Menu
11/03/2005
US and UK governments criticised over Iraqi death count
The British and American governments have been criticised over their failure to establish a count of civilian deaths in Iraq.
A group of international health experts told the British Medical Journal (BMJ) that the British government had relied on figures from Iraq's Ministry of Health. They said this was "unacceptable" because the figures did not take into account deaths during the first twelve months of the US-led invasion of Iraq, only included violent deaths that were reported and did not allow for "reliable attribution" between different causes of death and injury.
The group, which included experts from the UK, US, Canada, Spain, Italy and Australia, said that the policy of both the US and UK governments had been "wholly irresponsible" and called for an independent inquiry into war-related casualties in Iraq.
Research conducted by the Lancet suggested that Iraq had suffered around 100,000 excess deaths since the 2003 invasion. However, it was reported that the government had rejected the survey as "unreliable".
According to reports, the figures used by the Foreign Office put the number of Iraqi civilians killed between April and December 2004 at 5,144. The Iraq Body Count, an independent database, puts the death toll somewhere between 16,231 and 18,509 from the beginning of the war in March 2003.
A Foreign Office spokesman told the BMJ that they believed the Iraqi Ministry of Health figures were "the best available in an uncertain situation". The spokesman added, "in the current security climate, more accurate research is not feasible."
The experts have called for a large, scientifically independent study in order to "remove uncertainties that remain". However, both the British and American governments have said that they were not legally obliged to count civilian casualties.
Professor Klim McPherson, public health epidemiologist at Oxford University told the BMJ: "Basically this is a response to the government's continuing procrastination. Counting casualties can help to save lives both now and in the future - we have waited too long for this information."
(KMcA/SP)
A group of international health experts told the British Medical Journal (BMJ) that the British government had relied on figures from Iraq's Ministry of Health. They said this was "unacceptable" because the figures did not take into account deaths during the first twelve months of the US-led invasion of Iraq, only included violent deaths that were reported and did not allow for "reliable attribution" between different causes of death and injury.
The group, which included experts from the UK, US, Canada, Spain, Italy and Australia, said that the policy of both the US and UK governments had been "wholly irresponsible" and called for an independent inquiry into war-related casualties in Iraq.
Research conducted by the Lancet suggested that Iraq had suffered around 100,000 excess deaths since the 2003 invasion. However, it was reported that the government had rejected the survey as "unreliable".
According to reports, the figures used by the Foreign Office put the number of Iraqi civilians killed between April and December 2004 at 5,144. The Iraq Body Count, an independent database, puts the death toll somewhere between 16,231 and 18,509 from the beginning of the war in March 2003.
A Foreign Office spokesman told the BMJ that they believed the Iraqi Ministry of Health figures were "the best available in an uncertain situation". The spokesman added, "in the current security climate, more accurate research is not feasible."
The experts have called for a large, scientifically independent study in order to "remove uncertainties that remain". However, both the British and American governments have said that they were not legally obliged to count civilian casualties.
Professor Klim McPherson, public health epidemiologist at Oxford University told the BMJ: "Basically this is a response to the government's continuing procrastination. Counting casualties can help to save lives both now and in the future - we have waited too long for this information."
(KMcA/SP)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
20 January 2005
Foreign Office to issue death certificates for tsunami missing
The Foreign Office has confirmed that it will issue death certificates for British nationals missing, presumed dead, in the Boxing Day tsunami disaster.
Foreign Office to issue death certificates for tsunami missing
The Foreign Office has confirmed that it will issue death certificates for British nationals missing, presumed dead, in the Boxing Day tsunami disaster.
16 July 2013
Experts Sent In To Oversee Hospital Reforms
The government have announced special measures are being taken against 11 hospitals over "major failings". The hospitals were among 14 investigated over high death rates, with health secretary Jeremy Hunt saying that the 11 highlightes had "problems so entrenched that tough action was needed.
Experts Sent In To Oversee Hospital Reforms
The government have announced special measures are being taken against 11 hospitals over "major failings". The hospitals were among 14 investigated over high death rates, with health secretary Jeremy Hunt saying that the 11 highlightes had "problems so entrenched that tough action was needed.
19 July 2004
British soldier dies in Basrah helicopter crash
A British soldier has died after an RAF helicopter crashed in southern Iraq today. The MoD confirmed that the soldier was killed in "an accident" involving an RAF Puma helicopter at Basrah International Airport. Two other British military personnel were injured during the incident.
British soldier dies in Basrah helicopter crash
A British soldier has died after an RAF helicopter crashed in southern Iraq today. The MoD confirmed that the soldier was killed in "an accident" involving an RAF Puma helicopter at Basrah International Airport. Two other British military personnel were injured during the incident.
20 August 2012
Gu Kailai Given Suspended Death Sentence For Niel Heywood Murder
Gu Kailai, the wife of disgraced Chinese politician Bo Xilai, has been jailed for the murder of British businessman Neil Heywood. Gu was found guilty of poisoning Mr Heywood on November 2011, she did not contest the charge at her one-day trial and received a suspended death sentence.
Gu Kailai Given Suspended Death Sentence For Niel Heywood Murder
Gu Kailai, the wife of disgraced Chinese politician Bo Xilai, has been jailed for the murder of British businessman Neil Heywood. Gu was found guilty of poisoning Mr Heywood on November 2011, she did not contest the charge at her one-day trial and received a suspended death sentence.
12 September 2014
15-Year-Old Arrested After 60 Dogs Killed In Fire
At least 60 dogs have been killed in a fire at a dogs home in Manchester, which is believed to have been started deliberately. A 15-year-old boy has been arrested on suspicion of arson after a fire was started at Manchester Dogs' Home in Moss Brook Road, Harpurhey, on Thursday.
15-Year-Old Arrested After 60 Dogs Killed In Fire
At least 60 dogs have been killed in a fire at a dogs home in Manchester, which is believed to have been started deliberately. A 15-year-old boy has been arrested on suspicion of arson after a fire was started at Manchester Dogs' Home in Moss Brook Road, Harpurhey, on Thursday.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherThis Evening and Tonight:A dry night, save for a few light showers around the coasts, with prolonged clear spells and light winds bringing a frosty dawn for many in central and southern parts. Minimum temperature -3 °C.
