpaid Overtime
The proportion of employees in their late 50s and early 60s working unpaid overtime has increased sharply in the last decade - despite a fall in unpaid hours for the rest of the workforce - according to a new TUC analysis published today to mark Work Your Proper Hours Day.
Surge In Older Workers Doing Unpaid Overtime
The proportion of employees in their late 50s and early 60s working unpaid overtime has increased sharply in the last decade - despite a fall in unpaid hours for the rest of the workforce - according to a new TUC analysis published today to mark Work Your Proper Hours Day.
16 October 2013
Royal Mail Workers Balloted Over National Strike Action
Royal Mail could face its first national strike in almost four years, as the Communication Workers Union hold a ballot over action in a dispute over workers terms and condition at the newly privatised company.
Royal Mail Workers Balloted Over National Strike Action
Royal Mail could face its first national strike in almost four years, as the Communication Workers Union hold a ballot over action in a dispute over workers terms and condition at the newly privatised company.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
