Menu
08/03/2013
Bill Amendment On Abortion Is Wrong - Ford
Justice Minister David Ford has said it is wrong to use the Criminal Justice Bill to regulate abortion in Northern Ireland.
The move comes as three MLAs from the Stormont justice committee, the DUP's Paul Givan and the SDLP's Alban Maginness, backed by the UUP's Tom Elliott, seek to amend the bill so abortions may only be carried out by the NHS.
The decision follows controversy over the Marie Stopes clinic, which was opened in Belfast in October of last year.
The private clinic said it would only operate within the strict legal framework in Northern Ireland, which states that a woman may only have an abortion if her health is at risk.
This remark was reiterated at the time by Health Minister Edwin Poots, but pro-life protesters and campaigners have been pushing to prevent the clinic from operating.
Now, as three MLAs attempt to push through amendments to the Criminal Justic Bill, Mr Ford has said: "I agree that the Assembly needs to address the regulation of abortion by private providers. I understand the Health Minister has been considering how best this can be achieved and has undertaken to come back to the Assembly.
"But it is a fundamental principle of devolution that laws should be fully examined and consulted on. Tacking on a last-minute amendment to the Criminal Justice Bill is not the way to deal with this issue. It requires full consideration and consultation to ensure all viewpoints are aired and considered, especially from people directly impacted."
He continued: "I believe that the wording of the amendment could lead to overlapping offences and would cause confusion in an area where clarity is needed. Potentially, it could also criminalise certain forms of contraception and it would be liable to be challenged in the courts."
Sinn Féin has also opposed the amendment.
The party's South Down MLA Caitriona Ruane said: "This is bad law - it's not a good way to be doing law - tagging it on to the end of a criminal justice bill."
"This is a health matter. Sinn Féin will be opposing it and we are in discussions around how we will do that."
She told the BBC she was concerned that it was men who were bringing forward the amendment.
"I wonder did those men...consult with the women in their parties. Really what we need to do is ensure women's lives are protected," she remarked.
(IT)
The move comes as three MLAs from the Stormont justice committee, the DUP's Paul Givan and the SDLP's Alban Maginness, backed by the UUP's Tom Elliott, seek to amend the bill so abortions may only be carried out by the NHS.
The decision follows controversy over the Marie Stopes clinic, which was opened in Belfast in October of last year.
The private clinic said it would only operate within the strict legal framework in Northern Ireland, which states that a woman may only have an abortion if her health is at risk.
This remark was reiterated at the time by Health Minister Edwin Poots, but pro-life protesters and campaigners have been pushing to prevent the clinic from operating.
Now, as three MLAs attempt to push through amendments to the Criminal Justic Bill, Mr Ford has said: "I agree that the Assembly needs to address the regulation of abortion by private providers. I understand the Health Minister has been considering how best this can be achieved and has undertaken to come back to the Assembly.
"But it is a fundamental principle of devolution that laws should be fully examined and consulted on. Tacking on a last-minute amendment to the Criminal Justice Bill is not the way to deal with this issue. It requires full consideration and consultation to ensure all viewpoints are aired and considered, especially from people directly impacted."
He continued: "I believe that the wording of the amendment could lead to overlapping offences and would cause confusion in an area where clarity is needed. Potentially, it could also criminalise certain forms of contraception and it would be liable to be challenged in the courts."
Sinn Féin has also opposed the amendment.
The party's South Down MLA Caitriona Ruane said: "This is bad law - it's not a good way to be doing law - tagging it on to the end of a criminal justice bill."
"This is a health matter. Sinn Féin will be opposing it and we are in discussions around how we will do that."
She told the BBC she was concerned that it was men who were bringing forward the amendment.
"I wonder did those men...consult with the women in their parties. Really what we need to do is ensure women's lives are protected," she remarked.
(IT)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
01 March 2013
Abortion Vote Debate Could Be Delayed
The vote on a new law preventing private clinics in NI to carry out abortions may be delayed. Stormont were due to debate the amendment to the criminal justice bill next Tuesday, but justice minister David Ford has asked for a postponement. Ford wants to postpone the debate until 12 March over an unrelated matter.
Abortion Vote Debate Could Be Delayed
The vote on a new law preventing private clinics in NI to carry out abortions may be delayed. Stormont were due to debate the amendment to the criminal justice bill next Tuesday, but justice minister David Ford has asked for a postponement. Ford wants to postpone the debate until 12 March over an unrelated matter.
19 November 2024
Justice Minister Announces Additional Funding For Department
Justice Minister Naomi Long has welcomed the allocation of an additional £39.3 million to the Department of Justice following the October Monitoring Round. This funding will be used to address various pressures within the justice system, including those arising from the civil disorder during the summer.
Justice Minister Announces Additional Funding For Department
Justice Minister Naomi Long has welcomed the allocation of an additional £39.3 million to the Department of Justice following the October Monitoring Round. This funding will be used to address various pressures within the justice system, including those arising from the civil disorder during the summer.
18 October 2010
Justice Bill Seeks Better Deal For Victims
For the first time in four decades, a new Justice Bill has been published in Northern Ireland.
Justice Bill Seeks Better Deal For Victims
For the first time in four decades, a new Justice Bill has been published in Northern Ireland.
24 January 2024
SDLP Proposes Amendment To Executive Formation Bill
The SDLP has said that it will seek to amend proposed legislation extending the deadline for the formation of an Executive after the previous deadline passed last week.
SDLP Proposes Amendment To Executive Formation Bill
The SDLP has said that it will seek to amend proposed legislation extending the deadline for the formation of an Executive after the previous deadline passed last week.
18 July 2023
Key Vote Upcoming For Troubles Legacy Bill
The Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Bill is set to be discussed in the Commons again ahead of a vote on potential amendments to the bill. Peers had backed an amendment to the bill preventing a person from requesting immunity from prosecution as part of any future investigation.
Key Vote Upcoming For Troubles Legacy Bill
The Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Bill is set to be discussed in the Commons again ahead of a vote on potential amendments to the bill. Peers had backed an amendment to the bill preventing a person from requesting immunity from prosecution as part of any future investigation.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A showery start with outbreaks most frequent north of Lough Neagh and through the morning, before dwindling during the afternoon as the northwest breezes ease and brighter spells of weak sunshine prosper. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
